User: CurSol1!, Location: Boston
Asked on: Saturday, October 18, 2025 at 8:36 am EDT
Answered on: Saturday, October 18, 2025 at 9:10 am EDT
Question: Here's a good head scratcher for you guys and gals.....I've been in the trade for over 40-yrs now and yet I cannot figure out how you can test to see if a live conductor that is nicked by a screw in a conduit and could be leaking to ground but yet not bad enough to trip a breaker.One of our customers had a very large rubber roof (50,00SF) where the roofer has penetrated many conduits with their 6" rubber roofing screws.My guys found a few in just the first look. We usually provide insulation resistance test reports using our meggars but always on de-energized circuits.When this building was originally built, our code did not address conduits above bar joists and in the corrugated metal pan roofing and of course in this case, there could be upwards of at least thousands of screws, 50 or more conduit runs with hundreds of live circuits.To make matters worse, we do not have as-builts to help us determine where all the branch circuits go and what are connected to them, so now that just by pulling the conductor off the breaker and inducing upwards of 1000V into the conductor with our meggar is going to result in countless printers, computer, tv's damage and who knows what..... so with that said:Is there any way to test a live conductor's insulation resistance value (leakage to conduit/ground) with unknown loads on that conductor's circuit?Playing the devil's advocate and hoping for some valued input:If we turn off the breaker, could we read the resistance value from conductor to conduit? Whatever is plugged into that circuit is probably going to provide bad readings though, correct?Do you think that if we data log amperage we may find some anomalies? Motor start or any load turned on is going to blow that theory.Talk about a needle in a haystack, I told our customer to initiate an insurance claim against roofing company because a dead short could happen now or it can happen in a year if you have a nicked wire and the roof heats up or the insulation breaks down over time, you'll then get that fault. I feel bad for our customer, but we are at a stand-still as to how we can attack and dig into this one...Norman
Norman, this is a truly challenging situation, and I understand your frustration after 40 years in the trade. You're facing a complex problem with high stakes. Here's a breakdown of the challenges and some potential approaches, along with their limitations
The Core Problem:
Nicked Conductors, Not Shorts
You're looking for small insulation faults (leaks to ground) before they become full-blown short circuits. This is far harder to detect.
Live Circuits with Unknown Loads
The unknown and varying loads connected to these circuits make standard testing very difficult.
Scale
The sheer number of potential fault locations (screws, conduit runs, circuits) is overwhelming.
Lack of As-Builts
Makes tracing circuits and isolating potential problems extremely difficult.
Potential for Damage
De-energizing and Meggering is risky due to sensitive equipment connected to the circuits.
Why Standard Methods Don't Work (Well)
Megger (Insulation Resistance Test)
As you pointed out, Meggering a de-energized circuit should find the fault, but the connected loads will create parallel paths, significantly lowering the resistance reading and making it impossible to isolate the nicked wire. You also risk damaging sensitive equipment. Plus, on a live circuit, this is obviously a non-starter.
Voltage Drop Tests
Voltage drop tests are designed to identify issues related to high loads or undersized conductors. Finding small leakage currents is not possible.
Simple Continuity Tests
Continuity tests won't find a high-resistance leak to ground.
GFCI Breakers
A 5mA leakage is required to trip a standard GFCI breaker, your fault may be much lower than that, so it may not even trip.
Potential Approaches (with their drawbacks)
Infrared Thermography (IR Scanning)
Theory
If a small current is leaking to ground through a nicked conductor, it might generate a small amount of heat in the conduit near the screw. An IR camera could potentially detect this.
Pros
Non-destructive, can be done on live circuits, can cover a large area relatively quickly.
Cons
Sensitivity
The heat generated by a small leakage current might be too small to detect, especially with ambient temperature variations and roof conditions (sun, wind). The metal roof itself will conduct heat making it even more difficult.
Interpretation
Even if you find a hot spot, it could be due to other factors (solar heating, nearby equipment). Requires careful analysis and verification.
Cost of High-Quality IR Equipment
You'd need a sensitive, high-resolution IR camera to maximize your chances of success.
Surface Conditions
Dirt, rust, or uneven surfaces on the conduit could affect readings.2.
