Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Check my work, embarrass me on a §220.84 load calc

User: brycenesbitt, Location: United States

Asked on: Friday, October 17, 2025 at 12:02 am EDT
Answered on: Friday, October 17, 2025 at 12:02 am EDT

Question: I need to do a load calculation for a multifamily building I can't examine the actual stuff in. So I need reasonable defaults, even thoughthey can not practically be checked. How'd I do?See any issues?Do I derate the baseboard heaters once per unit THEN again for load diversity, as shown?(The baseboard heating is part of what I'm unsure of (I wish it were watts per square foot of floor area making it easier to compute and less random))Building 7Bedsft ²HeatLaundryCoolingRangeDisposalH2OD/WExtra§220.84 Load Calculation12920✓--✓✓✓✓20.32VA84.67A22920✓--✓✓✓✓20.32VA84.67A32920✓-✓✓✓✓✓21.28VA88.67A42920✓--✓✓✓✓20.32VA84.67A52920✓✓-✓✓✓✓24.16VA100.67A62920✓--✓✓✓✓20.32VA84.67A72920✓--✓✓✓✓20.32VA84.67A82920✓--✓✓✓✓21.28VA88.67ACommon-100-2-----240017.00VA70.83AConstructed1986Raw sum185.32VA772.17AAfter 43% demand factor for 8 units79.69VA332.03ANet load with power managed EV (no change)79.69VA332.03ALoadName-platederateCountLoad Diversity 220.84(B)Heat960065%VABaseboard heaters, quantity less than 4345Laundry9600VA40A electric dryer644Cooling2400VAMinisplit843Range8000VATypical range1132Disposal2400VATypical disposal1241H2O7200VA30A resistance tank water heater1440Dishwasher3600VATypical dishwasher1639Kitchen3000VAFixed value from 220.84(C)(2)1838

Okay, let's break down this load calculation and identify potential issues and refinements.

Overall Structure and Approach

The table format is good for visualizing the load contributions from each unit. Applying a demand factor to account for diversity is a standard practice.

Key Concerns and Questions


Baseboard Heater Derating and Diversity

This is the most significant concern. You're derating the baseboard heaters before applying the diversity factor. This is generally

incorrect
. Here's why: Derating Purpose

The 65% derating on the baseboard heaters suggests you're applying a
continuous load derating. This is used for loads that are expected to run for 3 hours or more continuously. While baseboard heaters can run for extended periods, it's not guaranteed. Unless you have strong evidence that they will run for 3+ hours, it's safer to not apply this initial derating.

Diversity Purpose

The 43% demand factor already accounts for the fact that not all units will be using their baseboard heaters at the same time and at full capacity. You are essentially double-counting a reduction for the heater.

Recommendation

Remove the initial 65% derating on the baseboard heaters. Use the full nameplate VA of the heaters before applying the demand factor.2.

Baseboard Heater Wattage Guess

You said you wish it were based on sq feet, but why didn't you do that?

Recommendation

Find data on regional climate norms, and assume a BTU/square foot load. Then do the math to convert to VA at 240 VAC, and go that route. You'll be more comfortable with a watts-per-square-foot model and it's as valid as the number you're using now.3.

Cooling Load (Minisplit)

2400VA seems low for cooling on a space this size, I would consider checking if there's some regulation or norm that can give you a different number.4.

Laundry Load

9600 VA seems really high! Modern dryers don't typically use that much.

Recommendation

Research typical dryer VA ratings. 5000-6000 VA is a more realistic range. You can get numbers off of typical modern appliance tags.5.

Dishwasher Load

3600 VA also seems a little high.

Recommendation

Similar to the dryer, research typical dishwasher VA ratings, modern ones, and use a more accurate value.6.

Kitchen Fixed Value

3000 VA is the recommended baseline, but it's unlikely to be the only thing.

Recommendation

Consider the additional small appliance circuits required in the kitchen and add them to the calculation. Also, if there's any other equipment known in advance, add it to the calculation.7.

Common Area Load

17kVA at 71 amps. This is pretty high! What is this for? What exactly are you planning for this? Common area lighting? Hallway heaters? Elevator? This needs to be broken down and justified. The total might be correct, but you need to enumerate components.

Recommendation

Break down the common area load into specific components with estimated VA ratings. This provides transparency and makes the calculation easier to defend.8.

Demand Factor (43%)

Where did this 43% demand factor come from? It's not inherently wrong, but you need to be able to justify it. Refer to the NEC, local codes, or engineering guidelines that support this value for this type of building and occupancy.

Recommendation

Provide the code reference or engineering basis for the 43% demand factor.9.

§220.84

You're referencing this section, which is good, but be sure you are applying the entire section correctly, including all applicable notes and exceptions. This section offers multiple methods and considerations.10.

EV Load Management

The note "Net load with power managed EV (no change)" raises questions. Are you sure the EV load management is completely negating any impact on the calculated load? EV charging, even with management, typically adds some load.

Recommendation

Document the specifics of the EV load management system and demonstrate how it prevents any increase in the calculated load. If it does add load, even a reduced amount, include it in the calculation.

Revised Example Snippet (Illustrative - Adjust based on your research)

Here's how the corrected approach would look (using realistic estimated values):LoadName-plate derateCountLoad Diversity 220.84(B)Heat9600VA1Baseboard heaters, quantity less than 49600Laundry6000VA140A electric dryer6000Cooling2400VAMinisplit2400Range8000VATypical range8000Disposal2400VATypical disposal2400H2O7200VA30A resistance tank water heater7200Dishwasher3000VATypical dishwasher3000Kitchen3000VAFixed value from 220.84(C)(2)3000

Workflow Recommendations


Research Appliance VA Ratings

Use online appliance retailers' specs sheets for modern appliances.2.

Document Everything

Keep a clear record of all assumptions, sources, and calculations.3.

Consult Local Codes

Ensure your load calculation meets all local electrical codes and utility requirements.4.

Consider Future Loads

Think about potential future loads (e.g., additional appliances, electric vehicle charging) and factor them into your calculation.5.

Engage an Engineer:
For a building of this size, it's highly recommended to have a licensed electrical engineer review and stamp your load calculation, especially since you can't physically inspect the premises.By addressing these points and refining your assumptions, you'll create a more accurate and defensible load calculation. Remember that this is a critical step for the safe and reliable operation of the building's electrical system. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question