User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Thursday, November 13, 2025 at 7:44 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, November 13, 2025 at 7:44 am EST
Question: Curious others thoughts who've been on very big jobs.If you had a project that would have an average of about 15-17 electricians and consisted of ONLY lighting and power/mechanical. Renovation existing 8 story building. Footprint about about 200'x150' each floor.1. 60% large feeders(EM and norm) and distribution equipment2. 20% MI cable3. 20% fit-outI would obviously have a dedicated non working general foreman and another layout guy( thanks inf) for a little while but would there be a need for a sub foreman either working or non working. I have heard of some very large jobs( depending on number of men) having several sub foreman. This job may peak at 25' electrician at high point.
Okay, let's break down whether you need a sub-foreman (or multiple) on this project, considering the scale, scope, and potential peak manpower.
My Take (Based on Experience with Similar-Sized Projects)
Yes, you almost certainly need at least one sub-foreman, and possibly two depending on the sequencing and complexity. The sub-foreman should be working hands-on and actively managing a portion of the work.Here's the Reasoning
Span of Control
Even with a General Foreman and a dedicated layout person, managing 15-25 electricians effectively on an 8-story building with the given breakdown of tasks is incredibly difficult. The General Foreman will be spending a significant amount of time: Coordination with GC, other trades, and project management. Material management, procurement, and staging. Scheduling and task assignments. Addressing RFIs, submittals, and design changes. Safety and quality control. Problem-solving field issues.The layout person helps with initial layout, but doesn't provide direct supervision of the work. The General Foreman cannot be everywhere at once, seeing every issue, addressing questions promptly, and ensuring consistent quality. This is where a sub-foreman steps in.2.
Task Segregation & Specialization
Your project has distinct phases:
Large Feeders & Distribution
This is a critical path item and often requires specialized knowledge and coordination. Having a sub-foreman dedicated to this phase ensures it stays on track and that the more experienced electricians are focused on it.
MI Cable
MI cable installation is also a specific skill set requiring expertise. This is a great area for a sub-foreman to focus on and ensure proper installation and safety protocols.
Fit-Out
The fit-out phase is likely more spread out and involves a lot of detail work. This can be another potential area where a sub-foreman can manage the electricians and ensure a smooth completion of the project.3.
Renovation Complexity
Renovations are inherently more challenging than new construction. You'll encounter unforeseen conditions, as-builts that are inaccurate, and coordination issues with existing systems. More eyes on the ground are essential.4.
Project Timeline and Efficiency
Properly supervised electricians are more productive. A sub-foreman can provide just-in-time instruction, clarify ambiguities, and keep the work flowing smoothly. This translates to cost savings and adherence to schedule.5.
Quality Control
Having a sub-foreman directly overseeing specific portions of the work improves the overall quality. They can catch mistakes early, enforce code compliance, and ensure that the work meets the required standards.
How to Structure the Sub-Foreman Role(s)
Working Sub-Foreman
Absolutely. The sub-foreman must be a skilled electrician who actively participates in the work. They lead by example, demonstrate proper techniques, and can step in to help when needed. Their primary responsibility is supervision and ensuring quality, but they also contribute to the physical installation.
Number of Sub-Foremen
Consider these factors:
Project Phasing
Are the "feeder/distribution," "MI cable," and "fit-out" phases happening concurrently across multiple floors, or are they sequential? If concurrent and spread out, you likely need at least two sub-foremen (maybe even three depending on how much of the job is MI cable). If sequential, one might be sufficient, but you still need a second as you near project peak.
Floor-by-Floor Breakdown
Is each floor a separate "unit" or are tasks overlapping across multiple floors? If tasks are heavily overlapping across multiple floors you need another sub-foreman.
Skill Levels
Are you using mostly journey-level electricians, or a mix of apprentices and journeymen? More junior electricians require more direct supervision.
Union Rules
If your using a union, it's a contractual issue to have the correct ratio.
Example Scenarios
Scenario 1: Phased approach
Feeder/distribution first, then MI cable, then fit-out. One working sub-foreman focusing on each phase as it comes online would work.
Scenario 2: Concurrent phases, large crew, spread out
You need two sub-foremen from the start, with possibly a third coming on during the peak "fit-out" phase. One focused on feeders and distribution, one focused on MI cable. Later in the job, the foreman on feeders and distribution will roll over to the fit-out as well.
Important Considerations
Communication
Establish clear communication channels between the General Foreman, sub-foreman (or sub-foremen), and the electricians. Regular meetings (even short daily huddles) are essential.
Authority
Clearly define the sub-foreman's authority and responsibilities. They need to be empowered to make decisions and address issues on their assigned areas.
Selection
Choose your sub-foreman carefully. They need to be not only skilled electricians but also good communicators, problem-solvers, and motivators.
Cost
The cost of an additional sub-foreman is almost always justified by the increased efficiency, quality, and reduced risk of delays. It's an investment, not just an expense.
In Summary:
On a project of this scale and complexity, at least* one working sub-foreman is essential. Two sub-foremen would be highly beneficial and would likely result in a smoother, more efficient, and higher-quality installation. The key is to assess your project phasing, crew composition, and floor-by-floor breakdown to determine the optimal number of sub-foremen. Don't skimp on supervision – it pays off in the long run. Flag for review