User: DakotaGrand, Location: Murfreesboro
Asked on: Friday, October 24, 2025 at 2:12 pm EDT
Answered on: Friday, October 24, 2025 at 2:16 pm EDT
Question: So I waas reading through an old thread on this question and seems I did the same calculations and came up with the same answers they came to in the thread. But the PSI practice exam is saying that is incorrect. using article 630.10 you would go to the next standard breaker size of 450. they are saying the correct answer is 400. can anyone shed some light on this.Multiple nonmotor generator arc welders are being served by a branch panel. There are two 120-amperes welders with a 70% duty cycle, one 90-amperes welder with a 80% duty cycle, and one 250-amperes welder with a 50% duty cycle. What is the minimum disconnect for this
Okay, let's break down this arc welder calculation and why the answer might be 400 amps based on the PSI practice exam. It's all about correctly applying Article 630.11(A) and 630.
12.1. Individual Welder Calculations
Two 120A Welders @ 70% Duty Cycle
120A 0.70 = 84A each
One 90A Welder @ 80% Duty Cycle
90A 0.80 = 72A
One 250A Welder @ 50% Duty Cycle
250A 0.50 = 125A
2. Apply Article 630.11(A) - Finding the Equivalent Primary Current
This is where the "Table 630.11(A)" comes into play. We need to determine which welder has the highest duty cycle and then apply the diversity factor as the welders are rated differently.
Highest Duty Cycle Welder
The 90A welder has the highest duty cycle at 80%. Therefore we use this as a start point. 90A .80 = 72 amps
Additional Welders Calculation
Now we need to calculate the additional welders Two 120A Welders @ 70% Duty Cycle: 120A 0.70 = 84A each One 250A Welder @ 50% Duty Cycle: 250A 0.50 = 125A
Summation of Total Amps
72+84+84+125 = 365 amps
3. Apply Article 630.12 - Overcurrent Protection The overcurrent protection must be based off the calculated amperage in article 630.11. Because we calculated our amperage at 365 amps, the next standard size is 400 ampsWhy the Confusion? Duty Cycle Derating Confusion
A common mistake is to only use the duty cycle for each welder to determine its individual contribution to the total current and then add them together. While you do calculate the individual contributions based on duty cycle, you then need to use the Table 630.11(A) to determine the multiplier and apply it to the largest welder's duty cycle.
Incorrect Table Use
Make sure you're using the correct row of Table 630.11(A) based on the number of welders, after* you've already taken into account the individual duty cycles.
In Summary
The correct answer, based on a strict reading and common application of Article 630, is 400 amps. The PSI exam is likely testing your ability to correctly apply the duty cycle derating factors and then use the standard breaker size rules. Flag for review