User: DustyGmt, Location: Vermont
Asked on: Friday, October 17, 2025 at 12:35 pm EDT
Answered on: Friday, October 17, 2025 at 12:35 pm EDT
Question: New member as well as a new electrician, I finished my 4th year of electrical school a few years ago and am working on my own here and there and troubleshooting these kinds of things are not a strength. I guess ill just outline the problem as best I can.Lady called and said she has 4 nest thermostats that arent working and the hydronic baseboard heaters arent coming on. First thing i did when I got here was pulled one of the dead nest T stats and plugged it into a micro USB to recharge it and then took a voltage reading on the Red and White wires, I was only getting 4V between the red and white at each of the 4 locations. I then went to the Taco box and tested the Line voltage and had 120v, then I tested each of the two transformers and was getting 27V, then I tested Zones 1-4 and was getting the 4V (no surprise) but Zone 6 which does the Hot Water Heater was reading out at 27V between the red and white and that is working properly. There are two transformers in this Taco Box and 2-5A Fuses and I tested those as well and they are working.I then pulled all of the thermostats off the walls and went back to the taco box and started getting 9v on the red and white zones 1-4. I took the wires off zones 1-3 and was getting a reading of 13V on Zone 4. I apologize if this is scattershot, I'm certain my lack of experience troubleshooting Low Voltage controls is really showing here but just trying to walk you through my probably somewhat misguided process. Also turned the circuit off and put my meter on the Continuity Tone function and rang out each R/W Zones 1-6 and the only Zone having Continuity was Zone 6, the only Zone getting proper voltage and working properly.Sorry for the giant wall of text, I'm out of my depth here and am ready to punt it to someone more qualified but its kind of eating at me that I cant figure this out, I want to become more skilled at troubleshooting these things but I'm inclined to believe that this may be a bad control box or maybe somewhere in this ugly rats nest of LowV wires there is a problem but it was working fine last winter so I'm not sure. Any tips or help from an old pro would be appreciated. Thanks. -Dusty
Okay Dusty, no worries, we'll walk through this systematically. It's good you're trying to learn and tackle the problem. Low voltage can be tricky, but breaking it down will help. Your instincts about a bad control box or a short somewhere are good starting points.Here's a step-by-step troubleshooting approach, incorporating your initial findings and suggesting further investigation
1. Understanding the System (Hydronic Baseboard with Taco Zone Valves and Nest Thermostats):
Hydronic Baseboard
Hot water circulates through baseboard radiators.
Taco Zone Valves
These valves control the flow of hot water to each zone (area) based on thermostat demand. They are typically 24V powered.
Taco Control Box (Relay)
This box receives signals from the thermostats (low voltage) and controls the circulator pump (line voltage) and the zone valves. It also usually houses the 24V transformers.
Nest Thermostats
These thermostats need 24V power from the Taco system (typically R and C wires) to operate.
2. Reviewing Your Initial Findings
Low Voltage at Thermostat Locations (4V initially, then rising to 9-13V when thermostats were removed)
This is the KEY symptom. It indicates a problem with the 24V power supply to the thermostats or a voltage drop due to a load issue.
Good Line Voltage to Taco Box (120V)
This confirms the box is receiving power.
Transformers Outputting 27V
Good! The transformers are working, but the voltage isn't making it to the thermostat wires properly.
Zone 6 (Hot Water Heater) Working Correctly (27V)
This confirms the transformer and control box can deliver proper voltage to a zone. It isolates the problem to zones 1-4 and their circuitry.
Continuity Only on Zone 6 (Working Zone)
This, combined with the low voltage on the other zones, strongly suggests a short or low-resistance path to ground somewhere in Zones 1-4.
3. Systematic Troubleshooting Steps
a) Isolate the Problem
Disconnect All Thermostat Wires at the Taco Box
Completely remove the R and W wires for ALL thermostats (zones 1-4) from the Taco control box. This isolates the thermostat wiring from the control box itself.
Measure Voltage at Taco Box Terminals (Zones 1-4)
With all thermostat wires disconnected, measure the voltage between the R and W terminals for Zones 1-4 at the Taco box.