High-Sensitivity Clamp Meter (Leakage Current Measurement)
Theory
Use a very sensitive clamp meter (designed for measuring leakage current, down to microamps) around individual conduit runs. A significant leakage current reading could indicate a fault somewhere along that conduit run.
Pros
Can be done on live circuits. Relatively inexpensive equipment.
Cons
Ground Loops and Noise
Stray currents in the grounding system can make it difficult to isolate the specific leakage current from a fault. You're measuring everything returning to the source.
Unknown Loads
Some leakage current is normal in electronic equipment (capacitive coupling). Distinguishing normal leakage from fault leakage can be tough.
Difficulty Isolating the Exact Location
Even if you find a conduit run with high leakage, you still need to pinpoint the screw.
Sensitivity
The magnitude of the leakage current needs to be sufficient to be detected. A very small leak could be missed.3.
Time-Domain Reflectometry (TDR)
Theory
TDR sends a signal down the conductor and analyzes reflections. A fault in the insulation might cause a reflection. This is more commonly used for locating faults in cables, but potentially could be used on long conduit runs.
Pros
Potentially can pinpoint the location of the fault along the conductor.
Cons
Complexity
TDR equipment is specialized and requires training to use and interpret the results.
Cost
TDR equipment can be expensive.
May not be effective
The TDR may not be able to see such a low resistance leakage, or may see reflections from all sorts of sources.4.
Circuit Tracing with Tone Generator
Theory
Use a circuit tracer to identify the path of each circuit. This can help you narrow down the potential areas where screws may have penetrated conduits.
Pros
Helps map out the electrical system, which is valuable in the long run.
Cons
Still doesn't pinpoint the fault location. Requires de-energizing circuits. Can be time-consuming.5.
Focused Visual Inspection (After Narrowing Down)
Theory
After using one or more of the above methods to narrow down the problem area, conduct a very careful visual inspection of the conduit and screws in that area.
Pros
Direct observation of the fault.
Cons
Labor-intensive. Requires access to the roof and close examination of potentially hundreds of screws.6.
Sectional De-Energizing and Testing
Theory
De-energize sections of the electrical system (carefully documenting what is being de-energized), then use a Megger or similar instrument to test the insulation resistance of the de-energized sections. This helps to isolate the problem to a specific area.
Pros
More accurate than testing the entire system at once.
Cons
Requires significant downtime, coordination, and documentation. Still risks damaging sensitive equipment if not done carefully.
A Phased Approach
Given the challenges, here's a suggested approach:1.
Document Everything
Start meticulously documenting everything you do. This is crucial for tracking progress and avoiding mistakes.2.
Prioritize
Focus on the most critical circuits first (e.g., those serving life safety equipment, critical processes).3.
Infrared Scan (Initial Assessment)
Perform a comprehensive IR scan of the roof, paying close attention to conduit runs. Document any hotspots.4.
Leakage Current Measurement (Targeted)
For conduit runs identified as potential problem areas by the IR scan, use a high-sensitivity clamp meter to measure leakage current.5.
Circuit Tracing
If possible, trace circuits to determine their path and identify potential areas of concern.6.
Focused Visual Inspection
Carefully examine the screws and conduit in areas identified as high-risk by the previous steps.7.
Sectional De-Energizing and Testing (Last Resort)
If the above steps don't yield results, consider sectional de-energizing and testing, but only after careful planning and risk assessment.8.
Insurance Claim (Continued Support)
Continue to advise the customer to pursue an insurance claim against the roofing company.
Important Considerations
Safety
Always prioritize safety. Work with qualified electricians and follow all applicable safety procedures.
Communication
Keep the customer informed of your progress and the challenges you're facing.
Liability
Be careful not to assume responsibility for the roofing company's negligence. Focus on providing your professional assessment and recommendations.
Cost
Clearly communicate the costs associated with each testing method.
Final Thoughts:
This is a difficult situation with no easy answers. The best approach is likely a combination of methods, starting with the least intrusive and progressing to more invasive techniques as needed. Meticulous documentation, careful planning, and clear communication are essential for success. Your customer will have to accept the costs associated with these steps, and the potential that you may not find all of the nicked wires, but rather mitigate the amount you can find in the allotted time.Good luck, Norman. I hope this helps! Flag for review