Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Recessed LED Lights

User: Little Bill, Location: Tennessee NEC:2017

Asked on: Wednesday, November 12, 2025 at 11:49 am EST
Answered on: Wednesday, November 12, 2025 at 11:49 am EST

Question: I installed over 100 LED recessed lights in a new construction home about 3 years ago, in 2022. Starting in 2023, several of the lights have either totally stopped working, are intermittent, or flickering/strobing. The vendor has replaced them under the 5 year warranty. That is good, but I get no compensation for my labor. I think I have replaced 40 or 50 of them.There is no pattern of where the lights are failing. They have failed all over the house, from top floor, main floor, basement, and outdoors. Voltages appear good, connections are tight, no other electronics in the house have failed.I replaced all the lights in a high ceiling with a different brand as they are the hardest to get to. Two of them failed less than a year after being replaced.Is it just bad lights, or is there something else causing this?

It's incredibly frustrating to have such a high failure rate with relatively new LED recessed lights, even with replacements under warranty. Based on your detailed description, here's a breakdown of the possible causes, ranked by likelihood, and what you can do

Most Likely Culprits:

1. Poor Quality LED Fixtures (Most Likely)

This is the most probable cause, especially given the high failure rate and the fact that it's occurring across different areas of the house.

Why

Cheaper LED fixtures often use lower-quality components, particularly the driver (the small power supply inside the fixture that converts AC to DC). Drivers are often the first thing to fail. Manufacturing tolerances on these cheaper fixtures can also vary greatly, leading to a higher failure rate.

Symptoms align perfectly

Random failures across different locations. No apparent pattern related to wiring or circuit.2.

Voltage Spikes/Surges (Moderately Likely)

While you say voltages appear good, transient voltage spikes can be hard to detect with a standard multimeter. These spikes can damage the sensitive electronics in the LED drivers.

Why

Surges can come from the utility company, nearby lightning strikes, or even large appliances in your home cycling on and off (air conditioners, refrigerators, etc.).


Symptoms align, but less so

Could explain random failures, but you'd likely see issues with other electronics too. However, LEDs are often more sensitive than many other appliances.

Less Likely, But Still Possible

3.

Overheating (Less Likely, but Possible for Specific Lights)

While LEDs run cooler than incandescent bulbs, they still generate some heat. If the fixtures are tightly packed with insulation or installed in areas with poor ventilation, this can shorten their lifespan.

Why

Heat degrades the electronic components inside the LED fixture, especially the driver.

Symptoms

More likely to affect fixtures in insulated ceilings, near recessed housing, or in confined spaces.
Less likely given your all-over-the-house failure pattern, unless all your fixtures are poorly ventilated.4.

Supply Voltage Issues (Less Likely)

Even though you checked voltage, consider the following:

Neutral Wire Problems

A loose or corroded neutral connection somewhere in your electrical panel or in the wiring to the lights could cause voltage fluctuations, even if the hot wire voltage looks good. This is rare, but problematic.


High/Low Voltage from Utility

Extremely rare, but a sustained period of high or low voltage from the power company could damage sensitive electronics.

Why

LED drivers are designed to operate within a specific voltage range. Fluctuations outside that range can cause damage.


Symptoms

More likely to affect multiple lights on the same circuit, or potentially the entire house if the issue is at the main panel. Less likely if failures are truly random across all circuits.5.

Installation Issues (Unlikely Given Your Attention to Detail)

You mentioned tight connections, but double-check:

Loose Connections

Even a slightly loose wire nut or push-in connector can create resistance, generate heat, and cause intermittent problems.

Improper Wiring

While unlikely in new construction, verify that the wiring is correct for the type of fixture (e.g., no crossed wires, proper grounding).


Why

Poor connections lead to voltage drops, arcing, and eventual failure.

Symptoms

Typically affects only the specific lights with the faulty connection.

Troubleshooting and Solutions


Document Everything

Keep a detailed log of when each light fails, where it's located, and the date of replacement. This will help you identify any patterns.2.

Investigate the Electrical Panel



Check the Neutral Bus

Make sure the neutral wires are securely connected to the neutral bus bar in your electrical panel. Look for any signs of corrosion or burning.

Check the Ground Bus

Ensure proper grounding throughout the system.3.

Consider a Whole-House Surge Protector

Install a surge protector at your main electrical panel. This will help protect all the electronics in your home from damaging voltage spikes. This is generally a good idea even if it's not the primary cause of your LED failures.4.

Evaluate Ventilation

Ensure adequate ventilation around the recessed light fixtures. Remove any excessive insulation that might be trapping heat. Consider using IC-rated (Insulation Contact) fixtures if they are in contact with insulation.5.

Monitor Voltage More Closely

While a multimeter is useful, it doesn't capture transient voltage events. Consider using a recording voltmeter (voltage logger) to monitor the voltage over a period of time. This can help identify any voltage spikes or sags that might be causing problems. Your electrician can do this for you.6.

Replace with High-Quality Fixtures (Essential)

When replacing the failed lights,

use a different brand that has a proven track record of reliability.
Look for brands that are known for using high-quality components and that offer a longer warranty (more than 5 years). Pay more upfront to save on replacements. Read reviews before you buy. Consider dimmable fixtures, even if you don't plan to dim them. Dimmable drivers are often built to handle a wider range of voltages.7. Consult with a Qualified Electrician

Given the scale of the problem, it's wise to consult with a qualified electrician. They can perform a thorough electrical inspection to rule out any underlying wiring issues or voltage problems. They can also advise you on the best surge protection solutions for your home.

Negotiating Labor Compensation (Difficult, but Worth Trying)



Review the Warranty Details Carefully

See if the warranty has any clauses about labor compensation. Most do not, but it's worth checking.

Contact the Vendor Again

Explain the ongoing problem and the significant amount of your time involved in replacing the lights. Politely ask if they can offer any compensation for your labor, even if it's just a partial reimbursement. Be prepared to document the number of hours you've spent replacing the lights.


Consider Small Claims Court

If the vendor is unwilling to help, you could consider filing a claim in small claims court to recover your labor costs. However, this may not be worth it due to the time and effort involved.

In summary, I strongly suspect the issue is with the quality of the LED fixtures themselves. Replacing them with a reliable brand is the key to resolving this problem long-term. Also, install surge protection for the whole house as a precaution.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question