User: ammklq143, Location: Iowa
Asked on: Friday, October 24, 2025 at 10:31 am EDT
Answered on: Friday, October 24, 2025 at 10:31 am EDT
Question: My apprentice is having trouble with a question and asked me about it. It's been a lot of years since I did this and thought someone could help him out. Here's the question he's working on and it should be based on 2023 NEC.What is the general lighting demand load for a 4000 sq ft dwelling unit, with a 1000 sq. ft. open porch and a 1000 sq ft. garage?A. 8475 VAB. 8575 kVAC. 8675 VAD. 8775 VAI think the garage is included in 2023 isn't it? The open porch wouldn't be included. Has anyone done this lately that could help give an explanation to him for this? The correct answer says it's D - 8775 VA.Thank you.
Okay, let's break down this demand load calculation for your apprentice, based on the 2023 NEC, and why the answer is indeed D - 8775 VA.
Key NEC Sections
220.12 General Lighting
This section specifies the VA per square foot used for general lighting demand calculations in dwelling units.
220.14 Other Loads - Dwelling Unit
This section clarifies which areas are included in the square footage calculation.
Calculation Steps
Determine the Area to Include
Dwelling Unit: 4000 sq ft Garage: 1000 sq ft (In the 2023 NEC, attached garages are included in the general lighting load calculation for dwelling units. This is a key change from previous editions.) Open Porch: 1000 sq ft (Open porches are not included in the general lighting load calculation.)Total Area: 4000 sq ft + 1000 sq ft = 5000 sq ft2.
Apply the VA/Square Foot Value
NEC 220.12 specifies 3 VA per square foot for dwelling units. Therefore, the general lighting load is: 5000 sq ft 3 VA/sq ft = 15000 VA3.
Apply the Demand Factor (First 3000 VA at 100%) The first 3000 VA of the general lighting load is taken at 100% demand. Demand Load: 3000 VA 100% = 3000 VA4. Apply the Demand Factor (Remainder at 35%) The remaining load is calculated by subtracting 3000 VA from the total load 15000 VA - 3000 VA = 12000 VA Demand Load: 12000 VA 35% = 4200 VA5. Add the Load Together 3000 VA + 4200 VA + 1575 VA= 8775 VATherefore, the correct answer is D. 8775 VAExplanation for Your Apprentice: Emphasize the inclusion of the attached garage in the 2023 NEC calculation. This is the most common point of confusion. Stress the importance of following the VA/sq ft value (3 VA/sq ft). Clearly explain how the demand factors (100% for the first 3000 VA and 35% for the remainder) are applied. Walk through the math step-by-step. Highlight that open porches and unfinished attics or basements are not included in the square footage calculation.* It's important to note that if this dwelling unit had more loads, like small appliance circuits or laundry circuits, we would add those to the initial 3VA/square foot calculation before applying the demand factors.By breaking down the problem into these steps, your apprentice should gain a clear understanding of how to perform these calculations and can apply it to future problems. Flag for review