Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: breaker sizing

User: zooby, Location: Indiana

Asked on: Wednesday, November 5, 2025 at 1:54 pm EST
Answered on: Wednesday, November 5, 2025 at 1:54 pm EST

Question: Scenario--- padmount to ATS -"normal power" lands on 200A CB.150A CB at generator to ATS emerg. power. I not saying this is wrong but curious why not use a 200A at the generator? Thoughts ?

Okay, let's break down why a 150A breaker might be used at the generator connection to an ATS, even when the utility feed is protected by a 200A breaker. There are several reasons, and it's not necessarily "wrong" – it depends on the specific design and load requirements.Here's a breakdown of the possible reasoning

Key Considerations
Load Size and Generator Capacity

The most crucial factor is the actual load the generator is intended to carry.


Generator Rating (kVA/kW)

The generator's capacity dictates the maximum current it can safely supply.

Code Requirements (NEC, etc.)

Electrical codes play a significant role in sizing breakers and conductors.


Coordination & Selective Coordination

Breakers are sometimes intentionally sized to trip in a specific order to minimize outages.

Possible Reasons for the 150A Breaker


Generator's Capacity Limits



The generator might be sized to supply a maximum of 150A at the voltage it provides.
Even if the normal power feed is 200A, the generator might not be capable of supplying that much current. Overloading a generator can damage it. A 150A breaker protects the generator from overcurrent. Example: Let's say the generator is a 480V, 3-phase unit rated at 125 kVA. The full-load current is roughly 150A (125,000 VA / (480V √3) ≈ 150A). In this case, a 150A breaker makes perfect sense.2. Designed Load Calculation



The engineering design may have determined that the critical load supported by the generator never exceeds 150A.
The 200A breaker on the utility feed might be there to accommodate future load growth, surge capacity, or other non-critical loads that the generator won't power. Engineers perform a load calculation to determine the maximum demand the generator will realistically serve during an outage. This calculation considers factors like lighting, essential equipment, and HVAC.3. Conductor Ampacity



The conductors running from the generator to the ATS might be rated for 150A.
The breaker must protect the conductors from overcurrent. If the wiring is only rated for 150A, a larger breaker would be a code violation and a safety hazard.4. Selective Coordination

In some critical applications (hospitals, data centers), selective coordination is required. This means that the breaker closest to the fault should trip first, minimizing the impact of the outage. The 150A breaker might be sized to coordinate with other downstream breakers. The goal is to prevent the 200A breaker from tripping unnecessarily and shutting down more of the system than needed.5.

Code Compliance (NEC 700, 701, 702)

The National Electrical Code (NEC) and other local codes provide specific guidelines for emergency and standby power systems. These codes dictate breaker sizing, conductor ampacity, and other safety requirements. The 150A breaker might be necessary to comply with these codes based on the specific installation. Specifically, NEC Article 700 (Emergency Systems), Article 701 (Legally Required Standby Systems), and Article 702 (Optional Standby Systems) dictate different requirements.6.

Starting Current Considerations
Some loads may have a significantly higher starting current (e.g., motors). The 200A breaker on the utility side might be chosen to handle this inrush current. If the generator is not intended to handle these loads, the 150A breaker could protect it.

Why NOT a 200A Breaker at the Generator (Even if it
Could Handle It)



Unnecessary Cost

A 200A breaker is more expensive than a 150A breaker. If the generator can't supply 200A, or the conductors are not rated for it, there's no point in spending extra money on a larger breaker.

Less Protection

A smaller breaker provides better protection for the generator and conductors against overcurrent. If a fault occurs and the generator is trying to supply more than 150A, the 150A breaker will trip faster than a 200A breaker.


Potential for Damage

If the generator is only designed to provide 150A, a 200A breaker could allow it to be overloaded, potentially damaging the generator.

In summary:


The 150A breaker at the generator is likely there to protect the generator itself, the conductors, or to ensure proper coordination within the electrical system. It's not necessarily an error. To determine if it's appropriate, you'd need to know: The generator's kVA/kW rating and voltage. The actual load being supported by the generator. The conductor ampacity between the generator and the ATS. Any applicable code requirements. Whether selective coordination is a design requirement.Without that information, it's impossible to say definitively whether a 200A breaker should* be used instead. The design is almost certainly intentional, driven by one or more of the reasons above. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question