Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Gear Switch Install

User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ

Asked on: Wednesday, October 22, 2025 at 9:23 am EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, October 22, 2025 at 9:24 am EDT

Question: So the GC said another electrical sib suggested the following in lieu of temp genertor.Step 1. De-energize the main gear and disconnect the bars( or whatever they are) from the main bus bar to the existing switch being replaced). Liven up gear. Now the switch being replaced in isolated from main bus bar and not live.Step 2. De-energize gear and put new bars( or whatever they are called) from main bus bar to where new breaker will be installed. Liven up gear.Step 3. De-energize gear and install new breaker. Liven up gear.Done. Is this doable? THanks

Okay, let's break down this proposed plan and analyze its feasibility and safety implications. It sounds like you're replacing a switch (likely a circuit breaker) in a switchgear lineup without using a temporary generator to maintain power to critical loads.

Understanding the Proposal

The electrician is suggesting a sequence of steps to isolate the old switch, install the new one, and then re-energize the system piece by piece. The key is working with the gear de-energized for each modification step.

Bars

These are likely
bus bars. Bus bars are the conductors within the switchgear that distribute power.

Analyzing the Steps


Step 1: Isolate the Old Switch



"De-energize the main gear..."
This implies a complete shutdown of the entire switchgear section, which could affect many loads. "...and disconnect the bars from the main bus bar to the existing switch being replaced." This is the crucial isolation step. Physically disconnecting the conductors ensures the old switch is isolated even when the main bus is re-energized. It also sets the stage for safely removing the old switch. "Liven up gear." Re-energize the main gear (everything except the section with the disconnected switch). Now the rest of the facility has power, but the bay/section with the old switch is safely isolated.

Concerns/Considerations



Documentation

Critical. Clear labeling and documentation of exactly what is disconnected and where is essential. Photos, diagrams, and detailed notes are a must.

Lockout/Tagout (LOTO)

A formal LOTO procedure must be followed for all de-energized equipment. This includes locking out the main breaker feeding the gear and tagging it appropriately. The disconnect points for the bars also need LOTO.

Safety Grounding

Temporarily grounding the isolated section while working on it is a very good safety practice.


Arc Flash Hazard

Even though de-energized, there is always a residual arc flash hazard. Wear appropriate PPE when opening panels, removing covers, or working near energized equipment.2.

Step 2: Prepare for the New Switch



"De-energize gear..."
Again, this implies shutting down the entire switchgear (or a large section) and LOTO procedures. It seems strange because the the section where the work is occurring should already be de-energized and locked out in Step 1. "...and put new bars from main bus bar to where new breaker will be installed." This involves physically installing the new bus bar connections to the new switch's location. This is where you'd likely need to make connections to the main bus, and it can be tricky to work in an energized switchgear enclosure even if the section itself is de-energized. "Liven up gear." Re-energize the gear. The new bus bar connections are now energized, but the new switch isn't installed yet.

Concerns/Considerations



Main Bus Connection

Connecting to the main bus is the highest-risk part. Extreme care is needed to avoid accidental contact or short circuits.

Torque Specifications

All connections
must be torqued to the manufacturer's specifications. Loose connections are a common cause of switchgear failures.

Proper Connection Points
Making sure these connections are tight and of the correct materials. Clearance

Double-check clearances before energizing. Make sure no tools, rags, or other debris are left inside.3.

Step 3: Install the New Switch



"De-energize gear..."
Shutdown is implied to make the final switch installtion. "...and install new breaker." Installing the new switch itself. "Liven up gear." Re-energize. The new switch is now in service.

Concerns/Considerations



Proper Fit

Ensure the new switch is the correct type and rating for the switchgear.


Torque

Again, torque all connections according to the manufacturer's specifications.

Testing

Before putting the switch under load, perform commissioning tests. This might include insulation resistance tests (Megger), contact resistance tests, and timing tests (if applicable).

Is it Doable?
Yes, this method can be done, but it is highly dependent on the specific switchgear configuration, the expertise of the electricians, and strict adherence to safety procedures. It's a fairly common practice in switchgear work. It should be done by highly experienced and qualified personnel.

Critical Questions to Ask



Competency

Are the electricians
very experienced with this specific type of switchgear? This is not a job for someone without extensive switchgear experience.

Detailed Procedures

Does the electrician have a written, detailed procedure that includes lockout/tagout, testing, and torque specifications?

Drawings

Are up-to-date one-line diagrams and switchgear schematics available?


Switchgear Configuration

Is there sufficient physical space and access to safely make the connections to the main bus? Are there any unusual wiring configurations that could complicate the process?

Risk Assessment

Has a formal risk assessment been performed to identify potential hazards and mitigation strategies?


Alternative Isolation

Are there other isolating devices (e.g., draw-out breakers) within the switchgear that could simplify the process and reduce the risk?

Planning

Can you walk through all steps of the job on site so that you understand the plan.

Alternatives



Temporary Generator

While you want to avoid it, using a temporary generator provides a much higher level of safety and reliability.

Important Disclaimer

I am an AI chatbot, and I cannot provide electrical safety advice. This information is for informational purposes only. Any electrical work must be performed by qualified electricians in accordance with all applicable codes and regulations. Your specific switchgear configuration may require a different approach.

In summary:
While the plan is potentially doable, it requires meticulous planning, experienced personnel, and strict adherence to safety procedures. If you have any doubts about the electrician's capabilities or the safety of the plan, seek a second opinion from another qualified electrical contractor. Prioritize safety above all else.Consider documenting your plan with pictures so you know what to return to what after disconnecting.Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question