User: Joao, Location: portugal
Asked on: Wednesday, November 5, 2025 at 10:34 am EST
Answered on: Wednesday, November 5, 2025 at 10:35 am EST
Question: For this service voltages I believe that cable 18/30 (36) kV should not be used even designed for Umax=36 kV.Also in most cases earthing regime is IT.In this way may be the best technical solution is cable 26/45 kV and not use 18/30 (36) kV cable.
You are correct in your assessment. Here's a breakdown of why using a 26/45 kV cable is generally a better technical solution than an 18/30 (36) kV cable in an IT (Isolated Terra) earthing system operating at 18/30 kV
Understanding the Voltage Designations:
18/30 (36) kV Cable
This indicates the cable's voltage ratings as follows: U₀ (U-zero): 18 kV - Rated voltage between phase and earth/metallic screen. U: 30 kV - Rated voltage between phases. Umax: 36 kV - Maximum system voltage the cable is designed to withstand under normal operating conditions. This is a critical point.
26/45 kV Cable
U₀ (U-zero): 26 kV - Rated voltage between phase and earth/metallic screen. U: 45 kV - Rated voltage between phases. Umax: Higher than 45kV
Why 26/45 kV is a Better Choice in an IT System
Overvoltage Protection in IT Systems
IT systems are not directly grounded at the source. This means that a single ground fault doesn't immediately cause a high fault current to flow and trip a circuit breaker. Instead:
Voltage Rise
In an IT system, when one phase faults to ground, the voltage on the other two phases will rise to approximately the phase-to-phase voltage. In a 18/30 kV system, the two healthy phases experience almost 30 kV to ground during a single ground fault.
Stress on Insulation
This sustained overvoltage significantly stresses the cable insulation. A cable rated for 18 kV to ground (like the 18/30 kV cable) is operating very close to, or potentially exceeding, its design limits during this fault condition.2.
Safety Factor & Insulation Life
Using a 26/45 kV cable provides a significantly larger safety margin. The higher U₀ (26 kV) means the cable is designed to withstand a higher voltage between phase and earth. This leads to:
Increased Reliability
Less risk of insulation breakdown due to overvoltage stress.
Longer Lifespan
Reduced aging and degradation of the insulation, leading to a longer cable lifespan.
Better Performance Under Transient Conditions
IT systems are also susceptible to voltage transients (e.g., from lightning or switching). The higher-rated cable provides better protection against these transient overvoltages.3.
Compliance with Standards
Many electrical codes and standards (such as IEC) recommend or even require the use of higher-rated cables in IT systems for exactly these reasons. Using the 26/45 kV cable aligns better with best practices and regulatory requirements.4.
Minimizing Risk in Case of Double Fault
Although IT systems are designed to operate with one fault, the risk of a second fault occurring on a different phase is always present. If a second fault to ground happens, it can cause a much more significant overvoltage. A 26/45 kV cable will offer much better performance and higher insulation resistance than a 18/30 (36) kV cable.
In summary:
While the 18/30 (36) kV cable might* technically meet the nominal voltage requirements of the system, it's operating very close to its limits during a ground fault in an IT system. The 26/45 kV cable provides a much more robust and reliable solution, offering significantly better overvoltage protection, increased lifespan, and greater compliance with industry standards. The increased upfront cost of the higher-rated cable is usually justified by the reduced risk of failure, longer lifespan, and improved overall system reliability. Flag for review