If you now get a stable 24V-27V on all zones
The problem is in the thermostat wiring, the thermostats themselves, or the wiring between the Taco box and the thermostats. Continue to step (b).
If you still get low voltage (around 4V) on Zones 1-4 with the thermostat wires disconnected
The problem is most likely within the Taco control box itself. One of the zone relays might be damaged or stuck. Skip to step (d)
b) Thermostat Wiring/Thermostat Check (Assuming you got 24-27V in step (a))
Check for Shorts in Thermostat Wiring
Power off the circuit. Disconnect the R and W wires at one thermostat location (say, Zone 1). Using your multimeter on continuity/tone mode, check for a short between: R and W wires R wire and ground W wire and ground Repeat this process at each thermostat location (Zones 2, 3, and 4). Look for any wiring damage, staples piercing the wires, or loose connections that might be causing a short.
Inspect Thermostat Wiring Terminals
Carefully inspect the terminals on the back of each Nest thermostat. Look for corrosion, loose wires, or wires touching each other. Make sure the wires are securely connected.
Test the Nest Thermostats Individually
Disconnect the thermostat from the wall. Bring ONE of the Nests to the Taco box. Temporarily wire the R and W wires directly to the Zone 1 terminals on the Taco box. (Remember, make sure you're getting 24-27V at the Taco box with the thermostat wires disconnected.) Observe if the zone valve for Zone 1 activates. Repeat this process for each Nest thermostat, testing it on Zone 1 terminals. This helps isolate if one of the Nests is faulty and pulling down the voltage.
c) Wiring from Taco Box to Thermostats (If no shorts are found and Nests seem okay)
Check Wire Runs for Damage
Carefully inspect the entire length of the thermostat wiring from the Taco box to each thermostat location. Look for damage, staples through the wires, rodent damage, or anything that could cause a short. This might involve opening up walls or ceilings, so proceed with caution and with the homeowner's permission.
Consider New Wire Runs
If the wiring is old or damaged, the easiest solution might be to run new thermostat wires. Use thermostat wire specifically rated for low-voltage applications (18/2 or 18/3 stranded wire).
d) Taco Control Box Diagnosis (If low voltage persists at the Taco box with all thermostat wires disconnected)
Inspect the Relays
Carefully examine the relays on the Taco control box (the small, rectangular components). Look for signs of burning, discoloration, or physical damage. A faulty relay might be shorting out the 24V power supply.
Swap Relays (Advanced)
If the relays are the same type, you could carefully swap the relay for the known-good Zone 6 with one of the other zones (e.g., Zone 1) to see if the problem moves. However, if you're not comfortable doing this, or if the relays are different types, DO NOT DO THIS. You could damage the control box.
Consider Replacing the Taco Control Box
If you suspect a faulty relay or internal control board issue, the easiest solution is often to replace the entire Taco control box. Make sure to get a compatible replacement model.
4. Key Considerations and Safety
Safety First
Always turn off the power to the circuit breaker feeding the Taco control box before working on any of the wiring.
Label Everything
Before disconnecting any wires, label them clearly so you can easily reconnect them correctly. Take pictures!
Wiring Diagrams
If available, consult the wiring diagrams for the Taco control box and the Nest thermostats. These can be invaluable for understanding the system.
Homeowner Communication
Keep the homeowner informed of your progress and any potential costs for replacement parts or additional labor.
5. Specific Thoughts Based on Your Information
Continuity on Zone 6
This is interesting and suggests a possible design difference or perhaps a feature of Zone 6. It is NOT necessarily a problem, since it's working.
Voltage Rising When Thermostats Are Removed
This is a CLASSIC symptom of a load problem. The 24V power supply is weak, and the thermostats are drawing too much current (due to a short or other issue) when connected.
Old Wiring
Given that the system was working fine last winter, a rodent chewing on the wire is always possible.
In summary:Based on your troubleshooting so far, my strongest* suspicion is a short in the thermostat wiring or a faulty thermostat on Zones 1-4. The low voltage readings and the increase in voltage when thermostats are disconnected point to this. The continuity test reinforces this idea. Systematically checking each wire run and each thermostat for shorts is the next step.I hope this helps! Don't get discouraged; troubleshooting is a skill that develops over time. By being methodical and understanding the system, you'll get there. Flag for review