User: AM59, Location: Boston, MA
Asked on: Thursday, October 30, 2025 at 2:57 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, October 30, 2025 at 3:08 pm EDT
Question: I'm an electrical engineer working with a prospective client to help them decide whether they can move forward with a restaurant fit-out job. The restaurant owner wants to use a bunch of foreign kitchen equipment that hasn't been tested by a NRTL. I'm just part of a team working on the MEP systems for this project, is the lack of approval for the equipment my problem?My drawings wouldn't actually say to connect anything, it would be all receptacles and switches for "equipment connection". Am I completely divorced from the acceptability of the equipment, or is there a requirement that I abstain from work where I know the code will not ultimately be followed to the letter? Or do I just kick it down to the road and have some CYA language on the drawings like "acceptability of all kitchen equipment to be coordinated with AHJ."?
This is a tricky situation, and the best answer depends on a few factors, but generally, you do have some responsibility and shouldn't just completely ignore the issue. Here's a breakdown of your concerns and how to approach them
Your Responsibilities:
Professional Responsibility
As a licensed electrical engineer, you have a professional obligation to design safe and code-compliant systems. You can't knowingly design a system that facilitates the use of non-compliant equipment.
Liability
Even if your drawings only show receptacles and switches, you could be held liable if your design enables the use of unsafe equipment that causes damage or injury.
Reputation
If the project is ultimately rejected or causes problems due to non-compliant equipment, it can reflect poorly on your firm and your expertise.
Why You Can't Completely Ignore It
The NEC (National Electrical Code) and NRTL Listing
The NEC (and corresponding codes in your jurisdiction) generally requires electrical equipment to be listed and labeled by a Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratory (NRTL) like UL, ETL, CSA, etc. This listing signifies that the equipment has been tested and meets specific safety standards. You're right, you don't test the equipment, but the code requires it to be tested.
AHJ Approval
The Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) (e.g., a local building inspector) ultimately has the final say on whether the installation is approved. They will likely reject the installation if the kitchen equipment lacks the required NRTL listing.
Safety Concerns
Using unlisted equipment can present significant safety hazards, including electrical shock, fire, and other dangers.
What You Should Do
Document Your Concerns
The most important thing to do is document your concerns in writing (email, memo, etc.). This will provide a record that you informed the client about the issue. Include the following: Explain the NEC requirements for NRTL listing. State that the use of unlisted equipment could result in rejection by the AHJ. Highlight the potential safety hazards associated with unlisted equipment. Recommend that the client consult with the AHJ to determine if there are any alternative means of compliance (e.g., field evaluation). Explain that field evaluation is a process where an NRTL comes to the site and evaluates the equipment in place. This is often costly.2.
Coordinate with the Client
Clearly communicate your concerns to the client. Explain the implications of using non-compliant equipment. Ask the client if they are aware of the NRTL listing requirement and if they have a plan to address it. Offer suggestions for alternative solutions, such as: Replacing the unlisted equipment with NRTL-listed alternatives. Having the equipment field-evaluated by an NRTL. Seeking a variance from the AHJ (this is rare and not guaranteed).3.
Coordinate with the Other MEP Team Members
Talk to the other members of the MEP team (mechanical, plumbing). This isn't just an electrical problem. Make sure everyone is on the same page regarding the equipment issue.4.
Consider Your Scope of Work
Adjusting Scope
If the client insists on using unlisted equipment and refuses to address the issue, you may need to consider adjusting your scope of work. This could involve excluding the connections for the non-compliant equipment from your design. (Though this is risky).
Resigning from the Project
As a last resort, if you feel that the client's actions are creating an unacceptable level of risk or violating your professional ethics, you may need to consider resigning from the project.5.
CYA Language on Drawings (and Specifications)
You absolutely should include disclaimer language on your drawings and specifications, but don't rely on it as your only protection. Example language: "All electrical equipment shall be listed and labeled by a Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratory (NRTL) acceptable to the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ). It is the responsibility of the owner/contractor to verify that all equipment meets this requirement prior to installation." "The electrical contractor shall verify the ampacity and voltage requirements of all equipment prior to installation." "The acceptability of all kitchen equipment, including compliance with applicable codes and standards, is the sole responsibility of the owner/contractor and shall be coordinated with the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)." Consider adding a note to the drawings specifically calling out the non-listed equipment: "Kitchen equipment supplied without NRTL listing. Coordination with the AHJ is required."
Important Considerations
AHJ Consultation
The best course of action is to encourage the client to consult with the AHJ before proceeding with the design. This will provide clarity on what the AHJ will accept and what alternatives might be available.
Document Everything
Keep a detailed record of all communication with the client, the AHJ, and other team members.
Seek Legal Counsel
If you have any concerns about your liability or the ethical implications of the project, consult with an attorney who specializes in engineering law.*
Field Evaluation
While field evaluation can be an option, it's important to understand that it can be costly and time-consuming. The equipment may still fail the evaluation.
In Summary:
You can't simply ignore the issue of non-compliant equipment. Your professional responsibilities require you to address the safety concerns and ensure that your design complies with applicable codes and standards. Document your concerns, communicate with the client, and consider adjusting your scope of work if necessary. Getting the AHJ involved early is crucial. And, don't underestimate the importance of CYA language. While that language isn't a get-out-of-jail-free card, it does show that you tried to address the issue. Good luck! Flag for review