Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 2023 - 220.70 Energy Management Systems

User: Rock86, Location: new york

Asked on: Wednesday, November 5, 2025 at 3:43 pm EST
Answered on: Wednesday, November 5, 2025 at 3:43 pm EST

Question: As NYS is about to adopt the 2023 NEC, and make some drastic energy code changes, I am trying educate myself on Energy Management Systems and how to incorporate them into new designs. I watched Ryan Jackson's video on 220.70 and he made it sound like you can basically size the load how you would like and program the management system to handle the rest (obvious with some validity).Does anyone have experience with the systems and can share how they have integrated them? Can you use them to size your service entrance equipment? Do any of the big equipment companies provide training for these systems? Any Pros & Cons from person experience?Thank you all.

You're right to be looking into Energy Management Systems (EMS) with the upcoming NEC 2023 and energy code changes in NYS. Ryan Jackson's video is a good starting point, but the reality is nuanced. Let's break down EMS and how they relate to service entrance sizing

What are Energy Management Systems (EMS)?
Definition

An EMS is a system that monitors, controls, and optimizes energy consumption within a building. This can include lighting, HVAC, plug loads, and other electrical equipment.


Components



Sensors

Measure energy usage, temperature, occupancy, etc.


Controllers

Receive sensor data and execute pre-programmed or adaptive control strategies.

Software/Interface

Allows monitoring, programming, and reporting.


Communication Network

Connects all components.

Functionality



Load Shedding

Reduces peak demand by temporarily turning off or reducing power to non-critical loads.

Demand Limiting

Prevents the building from exceeding a pre-set demand limit.


Occupancy-Based Control

Adjusts lighting and HVAC based on occupancy.

Scheduling

Turns equipment on and off based on time of day or day of week.


Monitoring & Reporting

Tracks energy consumption and provides reports to identify areas for improvement.

Can You Use EMS for Service Entrance Sizing? (The Crucial Question)


Yes, BUT with SIGNIFICANT CAVEATS. NEC 220.70 allows for demand factors to be applied to feeder and service calculations based on load control under engineering supervision. Here's the breakdown: NEC 220.70 (2023 NEC - Likely in NYS Adoption)

This section allows for reduced demand factor calculations for service and feeder sizing where the design incorporates continuous monitoring, control, and reduction of the maximum demand using load control or peak demand limiting equipment.

Key Phrase

"Under engineering supervision." This is crucial. You need a qualified engineer to design, implement, and certify the EMS is functioning as intended.


Documentation is Paramount

You'll need to provide detailed engineering calculations demonstrating how the EMS will reliably reduce peak demand and ensure that the service entrance equipment will be adequately sized even under worst-case scenarios. You need to prove its efficacy.

How It Works (Theoretically)


Comprehensive Load Analysis

Analyze all connected loads and their potential demand profiles.2.

EMS Design

Design an EMS strategy with specific load shedding or demand limiting programs. Identify which loads can be shed without impacting critical operations or safety.3.

Engineering Calculations

Calculate the maximum demand after applying the EMS strategy. This will involve demonstrating the reliability of the EMS to shed the loads, how long it can shed them, and the impact on the overall load profile.4.

Sizing

Size the service entrance equipment based on the reduced demand calculated in step 3.5.

Commissioning

Thoroughly commission the EMS to ensure it functions as designed.6.

Ongoing Monitoring

Continuously monitor the EMS to verify its effectiveness and make adjustments as needed.

Important Considerations & Potential Pitfalls



Reliability is Key

The EMS must be reliable. If the EMS fails, the service entrance equipment must still be able to handle the connected load. Consider backup power for the EMS itself.

Risk Assessment

Perform a thorough risk assessment to identify potential failure modes and their impact on the building.


AHJ Acceptance

The Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) will likely scrutinize your EMS design and calculations very closely. Be prepared to provide detailed documentation and defend your design.

Over-Reliance is Dangerous

Don't assume the EMS will always work perfectly. Account for potential manual overrides, human error, and unexpected load increases.


Complexity

EMS can be complex to design and implement. Properly trained personnel are required for commissioning and maintenance.

Cost

While EMS can save energy and reduce peak demand, the initial cost of the system and engineering services can be significant.

Practical Examples & Integration Strategies



HVAC

Strategically stage HVAC units, allowing the EMS to shed non-essential units during peak demand.

Lighting

Implement dimming controls and occupancy sensors to reduce lighting load.


Electric Vehicle Charging

Stagger EV charging and reduce charging rates during peak demand.

Water Heating

Shed electric water heaters during peak demand.


Process Equipment

Certain industrial processes may be interruptible without significant impact.

Training and Resources



Equipment Manufacturers



Schneider Electric

Offers training on their EcoStruxure Power Monitoring Expert and other EMS solutions.

Siemens

Provides training on their Desigo CC and other building automation systems.


Johnson Controls

Offers training on their Metasys building automation system.

Eaton

Offers Power Xpert Energy Management.
Many other smaller EMS providers.

Professional Organizations



ASHRAE (American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers)

Offers courses and resources on energy management.

IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers)

Provides publications and standards related to power and energy management.


Local Training Providers

Check with local community colleges or technical schools for courses on building automation and energy management.

Pros and Cons (Personal Experience - From others)



Pros



Reduced Energy Costs

Optimizing energy usage leads to lower utility bills.


Peak Demand Reduction

Lowering peak demand can significantly reduce demand charges.

Improved Building Performance

EMS can improve occupant comfort and productivity.


Sustainability

Reducing energy consumption contributes to sustainability goals.

Compliance

EMS can help meet energy code requirements and green building certifications.


Data and Insights

Detailed energy data provides valuable insights for identifying areas for improvement.

Cons



Initial Cost

The upfront cost of an EMS can be significant.


Complexity

EMS can be complex to design, install, and maintain.

Reliability Concerns

EMS must be reliable to ensure that critical loads are not interrupted.


Security Risks

Connected systems are vulnerable to cyberattacks.

Training Requirements

Properly trained personnel are needed to manage and maintain the EMS.


AHJ Acceptance

Gaining approval from the AHJ can be challenging, especially when using EMS for service entrance sizing.

Potential for Oversizing if Not Used Correctly

Paradoxically, if not planned carefully, the addition of EMS can lead to more loads on the electrical system, not less. This is especially true if the EMS is not well-integrated with the building's overall operational strategy.

Key Takeaways:
EMS can be a valuable tool for energy management and can potentially reduce service entrance sizing, but it requires careful planning, engineering, and implementation. NEC 220.70 provides a pathway, but it is not a shortcut. You must demonstrate the reliability of the EMS and its ability to reduce peak demand. Focus on understanding the specific loads in your building and how they can be controlled. Invest in proper training and consider working with experienced EMS providers and engineers. Communicate closely with the AHJ throughout the design process.* Thoroughly document your calculations and design decisions.By carefully considering these factors, you can determine if an EMS is the right solution for your project and how to effectively integrate it into your design. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question