User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Tuesday, October 21, 2025 at 7:54 am EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, October 21, 2025 at 7:55 am EDT
Question: Have a unique situation where existing modular buildings( about 15) are being relocated and we need to temp them out. All I have is an existing one line showing different boards feeding the buildings to be relocated. Not all are being relocated.If I just have below and say there are, (as an example), 15 of them like this being fed from 100A breaker that would not necessarily mean I need 1500A source of power correct? It would never demand that much at once? With the limited info I have could I just take 80% of the total amperage and say I need that much power at the source? Thanks
You're absolutely right, simply adding up the breaker sizes doesn't give you an accurate picture of the actual load demand. You're also on the right track thinking about demand factors. However, just blindly applying an 80% factor is a dangerous shortcut. Here's a breakdown of how to approach this problem with the limited information, and why your 80% idea needs more thought
The Problem with Simply Adding Breaker Sizes:
Diversity
The modular buildings will almost certainly not all be drawing their full 100A simultaneously. The more buildings you have, the lower the probability of peak demand occurring at the same time for each. This is where demand factors come in.
Load Types
What's in the modular buildings? Are they offices with lights and computers? Residential units with appliances and HVAC? Laboratories with specialized equipment? The load types are critical to estimating demand.
Duty Cycle
Even if a building could draw 100A, how often does it actually do so? A welder might have a 100A breaker, but it's not welding continuously.
Steps to Take With Limited Information
1.
Absolutely Essential: Characterize the Loads
The #1 Priority
Find out exactly what's inside these modular buildings. Is it office space, residential units, workshops, medical clinics, storage? The load type heavily influences demand factors.
Inventory
Try to get even a rough inventory of typical equipment in each type of modular building. Examples:
Office
Number of computers, lights (type and wattage), HVAC units (size), water cooler, coffee maker, etc.
Residential
HVAC units (size), refrigerator, stove (gas or electric?), water heater (electric?), microwave, lights, TV, etc.
Workshop
Number and type of power tools, welders, etc. (even rough estimates).2.
Determine Load Demand Factors
NEC Table 220.42 (General Lighting)
If buildings are predominately office space or are general lighting, this is a good starting point.
NEC Article 220
This article covers branch circuit, feeder and service calculations, and is your primary source for demand factors. Specific tables will be determined by the type of loads you've identified in step 1.
NEC Article 220.82 (Optional Method for Dwelling Units)
If the modulars are residential, this article provides a simplified method for dwelling unit load calculations.
Professional Engineer
For complex situations, or if you need to be absolutely sure, a consulting engineer specializing in electrical power distribution is the best investment.3.
Calculate Demand Load per Modular Building Type
Use the correct demand factors from the NEC to determine a calculated load for each type of modular building. Example (Simplified Office)
Let's say you have 5 offices, each with an estimated connected load of 30A (lights, computers, etc.). The NEC might allow you to apply a demand factor of 70% for lighting loads over 120 VA per square foot. It might allow a demand factor of 50% for receptacle outlets. These must be specifically determined per code and application. Your calculated demand for each office modular might then be, say, 20A instead of 30A.4.
Sum the Demand Loads, Applying a Further Diversity Factor (Potentially)
This is where you can potentially reduce the overall demand further. Consider how the modular buildings will be used in relation to each other.
Example
If you have 15 modulars, and 5 are offices, 5 are residential, and 5 are workshops, you'll have three separate calculated demand loads from Step 3. Sum the 5 office loads, the 5 residential loads, and the 5 workshop loads separately.
Diversity Factor
Will the workshops be used at the same time as the offices? Unlikely. Will the residential units all be cooking dinner at the same time? Maybe, but probably not with maximum power draw. You may be able to apply a diversity factor to the summed loads of the different types of modulars. This is the riskiest step, and requires careful judgment. A PE is often required.5.
Calculate Total Required Amperage
Add up the calculated demand loads (with any appropriate diversity factor applied). This is your estimated total amperage requirement.
Why Your 80% Idea Needs More Thought
Arbitrary
80% is just a guess. It might be too high (wasting money on unused capacity) or too low (risking overload).
Application
While 80% might be an appropriate demand factor for some specific loads (like continuous lighting in some scenarios), it's not a general "fudge factor" you can apply to everything.
Important Considerations for Temporary Power
Safety
Temporary power is often installed under less-than-ideal conditions. Oversizing the supply is usually a good idea, within reason, to provide extra headroom for unexpected loads or voltage drop.
Voltage Drop
Temporary wiring runs can be long. Calculate voltage drop carefully, especially for motor loads (HVAC, power tools). You might need larger conductors than you initially think.
Future Proofing
Consider if the temporary power will eventually become permanent. If so, design it for the long-term load, not just the temporary one.
In Summary
Load Type is King
Find out exactly what's inside the modular buildings.2.
NEC is Your Guide
Use NEC Article 220 and associated tables to determine appropriate demand factors for each load type.3.
Calculate Demand
Calculate a demand load for each type of modular building.4.
Sum and Consider Diversity
Sum the demand loads, and carefully consider if a diversity factor is appropriate.5.
Calculate Total Amperage
This is your estimated temporary power requirement.6.
Err on the Side of Safety
Oversize slightly, and calculate voltage drop.7.
Get a Professional
If you're unsure, consult with a qualified electrical engineer.
Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and should not be considered professional engineering advice. Consult with a qualified electrical engineer for your specific project. Electrical work can be dangerous, and should only be performed by qualified individuals. Flag for review