Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: CABLE IMPEDANCE IN EASYPOWER AND SKM

User: binwork91, Location: new york

Asked on: Wednesday, October 29, 2025 at 2:50 pm EDT
Answered on: Wednesday, October 29, 2025 at 2:50 pm EDT

Question: Hi, I am new to SKM.Anyone has idea why skm and Easypower have different impedance of cable?And which manufacture will you pick in skm? typical or IEEE or NEC or others?

Okay, let's break down why SKM and EasyPower might show different cable impedances and how to approach cable selection in SKM.

Why Impedance Differences in SKM and EasyPower?

Several factors can contribute to discrepancies in cable impedance calculations between SKM (like PTW) and EasyPower:1. Calculation Methods



Accuracy

Both software packages use algorithms to calculate cable impedance. However, they may use different levels of detail and approximations. This is especially true for things like:


Skin Effect

The phenomenon of alternating current concentrating near the surface of a conductor at higher frequencies. More accurate calculations include skin effect, which increases resistance.

Proximity Effect

Similar to skin effect but caused by the magnetic fields of nearby conductors. More detailed models account for proximity effect.


Temperature Correction

Cable impedance varies with temperature. The software may be using different default operating temperatures, or you may not be inputting the same temperature.

Assumptions

The software makes assumptions about the cable construction, materials, and operating conditions. If these assumptions differ, the results will also differ.2.

Cable Library Data



Source Data

Both programs rely on cable libraries that contain impedance data. The source of this data (e.g., manufacturer catalogs, IEEE standards, NEC tables) can be different. Even if the source seems the same (e.g., "NEC Table 9"), the interpretation and implementation within the software might vary.

Interpolation

The software often interpolates between data points in the library. Different interpolation methods can lead to slightly different impedance values.


Units

Ensure consistency in units (e.g., ohms per foot vs. ohms per 1000 feet) between the software and your input.3.

Input Data



Configuration

How the cables are configured in the software. Number of cables per phase, spacing, burial depth (if underground), ambient temperature and other parameters can dramatically change the impedance.


Operating Temperature

Make sure you're using the same operating temperature in both programs.4.

Software Versions

Algorithms can be updated with new software versions, and so may the cable libraries.

Troubleshooting Impedance Discrepancies


Here's a systematic approach to investigate discrepancies:1. Identify the Specific Cable

Pinpoint a specific cable that shows a significant difference in impedance.2.

Compare Input Data

Carefully compare all input parameters related to the cable in both SKM and EasyPower:
Cable type Conductor size and material (copper/aluminum) Insulation type Number of conductors per phase Spacing between conductors (or conduit configuration) Operating temperature Frequency (usually 60 Hz) Shielding and grounding details3.

Examine Cable Library Data

If possible, find out the
exact data source used by each program for that cable. Some software allows you to view the underlying values from the cable library.4.

Simplify the Model

Create a simple test case in both programs with only the cable in question. This eliminates potential interactions with other components.5.

Manual Calculation

Perform a manual calculation of the cable impedance using formulas from IEEE standards (e.g., IEEE Std 399, IEEE Std 242) or reputable textbooks. Compare your manual calculation to the software results. This will help you determine if one of the software packages has a fundamental issue.6.

Software Support

Contact the technical support teams for both SKM and EasyPower. Provide them with the detailed comparison of your inputs and the resulting impedances.

Choosing a Cable Manufacturer/Standard in SKM (PTW)


In SKM PTW, the choice of cable "manufacturer" or standard depends on the purpose of your study, the availability of data, and the level of accuracy you require.
Typical

This often represents a generic or average cable characteristic. It's useful for initial studies or when detailed manufacturer data is not available. However, it may not accurately reflect the performance of a specific cable.

IEEE

IEEE standards (like IEEE Std 399, IEEE Std 242, IEEE 525) provide formulas and data for calculating cable impedances. This is a good choice when you need more accurate results or want to verify the software's calculations.


NEC

NEC (National Electrical Code) tables provide ampacity and other information, but the impedance data is often less precise than IEEE data. The NEC values are generally conservative for safety reasons, and the impedances are usually based on certain assumptions.*

Manufacturer Specific

Ideally, if you know the exact cable you're using (or plan to use), choose the manufacturer-specific data. This is the most accurate option, but it requires you to obtain detailed specifications from the manufacturer's datasheets. Some manufacturers provide libraries directly compatible with SKM.

Recommendations


Start with Manufacturer Data (if available)

If you have the manufacturer's data sheets for the specific cables you are using, always prioritize entering that information. SKM allows you to input custom cable parameters, bypassing the standard libraries.2.

IEEE for Verification

If you don't have manufacturer data, use IEEE standards to calculate the cable impedance independently and compare it to SKM's results. This helps you ensure that SKM's calculations are reasonable.3.

Typical for Initial Studies

For preliminary studies or when detailed data is lacking, the "Typical" option can be useful for getting a general idea of the system's behavior. But remember that it's less precise.4.

Consistency

Within a single SKM project, try to be consistent in your choice of data sources. Avoid mixing and matching data from different sources unless you have a good reason to do so.5.

Documentation

Clearly document your choice of cable data sources and any assumptions you made. This will help you understand your results and defend your analysis.

In Summary:


Differences in cable impedances between SKM and EasyPower are common and usually stem from variations in calculation methods, cable library data, or input parameters. Thoroughly compare your inputs, examine the cable library data, and perform manual calculations to identify the source of the discrepancy. Choose the most appropriate cable data source in SKM based on data availability, accuracy requirements, and the purpose of your study. Remember that detailed manufacturer data is the most accurate, while IEEE standards offer a good balance between accuracy and availability. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question