User: Pinnie, Location: Ohio
Asked on: Saturday, November 1, 2025 at 6:11 pm EDT
Answered on: Saturday, November 1, 2025 at 6:12 pm EDT
Question: In the company I work for, guys will knockout or drill out a hole for a 1” emt into a four square. I think even as a pull box you would be over on a full boat 10 AWG pull, but what is the legality of such a modification?
You're right to question this. Drilling or punching a knockout into a standard four-square box for a 1" EMT connector raises significant concerns, primarily about box fill, pull box sizing, and potentially the listing and approval of the box itself. Here's a breakdown
1. Box Fill Calculations (NEC Article 314):
Conductor Count
Every conductor entering the box counts toward the box fill. This includes: Active conductors (hot, neutral, switch legs). Equipment grounding conductors. Conductors spliced within the box. Unused conductors (even if capped).
Device Fill
Devices like switches, receptacles, and even the strap of a wire connector each count as a number of conductors based on their size (see NEC 314.16(B)(4) and 314.16(B)(5)).
Fittings and Support
Internal clamps and fitting such as support posts count as an individual conductor if there are 1 or more present in the box.
Volume
Each conductor size (10 AWG, 12 AWG, 14 AWG, etc.) has a specific volume allowance (cubic inches). See NEC 314.16(B)(1).
The Calculation
You must calculate the total volume occupied by all conductors, devices, clamps/fittings and compare that to the available volume of the box. If the total volume exceeds the box's listed volume, you are in violation.
Why this matters with 10 AWG and a 1" EMT
10 AWG conductors are larger and require more volume than smaller conductors. A 1" EMT can carry a lot of 10 AWG conductors. Even with just a handful of 10 AWG wires, plus ground wires and devices, it's very easy to exceed the fill capacity of a standard four-square box.
2. Pull Box/Junction Box Sizing (NEC Article 314)
Straight Pulls
For straight pulls (conductors entering and exiting the box on opposite walls), the minimum length of the box must be eight times the trade size of the largest raceway entering the box (NEC 314.28(A)(1)). So, with a 1" EMT, the box must be at least 8 inches long in the direction of the pull. A four-square box is nowhere near that length.
Angle or U Pulls
For angle or U pulls, more complex calculations apply, based on the distance between raceway entries and the diameter of the raceways. These calculations are even more likely to require a larger box than a standard four-square.
Purpose of Rules
These sizing requirements are designed to provide adequate bending radius for the conductors, prevent insulation damage during pulling, and ensure the installer has enough room to work.
3. Alteration of Listed Equipment (NEC 110.3(B))
Listing and Labeling
Electrical equipment (including boxes) is typically "listed" by a recognized testing laboratory (like UL, ETL, CSA). Listing means the product has been tested and meets specific safety standards.
Installation and Use
NEC 110.3(B) requires that listed equipment be installed and used in accordance with its listing and labeling instructions.
Modification
Drilling or punching a knockout where one was not originally intended potentially violates the listing and labeling. The box was tested and approved as it was originally manufactured. Adding a knockout could compromise its structural integrity, grounding path, or ability to contain arcing or faults.
Legality and Code Violations
Drilling a hole in a four-square box for a 1" EMT is very likely a code violation based on:
Exceeding Box Fill
Highly probable if you have more than a few 10 AWG conductors.
Improper Pull Box Sizing
Almost guaranteed if the box is used as a pull point for the 1" EMT.
Altering Listed Equipment (Potentially)
Depends on the specific listing and labeling of the box. Some boxes might allow for field-drilled knockouts in certain locations, but this would need to be explicitly stated in the manufacturer's documentation. More than likely it violates the listing.
Recommendations
Stop the Practice
Immediately discourage this practice. Explain the potential code violations and safety hazards.2.
Consult the AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)
If there's any doubt, contact your local electrical inspector. They have the final say on code interpretation and enforcement.3.
Use Appropriate Boxes
For 1" EMT conduit runs with multiple 10 AWG conductors, use larger junction boxes that are properly sized according to NEC 314.28. Consider using pull boxes designed for the purpose.
4.
Review Manufacturer's Literature
If you must drill knockouts, carefully review the box manufacturer's documentation to see if it's permitted and what limitations apply. However, it's generally best to avoid drilling if possible.5.
Training
Provide training to employees on proper box fill calculations and pull box sizing.6.
Documentation
Keep records of box fill calculations and pull box sizing calculations for inspection purposes.
In summary, drilling a knockout for a 1" EMT into a standard four-square box is almost certainly a violation of the NEC, creating both code compliance and safety concerns. Using the correct size and type of box is crucial for a safe and code-compliant installation. Flag for review