User: Mr. Serious, Location: Oklahoma, USA
Asked on: Saturday, November 8, 2025 at 9:25 am EST
Answered on: Saturday, November 8, 2025 at 9:26 am EST
Question: I got dragged into this situation where a landlord was trying to replace meter cans on his 4-apartment house, and the city and inspector won't let him only replace the meter cans because the 4 individual services were originally only 40 amps each, and he wants to stay with that. Of course, I know that dwelling units now require minimum 100A service, but it doesn't make a lot of sense for these particular units. All appliances are gas and they want to keep it that way.To avoid having to run all new service wires and put 4 new panels, I suggested bringing it all under one service, and splitting off 4 feeders to the apartments. When doing it that way, if the load calculation comes up OK, would it be prohibited by code to re-use the existing 40-amp services, but make them (4) 40-amp feeders instead? It seems small for an apartment feeder, but these are small apartments without laundry facilities and I don't know if there is some minimum size require by code.I know that equipment grounding conductors would likely have to be added and grounds separated from neutrals in the existing main panels which would become sub-panels.I'm going to do a load calculation today and see how it comes out.
You're on the right track with the single service and multiple feeders approach. Let's break down the considerations
The Good News (and What You're Already Doing Right):
Single Service is a Smart Option
Converting to a single service is likely the most cost-effective and code-compliant solution if the existing services are truly inadequate.
Load Calculation is Crucial
This is absolutely the right first step. Don't skip any steps. You'll need to accurately assess the demand.
Grounding/Bonding
Yes, you must separate the neutrals and grounds in the existing panels when they become subpanels fed from the new service. You also must add a proper equipment grounding conductor (EGC) from the new service panel to each of the subpanels. Existing grounding practices, even if they were acceptable when the services were installed, are unlikely to be adequate as feeders.
The Question of 40-Amp Feeders
No Specific Minimum Feeder Size for Dwelling Units
The NEC doesn't mandate a specific minimum feeder size if your load calculation justifies it. However, be aware that inspectors will scrutinize a 40A feeder to an apartment, especially a modern one. It will raise a red flag, so your load calculation must be absolutely watertight.
NEC 215.2 Minimum Feeder Ampacity
While not a minimum feeder size for dwellings, NEC 215.2 outlines how to calculate minimum feeder ampacity. Ensure your load calculation aligns with the requirements of this section.
Practical Considerations
Even if code-compliant, 40A might be very restrictive for tenants. Future appliance upgrades (even a window AC unit) could easily overload it.
Future Proofing
Consider the long-term value. Bumping the feeders up to 60A or even 100A during this upgrade will provide significantly more flexibility and could increase the property's appeal to future tenants. The incremental cost might be worth it.
Code Considerations
NEC 220 (Load Calculations)
This is the bible. Use the standard method or optional method, as applicable. The more detailed your calculation, the better. Document everything!
NEC 230 (Services)
Relevant for the new single service. Ensure proper clearances, wiring methods, grounding, and overcurrent protection.
NEC 215 (Feeders)
Key for sizing the feeders to each apartment and for grounding requirements.
NEC 250 (Grounding and Bonding)
Critical for ensuring safety. Pay close attention to the differences between grounding electrodes, equipment grounding conductors, and bonding jumpers. The existing neutral-ground bond in the old service panels must be removed.
Important Points for Your Load Calculation
Cooking Equipment
Even if tenants say they only use gas, consider including a small allowance for occasional electric cooking (e.g., microwave, toaster oven). This is especially important if there's a countertop outlet near the gas stove.
Lighting
Use realistic lighting loads, considering that tenants might use multiple lamps.
Small Appliance Circuits
Factor in the required small appliance circuits, even if they seem unlikely to be heavily used.
Heating and Cooling
Although you say all appliances are gas, be sure to take into account space heaters and window AC units that tenants might use.
Demand Factors
You can apply demand factors as permitted by the NEC, but be conservative.
Recommendation
Comprehensive Load Calculation
Do it very carefully. Get a second opinion on it.2.
Talk to the Inspector
Discuss your plan with the inspector before starting any work. This can save you headaches later. Explain your reasoning for using 40A feeders (if your load calculation supports it), but be prepared to justify it thoroughly.3.
Consider Upgrading the Feeders
Even if the load calculation allows for 40A, strongly consider increasing the feeder size to at least 60A, or ideally 100A, for added capacity and future-proofing.4.
Document Everything
Keep detailed records of your load calculation, discussions with the inspector, and all materials used.
In summary, while a 40A feeder might technically be allowed if the load calculation supports it, it's a risky proposition that could lead to problems later. Prioritize safety, compliance, and long-term usability. The increased cost of larger feeders is likely a worthwhile investment. Flag for review