Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 230.85 2020 nec with nyc ammendment

User: darekelec, Location: nyc

Asked on: Sunday, November 9, 2025 at 12:35 pm EST
Answered on: Sunday, November 9, 2025 at 12:36 pm EST

Question: In many many cases we have lateral entering 1-2 family home with meters inside.Poco meters can be operated (shut off) remotely.Can I keep service disconnects indoors without emergency disconnect outdoors?We don’t have rough in inspections here. Only final.Nyc ammendmentSECTION 230.85Section 230.85 – Add an Exception at the end of Section 230.85 to read as follows:Exception: If the emergency disconnecting means cannot be located in a readily accessibleoutdoor location, or if the utility metering equipment is located indoors, 1 of the followingdisconnecting means shall be permitted:1. A remote disconnecting means provided by the utility2. An indoor shunt-trip disconnecting means with the control device located in a readily accessibleoutdoor location and marked, “Remote Emergency Disconnect”3. An approved equivalent means.Thank you

Okay, let's break down the NYC amendment and your situation. Here's the interpretation, focusing on the key points and addressing your question

Understanding the NYC Amendment (230.85 Exception):

The NYC amendment to 230.85 (Emergency Disconnects) directly addresses situations where an outdoor emergency disconnect isn't feasible or desirable. It allows alternatives to a traditional outdoor disconnect, specifically in situations where: Either

An outdoor emergency disconnect is not readily accessible.


Or

The utility metering equipment is located indoors.

Your Situation



Lateral Entry, Meters Inside

This triggers the second condition of the exception.


Poco Remote Meter Shutoff

Your utility (Poco) has the capability to remotely disconnect power at the meter.

Service Disconnects Indoors

You want to keep your service disconnects (main breaker)
inside the dwelling.

No Rough-In Inspections

This simplifies the process, but it's crucial to ensure everything meets code during the final inspection.

Answer to Your Question: Can I Keep Service Disconnects Indoors WITHOUT an Emergency Disconnect Outdoors?
Yes, potentially. The NYC amendment, given your specific circumstances, seems to allow for keeping the service disconnect indoors without an outdoor emergency disconnect IF ONE of the conditions described in your amendment is satisfied.

Analysis

You have the utility meters inside. That means one of the exception conditions is satisfied. Based on this, you have three options.1. Utility Remote Disconnect

If the remote disconnect provided by the utility meets the requirements of the electrical inspection, you can keep your service disconnect indoors without an emergency disconnect outdoors.2.

Indoor Shunt-Trip with Outdoor Control

You could install an indoor shunt-trip breaker (a breaker that can be remotely tripped) and have a clearly marked "Remote Emergency Disconnect" control device mounted in a readily accessible outdoor location.3.

Approved Equivalent Means

This is a more ambiguous option. "Approved equivalent means" means the electrical inspector will have to approve your disconnect setup.

Important Considerations and Recommendations


VERIFY WITH YOUR ELECTRICAL INSPECTOR

This is absolutely critical. Interpretations of code can vary. Contact the NYC electrical inspection authority before you proceed with the installation. Explain your situation and ask for confirmation that the utility's remote shut-off is acceptable under the amendment and how they would inspect such a system. Get it in writing if possible. You can also describe your intention for an "approved equivalent means" setup and get the inspector's approval BEFORE installation.2.

Documentation from the Utility

Obtain official documentation from the utility describing their remote disconnect capabilities and procedures. This documentation should detail how quickly the disconnect can be initiated, the reliability of the system, and any relevant safety features. This documentation is essential for the inspector.3.

Accessibility and Labeling

Even with a remote disconnect, ensure the indoor service disconnects are readily accessible (not blocked by furniture, stored items, etc.). Label them clearly.4.

Coordination with Utility

Coordinate with the utility company about any remote shutoff considerations. Are there procedures to follow for turning on and off the power remotely?5.

Proper Installation

Regardless of which option you choose, ensure the installation meets all other applicable requirements of the NEC and NYC amendments.

In Summary:


The NYC amendment provides you with options for indoor service disconnects, especially with indoor metering and a utility remote disconnect. But, it's essential to proactively engage with the electrical inspector and the utility company to ensure your installation complies with their specific requirements and interpretations. Don't rely solely on online interpretations; get official guidance. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question