User: Jimmy7, Location: Boston, MA
Asked on: Tuesday, October 21, 2025 at 8:16 am EDT
Answered on: Tuesday, October 21, 2025 at 8:16 am EDT
Question: I have switched to using 3M wirenuts, because the red/yellow and orange/blue seem to cover any combination I run across. I was using and still have some Ideal B2 wirenuts. I actually looked at the listed combinations of the B2’s and noticed that they can handle 2 to 6 #14 solid, but it doesn’t list multiple 14 solids with say #18 stranded for a fixture wire or smoke detector or something like that. I’m sure I’m not the first or the last to use these in this type of combination. I pre-twist and make my connections tight, so no concern there. I was wondering is this just a testing issue, is the testing expensive?
You're asking a great question about the limitations of wirenut listings and how they apply to real-world scenarios. Here's a breakdown
Why Listings Don't Cover Every Combination
Cost
Listing agencies like UL (Underwriters Laboratories) or CSA (Canadian Standards Association) require rigorous testing for each specific combination of wires. Testing every possible combination of wire gauges, solid/stranded, and number of conductors would be astronomically expensive for manufacturers.
Practicality
Manufacturers focus on the most common and likely combinations to keep costs down and make the listings useful for the majority of applications. They prioritize combinations that are frequently encountered in standard electrical wiring.
Complexity
Listing standards are based on specific, repeatable tests. Mixing solid and stranded wires introduces a lot of variability in terms of how tightly they twist together and how the pressure is distributed within the wirenut.
Why the Listed Combinations are Important Safety
Wirenut listings are designed to ensure a safe and reliable connection under normal conditions. This includes resisting pull-out forces, maintaining electrical continuity, and preventing overheating.
Code Compliance
Electrical codes (like the NEC in the US) generally require that electrical connections be made with devices listed and labeled for the intended use. Deviating from the listed combinations can be a code violation, even if the connection seems secure.
Liability
If a fire or other electrical problem occurs and it's determined that the wiring was done in a way that deviated from listed product applications, you could potentially be held liable.
The Issue of Mixing Solid and Stranded Wires Outside the Listing Uneven Pressure
The core concern when mixing solid and stranded wires is that the solid wires might not compress the stranded wires adequately. Stranded wires are much more flexible, and the solid wires could essentially create pressure points that bypass some of the strands, resulting in a loose or unreliable connection over time.
Corrosion
If the connection isn't perfectly tight, moisture and air can get in, leading to corrosion, especially between dissimilar metals. This can further degrade the connection.
Overheating
A loose connection increases resistance, which generates heat. This can damage the insulation and even lead to a fire.
Your Practices (Pre-Twisting, Tightening)
While pre-twisting and ensuring a tight connection are good practices, they don't guarantee a safe or reliable connection when using unlisted combinations. Pre-twisting is acceptable in the 2023 NEC, as long as it does not damage the conductors. The UL White Book allows pre-twisting. It says that the products can be used with or without pre-twisting if the instructions don't require it.
Why 3M Wirenuts Seem More Versatile Design
3M wirenuts, particularly the red/yellow and orange/blue ones, are designed with a wider range of wire gauges and conductor counts in mind. Their internal spring and thread design may be more forgiving and better at accommodating slight variations in wire size and type.
Marketing
3M may also focus on listing a greater variety of combinations for their products.
What to Do in Your Situation1. Stick to Listed Combinations
The safest and most code-compliant approach is always to use wirenuts within their listed parameters.2.
Use the Right Wirenut
It sounds like you already have by switching to a product that is more in line with your application needs.3.
Consider Alternatives
Pigtailing
Pigtail the #18 wire to a piece of #14 solid wire and then use the B2 to connect to the existing #14 solid wires. This keeps the B2 usage within its listed parameters.
Push-In Connectors (e.g., Wago)
These connectors are often listed for a wider variety of solid/stranded combinations and can be a good alternative for connecting lighting fixtures or smoke detectors to solid-core wiring.
Lever Action Connectors (e.g., Wago)
These connectors can also handle solid and stranded wires.4.
Consult a Qualified Electrician
If you're unsure about the best way to make a particular connection, especially in a critical application, consult with a licensed electrician.
In Summary
While it might be tempting to use wirenuts outside their listed parameters, it's generally not recommended due to safety, code compliance, and potential liability concerns. Using the correct tool for the job, in line with its intended and tested usage, is always the best practice. If you're mixing solid and stranded wires, especially smaller gauge fixture wires, consider using connectors specifically listed for that purpose or adjust your methods to stay within the wirenut's approved configurations. Flag for review