User: A/A Fuel GTX, Location: WI & AZ
Asked on: Friday, October 31, 2025 at 6:34 pm EDT
Answered on: Friday, October 31, 2025 at 6:35 pm EDT
Question: Have a customer with a new home with a high end HVAC system. DC, variable speed, etc. When the system is in the cooling mode, the LED's in recessed cans throughout the house flicker randomly. The dimmers controlling the cans are LED rated. I recall a previous job awhile back where the well pump had the same effect on LED's/Dimmers. I believe the well guy had to put some kind of filter on the constant pressure well pump to alleviate the problem. Has anyone else had this problem? TIA
You're on the right track. What you're describing is likely harmonic distortion being introduced into the electrical system by the variable speed HVAC system (similar to what you saw with the well pump). Here's a breakdown of the problem and potential solutions
Understanding the Problem: Harmonic Distortion
What it is
Variable speed drives (VFDs) like those in your HVAC and well pumps chop the AC sine wave to control motor speed. This creates harmonics – frequencies that are multiples of the fundamental frequency (60 Hz in the US). These harmonics distort the voltage and current waveform.
How it affects LEDs
LED drivers are sensitive to voltage fluctuations. Harmonic distortion can cause the LED drivers to malfunction, leading to flickering, dimming, or even premature failure. Dimmers amplify the issue.
Why it's worse with modern systems
High-efficiency appliances and systems, while great for energy savings, often incorporate VFDs and other technologies that can generate harmonics.
Common Suspects
Variable-speed HVAC systems (compressors, fans) Variable-speed well pumps LED Lighting Solar Inverters Large banks of electronic devices (computers, servers) Electric Vehicle Chargers
Troubleshooting Steps1. Confirm the Source
Isolate the issue
Does the flickering only occur when the HVAC is running in cooling mode? If you can, temporarily disable the HVAC (or lower the speed) and see if the flickering stops.
Check voltage
Use a multimeter to monitor the voltage at the affected LED fixtures. Look for voltage fluctuations or irregularities when the HVAC is running. A true RMS meter is best.
Harmonic Analyzer
The ideal solution is to use a harmonic analyzer to measure the total harmonic distortion (THD) on the electrical system. This will quantify the problem and help you confirm the HVAC system as the source. An electrician with experience in power quality analysis should be able to do this.2.
Examine the HVAC System
Installation
Verify the HVAC system was installed correctly, following the manufacturer's instructions. Proper grounding is crucial.
Wiring
Check for loose connections or undersized wiring in the HVAC system's circuit.
Manufacturer Support
Contact the HVAC manufacturer or installer. They may be aware of known issues with that model and have recommended solutions.
Potential Solutions
Here are the most likely fixes, ranging from simpler to more complex:1. HVAC System Filter
Line Reactor or Harmonic Filter
This is often the most effective solution. A line reactor or harmonic filter installed on the HVAC system's incoming power line will reduce the amount of harmonic current injected into the electrical system.
Sizing
The filter must be properly sized for the HVAC system's horsepower/amperage and the level of harmonic distortion. Consult with an electrical engineer or power quality specialist to determine the correct size.
Installation
It should be installed as close to the HVAC unit as possible, on the line side of the disconnect.
Cost
Will Vary, but it may be worth a try before replacing the LEDs.2.
LED-Specific Solutions
Higher Quality LEDs
Replace the existing LED fixtures with higher-quality LEDs that are less susceptible to voltage fluctuations. Look for LEDs with better power factor correction (PF > 0.9).
LED Drivers with Harmonic Filtering
Some LED drivers are specifically designed to filter out harmonics.
Dedicated Circuits
If possible, put the LED lighting on a separate circuit from the HVAC system. This can help isolate the LEDs from the harmonic interference. This could also mean a 2-pole breaker to power the lights from the other phase, although this will require moving the neutral along with the hot.3.
Neutral Conductor
Adequate Sizing
Ensure that the neutral conductor for the affected circuits is adequately sized. Harmonic currents can overload the neutral conductor, leading to voltage distortion.
Dedicated Neutral
Consider running a dedicated neutral conductor for the LED lighting circuits back to the electrical panel.4.
Whole-House Solutions (More Complex and Expensive)
Harmonic Mitigation Panel
A harmonic mitigation panel installed at the main electrical panel can filter out harmonics from the entire electrical system. This is a more comprehensive solution but also more expensive.
Isolation Transformer
An isolation transformer can isolate the electrical system from the utility power, reducing the amount of harmonic distortion that enters the home.5.
Other Considerations
Dimmers
While you say they are LED-rated, try a different brand/model of LED dimmer. Sometimes, compatibility issues exist between specific LED fixtures and dimmers. Test with a standard (non-dimmable) LED to see if that resolves the issue.
Grounding
Verify that the entire electrical system is properly grounded. Poor grounding can exacerbate harmonic problems.
Important Notes
Consult an Expert
This type of problem is best addressed by an electrician with experience in power quality and harmonic mitigation. They can accurately diagnose the source of the problem and recommend the most effective solution.
Documentation
Document all troubleshooting steps, measurements, and solutions that you try. This will be helpful for future reference and for communicating with other professionals.
Safety: Always follow proper electrical safety procedures when working with electrical systems.Good luck! This can be a tricky problem, but with a systematic approach, you should be able to find a solution. Flag for review