User: hou628
Asked on: Monday, November 10, 2025 at 12:58 pm EST
Answered on: Monday, November 10, 2025 at 12:59 pm EST
Question: For a current project, an existing 25HP blower (continuous) is installed with a 100A breaker. Per NEC 430.250 the FLC, is 34A meaning the 250% breaker sizing would be 85A. I believe the 100A was chosen as the motor will be replaced in the future to 50HP.Questions:For the current setup, is the 100A acceptable per NEC code OR should the breaker size be reduced to 80A?If the load was not continuous would the 100A be acceptable?Thanks!
Okay, let's break down this motor circuit protection scenario according to the NEC.
Understanding the Relevant NEC Articles NEC 430.22 (Single Motor) - Conductors supplying a single motor. It usually requires conductors rated at least 125% of the motor's FLC (Full-Load Current). NEC 430.52 (Motor Branch-Circuit Short-Circuit and Ground-Fault Protection) - Sizing the overcurrent protection device (OCPD), such as a circuit breaker. This is where the 250% comes in. NEC 430.24 (Several Motors or a Motor(s) and Other Load(s)) - Deals with circuits supplying multiple motors or motors and other loads. Not as applicable here. NEC 430.6(A)(1) - Use the tables in the NEC for FLC values, not the motor nameplate (unless otherwise permitted). In this case, you're using Table 430.250 for 3-phase AC motors. NEC 430.52(C)(1) deals with sizing of instantaneous trip circuit breakers (inverse time breakers as you've specified)Analysis of Your Scenario1. Current 25HP Motor, Continuous Load, 100A Breaker FLC
As you stated, the FLC for a 25HP, 460V motor is 34A per NEC Table 430.250.
Maximum Breaker Size (NEC 430.52(C)(1))
34A 250% = 85A.
Is 100A Acceptable? No, the 100A breaker is not acceptable for the current 25HP motor in a continuous application. NEC 430.52(C)(1) states that if the calculated value does not correspond to a standard size breaker, the next higher standard size may be used. Thus, because 85A is not a standard breaker size, it could be bumped up to 90A if it is a standard size. Bumping it up all the way to 100A is not permissible.2. Future 50HP Motor, 100A Breaker (Planning Ahead) The FLC for a 50HP, 460V motor is 65A per NEC Table 430.250. Maximum Breaker Size: 65A 250% = 162.5A For a 50HP motor the 100A would not be acceptable. The OCPD would be tripping often.3. Non-Continuous Load If the load is not continuous (defined as operating at maximum current for 3 hours or more), the same rules still apply for the overcurrent protection. The duty of the motor doesn't directly affect the short-circuit and ground-fault protection sizing. The breaker is there to protect the circuit conductors and the motor from faults, regardless of how long the motor runs.
Recommendations and Considerations Correcting the Breaker Size
For the existing 25HP motor, the breaker should be reduced. Either to 80A or 90A.
Future Motor Upgrade
If you know you will be upgrading to a 50HP motor relatively soon, there are a few options:1.
Temporarily Install the Correct Breaker
Install an 80A or 90A breaker now to comply with the code for the 25HP motor. Then, when you upgrade the motor, replace the breaker with the appropriate size for the 50HP motor (Likely 175A based on 65A FLC 250%). You will also need to ensure the conductors are sized appropriately for the 50HP.2.
Install a Disconnect
You could install a disconnect with fuses rated to protect the 25HP motor. This setup would comply with NEC requirements for both the conductors and the motor.
Important Notes
Local Codes and AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)
Always check with your local electrical inspector or AHJ. They may have specific interpretations or requirements that supersede the general NEC guidelines.
Conductor Size
Ensure the circuit conductors (wires) are sized correctly for both the current 25HP motor and the future 50HP motor. Conductors must be rated at least 125% of the motor's FLC (NEC 430.22). If the conductors are not sized for the 50HP, you must replace them when you upgrade the motor.
Motor Nameplate vs. NEC Table
Always use the NEC tables for FLC unless the motor is specifically marked otherwise and the inspector approves.
In summary: For the current 25HP motor with a continuous load, the 100A breaker is not acceptable and should be reduced to 80A or 90A. The 100A breaker doesn't become acceptable until the 50HP motor is installed. Prior to changing the motor, changing the breaker to the appropriate size and adding a disconnect with the appropriately sized fuses is a better option. Remember to verify conductor sizing and consult with your local electrical inspector. Flag for review