User: LaserSurgeon, Location: Nashville
Asked on: Monday, October 20, 2025 at 7:35 pm EDT
Answered on: Monday, October 20, 2025 at 7:38 pm EDT
Question: I have an electric hot water heater (State PCE40-2LS) that has been upgraded to 2 6000W elements (12kW)It is wired to run on 3 Phase, unbalanced, 240 V, SIMULTANEOUS.I can not find a MOCP rating on the heater or the manufacturers website in a spec sheet.I have a 3 pole, 60 Amp breaker going to it.Am I good to go with either #8 or #6 copper; or should I downsize to a 50 Amp breaker?TY,Steven
Okay, Steven, let's break down the electrical calculations for your modified water heater and address your questions about wire sizing and breaker protection.
Important Considerations Before We Proceed
Local Codes are King
The following information is for educational purposes only and based on general electrical principles. You MUST comply with your local electrical codes and ordinances. Local codes can be more restrictive than the National Electrical Code (NEC). It is highly recommended to have a qualified electrician perform the installation.
Manufacturer Approval
Modifying equipment beyond its original design can have serious safety and warranty implications. Check with State Water Heaters or a qualified HVAC professional about the permissibility of the upgrade.
Unbalanced 3-Phase
This is a critical detail. An unbalanced load significantly complicates the calculations and can lead to voltage imbalances and equipment damage if not handled correctly.
Simultaneous Operation
Operating both elements at the same time is a very high load for a residential setting and can potentially overload your electrical service.
Calculations & Analysis1. Current Calculation (Per Phase)
Total Power: 12,000 Watts (6000W x 2 elements) Since this is unbalanced, the only way that both elements are operating simultaneously is if two legs are each providing 6000W Voltage (Line-to-Neutral, estimated): 240V / sqrt(3) = ~138.6V Current per phase: 6000W / 138.6V = 43.3 Amps (Per phase supplying 6000W)2.
MOCP (Minimum Overcurrent Protection) Determination
Crucial Information Missing
Typically, the MOCP is specified on the equipment's nameplate or in the manufacturer's documentation. Since you can't find it, you need to be very cautious.
Code Guidance
In the absence of a specified MOCP, you generally follow the NEC Article 422.11(E), which applies to fixed electric space-heating equipment. This section states that the overcurrent protection shall not exceed 150% of the element rating.
3.
Wire Sizing
NEC Table 310.16
This table provides ampacities for conductors based on insulation type and installation conditions.
#8 Copper
Generally, #8 copper wire with THHN/THWN insulation is rated for around 40-55 Amps (depending on conditions, termination temperature, and the specific table you're using from the NEC). Since each phase is calculated to be 43.3, #8 is insufficient.
#6 Copper
Generally, #6 copper wire with THHN/THWN insulation is rated for around 55-75 Amps (depending on conditions, termination temperature, and the specific table you're using from the NEC).
Recommendations and Actions1. Immediate Action: CONSULT A LICENSED ELECTRICIAN. This is not optional. Your electrician can perform a thorough site assessment, verify your voltage, measure actual current draw, and ensure the installation meets all applicable codes and safety requirements.2. Verify Element Ratings
Double-check the actual wattage rating of each element. Are they truly 6000W each?3.
Contact State Water Heaters
Try to obtain the MOCP (Minimum Overcurrent Protection) from the manufacturer directly. Explain that you've upgraded the elements and need the correct overcurrent protection value.4.
Derating
You may need to increase the wire size if multiple conductors are bundled together, or if they run through high-temperature areas.5.
Neutral Sizing
When dealing with unbalanced loads, the neutral conductor can carry significant current. Ensure it is properly sized to handle the potential imbalance.6.
Voltage Drop
With higher current loads, voltage drop becomes a concern. The longer the wire run from your panel to the water heater, the more significant the voltage drop will be. Use a voltage drop calculator to ensure the voltage at the water heater remains within acceptable limits.
Answering Your Specific Questions
"Am I good to go with either #8 or #6 copper?" No, probably not with #8. With the estimated 43.3A per phase and depending on your local codes, you would most likely need to upgrade to #6 copper or larger. "Or should I downsize to a 50 Amp breaker?" You could, but not without verifying the water heater's MOCP. Using a smaller breaker would offer more protection for the wiring. However, if the actual current draw is too close to the breaker rating, it could cause nuisance tripping. In addition, going down to a 50 Amp breaker does not solve the insufficient wiring; #8 is still not large enough for 43.3 Amps.
Additional Thoughts Load Shedding/Staggered Operation
A safer and potentially more energy-efficient approach is to use a controller that staggers the operation of the two elements. This would prevent the full 12kW load from being drawn simultaneously, reducing the demand on your electrical system.
Energy Consumption
Operating two 6000W elements simultaneously will consume a significant amount of energy. Consider the impact on your electric bill and whether your service can handle the increased load.
Alternative Solution
Depending on your hot water needs, consider other options, such as a larger-capacity water heater or a tankless water heater.
Disclaimer: I am an AI chatbot and cannot provide professional electrical advice. Always consult a qualified and licensed electrician for any electrical work. This information is for educational purposes only. Flag for review