User: MFS-PDX-313, Location: Tualatin, Oregon, USA
Asked on: Friday, November 7, 2025 at 1:55 pm EST
Answered on: Friday, November 7, 2025 at 1:56 pm EST
Question: I remember a while back, during a third-party safety audit, we (my coworkers and I) were shown that we were incorrectly switching signals.If you look at the picture below, the top version is the safe way. If you were to have a short between TB 1 and ground, it would blow a fuse/breaker. As opposed to the bottom version, where if there were a short between TB 2 and ground, it would render the leak switch invalid.If these relay coils are triggering power to a circuit that needs to be shut down, the upper version is the safe version.QUESTION: Do any of you fine folks know what standard this falls under, and what section? I want to say the inspector that pointed this out to us years back was referring to NFPA79 but I could be wrong.
You're likely on the right track with NFPA 79, Electrical Standard for Industrial Machinery, but without knowing the specific function of your circuit and the type of machinery involved, it's impossible to pinpoint the exact section. However, the concept you're describing falls under the broader principles of fail-safe design and risk reduction, which are central to NFPA 79 and other safety standards like IEC 60204-1 (which NFPA 79 is largely based on).Here's a breakdown of why the top version is safer and where to look in related standards
Why the Top Version is Safer (Fail-Safe Design):
De-energize to Trip
The top configuration is inherently safer because a short to ground between TB 1 and ground will cause the fuse/breaker to trip, de-energizing the relay coil. This action removes power from the controlled circuit, causing a shutdown. This is the essence of a "de-energize to trip" or "normally energized" safety circuit. The circuit needs power to remain safe. The loss of power makes the system safer.
Bottom Version - Dangerous
The bottom version allows the relay to remain energized even with a short to ground between TB 2 and ground. This masks the fault. The controlled circuit would continue to operate as if the leak switch was functioning correctly, creating a potentially hazardous situation. The leak is not being detected, and the circuit that's supposed to be shut down when a leak is detected, remains ON.
Relevant Standards and Sections (General Guidance)
While I can't give you a specific clause without knowing your exact application, here are areas to investigate within NFPA 79 and other related standards:
NFPA 79: Electrical Standard for Industrial Machinery Chapter 4: General Requirements
Focus on sections dealing with risk assessment, safeguarding, and control reliability. Look for concepts like "safety functions" and "performance levels" (PLr, PL).
Chapter 9: Control Circuits
This chapter addresses the design and construction of control circuits, including safety circuits. Specifically look at sections addressing:
Overcurrent Protection (e.g., Section 9.2.5)
How to properly size and place fuses/breakers.
Wiring Methods (e.g., Section 13)
How wiring is installed to minimize the risk of shorts to ground.
Emergency Stop Circuits (if applicable)
Emergency stop circuits must be designed to fail to a safe state.
Annex A: Explanatory Material
This annex provides helpful clarifications and examples that can aid in understanding the requirements.
IEC 60204-1: Safety of Machinery - Electrical Equipment of Machines (International Standard) This standard is the international counterpart to NFPA 79 and often contains more detailed information on safety-related control systems. NFPA 79 borrows heavily from IEC 60204-1. Look for sections on: Functional Safety Safety-Related Parts of Control Systems (SRP/CS) Performance Levels (PL) ANSI B11 Series (Safety of Machinery) If your machinery falls under a specific ANSI B11 standard (e.g., ANSI B11.1 for mechanical power presses), that standard may have additional requirements.
Key Concepts to Search For in Standards
Fail-Safe Design
The system should default to a safe state in the event of a fault.
Fault Tolerance
The ability of a system to continue functioning safely even with a single fault. (Single Fault Tolerance)
Risk Assessment
A systematic process to identify hazards and assess the risks associated with them. This assessment determines the required Performance Level (PLr) for the safety function.
Performance Level (PL)
A measure of the capability of a safety function to perform its intended function under foreseeable conditions. (PLr is the required PL, PL is the achieved PL).
Category (Safety-Related Parts of Control Systems)
A classification of the architecture of safety-related parts of control systems (e.g., Category 1, Category 2, Category 3, Category 4)
How to Find the Specific Section You Need
Identify the Safety Function
What specific hazard is the leak switch intended to mitigate?2.
Perform a Risk Assessment
Use a risk assessment methodology (e.g., ISO 12100) to determine the required Performance Level (PLr) for the safety function.3.
Determine the Category
Based on the PLr, determine the appropriate Category for the safety-related parts of the control system.4.
Consult NFPA 79 (or IEC 60204-1)
Using the information from steps 1-3, search the standard for sections that address the design, construction, and verification of safety functions with the required PLr and Category.
In summary, the upper version is safer because it embodies the principles of fail-safe design and will cause the circuit to de-energize upon a ground fault. Focus your research on NFPA 79 (especially Chapter 9), IEC 60204-1, and relevant ANSI B11 standards, looking for sections on safety functions, risk assessment, performance levels, and fault tolerance. You'll need to consider the specific application and the level of risk involved to determine the precise requirements that apply to your situation. Flag for review