User: electrofelon, Location: Cherry Valley NY, Seattle, WA
Asked on: Sunday, October 26, 2025 at 9:12 pm EDT
Answered on: Sunday, October 26, 2025 at 9:12 pm EDT
Question: I have a 1600A feeder leaving a switchboard, going thru an ATS, then back to the switchboard. The generator/ATS is NOT an SDS. The generator output breaker is 1200A. The conductors to (and back from) the ATS and switchboard are 6 sets of 500 AL, 2 sets in each pipe. The conductors from the gen to the ATS are 6 total sets of 350 AL, in 3 pipes. Max demand over 3 years is 380 amps. What size grounded conductors should I use?My thoughts: Its temping to go real small, maybe minimum size. Under normal operation, the neutral to/from the ATS wont be carrying anything. Minimum size per 215.2(A)(2) is 350MCM AL, which would be a 2/0 in each pipe. Also was kinda thinking that (3) 2/0 exceeds the demand figure (assuming perfectly balanced), but not sure that makes any logical sense to compare those two that way. I guess I could say absurd worst case is the 136 KW all on one phase which would be like 1100A This is large facility, im not doing a neutral calc, it would take half a week.
Okay, let's break down the grounded conductor sizing for this feeder. You're right to be cautious and not simply go with the absolute minimum. While the normal load might be light, there are scenarios where significant neutral current could flow, and code requirements are there to ensure safety and proper operation.Here's a structured approach
1. Understanding the System Type & Code Requirements:
Non-Separately Derived System (Non-SDS)
You've correctly identified that the generator/ATS setup is NOT an SDS. This means the neutral is continuously connected through the ATS and the switchboard. The generator isn't creating a new neutral point.
215.2(A)(2)
This section is the primary guide. It states the grounded conductor must be sized to carry the maximum unbalanced load as determined by 220.61. If the neutral conductors are paralleled, the ampacity of each paralleled conductor shall be not less than 1/3 of the ampacity of the ungrounded conductors.
250.24(C)(1)
This section applies to the supply side of the service disconnect. Since this is a feeder, it doesn't directly apply, but it provides some useful guidance by analogy.
250.30
This section applies to separately derived systems, and so is not relevant to your situation.
2. Key Considerations
Maximum Unbalanced Load
You need to estimate the maximum unbalanced load that could realistically occur on this feeder. While your 380A peak demand over three years is valuable, it might not represent the worst-case unbalanced condition. Consider what equipment is fed from this feeder. Are there large single-phase loads (e.g., HVAC, lighting panels with unbalanced circuits, etc.) that could create a significant imbalance?
Harmonics
Are there significant non-linear loads (e.g., VFDs, computers, LED lighting) that generate harmonic currents? Harmonics can significantly increase neutral current, even in systems that appear balanced at the fundamental frequency.
Parallel Conductors
Since you have parallel conductors, the minimum size requirements for each parallel grounded conductor apply independently.
Continuity and Fault Clearing
Don't forget the grounded conductor is also part of the fault clearing path. It needs to be sized adequately to carry fault current.
3. Applying the Code and Making a Decision
Let's analyze your thoughts and code sections in light of these considerations.
Your Temptation to Go Small
You're right to be cautious. Even if normally the neutral carries little current, you need to account for abnormal conditions and worst-case scenarios. A tiny neutral is a false economy and a potential safety hazard.
215.2(A)(2) and the 1/3 Rule
This is where we start. The total ampacity of your ungrounded conductors is 6 sets of 500 kcmil AL. Using 75 degree ampacity, that is 380 6 = 2280 amps. 1/3 of that is 760 amps. If this feeder has more than 4 current-carrying conductors, you would also need to apply derating factors. However, this is a minimum requirement. If an imbalance calculation dictates that the neutral must be larger than this amount, then you must go with the larger size.
Your Imbalance Calculation Thought
Comparing the demand of 380A to the capacity of (3) 2/0 conductors is not the right comparison. You need to consider the maximum unbalanced load that could occur, not just the typical load. While 380A is your peak total demand, it says nothing about the imbalance between phases.
Worst-Case Scenario (All Load on One Phase)
Your thought experiment of 136kW all on one phase is useful for understanding a theoretical worst-case. However, consider if that's realistic. Is it possible for that much load to be forced onto a single phase? Probably not. But it's a good exercise to understand the potential.
Calculating Unbalanced Neutral Load: NEC 220.61 applies in this case, however performing an accurate calculation for a large facility could be difficult.4. Recommendations
Given the information you've provided, here's a suggested approach:1.
Perform a Realistic Imbalance Calculation
This is critical. You need to go beyond the 380A peak demand and try to estimate the maximum unbalanced load that could realistically occur. Talk to the facility operators. Review load schedules. Look for patterns of single-phase loading that could cause significant neutral current.2.
Consider Harmonics
If there are significant non-linear loads, estimate the harmonic current contribution. There are engineering tools and methods to do this. A power quality analysis might be warranted if you suspect significant harmonic distortion.3.
Apply the 1/3 Rule as a MINIMUM
Remember, per 215.2(A)(2), the grounded conductor cannot be smaller than 1/3 the ampacity of the ungrounded conductors, this is a hard requirement.
4.
Fault Current Considerations
Ensure the selected grounded conductor size has sufficient ampacity and conductivity to carry fault current back to the source to facilitate proper operation of overcurrent devices.5.
Document Your Reasoning
Whatever size you choose, document how you arrived at that decision. Include your calculations, assumptions, and any relevant information about the load characteristics. This documentation is essential for future reference and for demonstrating compliance with the NEC.6.
Upsize for Future Capacity (Optional but Recommended)
If budget allows, consider upsizing the grounded conductors beyond the calculated minimum. This provides a safety margin and allows for future load growth without having to rework the wiring.
Example (Using the 1/3 Rule)
Ampacity of ungrounded conductors: 6 sets of 500 kcmil AL @ 75°C = 6 380A = 2280A Minimum neutral ampacity: 2280A / 3 = 760A Dividing into pipes = 760A / 3 pipes = 253A Therefore, each 2 sets of 2/0 aluminum conductors are sufficient for 253A
Important Considerations
Consult a Qualified Engineer
If you are unsure about any of these calculations or considerations, consult a qualified electrical engineer. They can perform a thorough load analysis, assess harmonic distortion, and ensure that the grounded conductor is sized appropriately for your specific application.
Local Codes and Regulations: Always verify and comply with any local codes and regulations that may be more stringent than the NEC.In summary, while the 1/3 rule in 215.2(A)(2) is your absolute minimum*, a realistic load analysis is crucial to ensure the grounded conductor can safely and effectively carry any potential unbalanced and harmonic currents. Don't hesitate to seek expert advice to ensure safety and compliance. Flag for review