User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Thursday, November 13, 2025 at 8:17 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, November 13, 2025 at 8:17 am EST
Question: Probably overthinking this but trying to semi-design temp riser to 120/208v 100A panels on each floor(8 floors). I’m going to assume the calculated load is 80A.Would you run a separate 80A feeder to each panel( keeping in mind VD as you go higher) or would you run say a feeder capable of say 300A and run that for every 3 panels and splice down on each floor? SB is splice box.
You're right to be thinking about this, it's a multi-faceted problem! Here's a breakdown of the considerations and why one approach is generally preferred for your scenario
Factors to Consider:
Voltage Drop (VD)
This is crucial, especially in tall buildings. VD increases with conductor length and current. The further you are from the source, the bigger the impact. You generally want to keep VD under 3% on feeders and 5% overall.
Conductor Size and Cost
Larger conductors (higher ampacity) are more expensive.
Installation Labor
Splicing (with proper hardware) is labor-intensive and requires more space. Continuous runs are usually faster to install.
Panelboard Coordination
Having individual feeders allows for better selective coordination of overcurrent protection. A fault on one floor won't necessarily trip a breaker upstream affecting multiple floors.
Future Load Growth
Consider the possibility of increased electrical demand in the future. Over-sizing the feeders now might save headaches later.
Accessibility for Maintenance/Upgrades
Individual feeders allow for easier isolation and maintenance/upgrades on a per-panel basis.
Space Constraints
The riser space available for conduits is a major factor. Large bundled conductors in a conduit can be difficult to work with and may require pulling compound/lubricant.
Code Compliance
NEC (or your local electrical code) governs conductor sizing, overcurrent protection, and allowable voltage drop.
Heat Dissipation
Larger bundled conductors in a conduit generate more heat.
Analysis of Your Options
Option 1: Separate 80A Feeders to Each Panel (8 feeders total) Pros
Better Voltage Drop Control
This is the biggest advantage. Shorter runs mean less VD.
Improved Coordination
Easier to coordinate circuit breakers for selective tripping. A fault on one floor is less likely to take down multiple floors.
Easier Maintenance/Upgrades
Individual panel isolation.
Easier to accommodate future load growth
You can upgrade the feeder to a specific panel without affecting the entire system.
Cons
Potentially Higher Initial Conductor Cost
You are buying 8 individual sets of conductors.
More Conduit Runs Required
Could strain conduit space in the riser.
Higher Initial Labor
8 individual runs of conduit.
Option 2: 300A Feeder (or equivalent) with Splices (SB every 3 panels) Pros
Potentially Lower Initial Conductor Cost
Larger conductor quantity will be less than the separate feeders.
Fewer Conduit Runs
Potentially saves space in the riser.
Cons
Voltage Drop Issues
VD will accumulate over the length of the riser, especially at the higher floors. You'll need to do careful VD calculations to ensure compliance. This might necessitate very large conductors, negating the cost savings.
Complex Splicing
Splicing large conductors requires specialized tools, hardware, and skilled labor. Splice boxes take up space.
Potential for Overheating at Splices
Poor splices can create hotspots.
Coordination Challenges
A fault on one of the floors fed by the 300A feeder could trip the upstream breaker, affecting multiple floors.
Difficult Future Upgrades
Upgrading one floor's panel would require re-evaluating the entire feeder and possibly re-splicing.
Access/Maintenance Issues
If there's a problem with the 300A feeder, multiple floors are affected.
Less Flexible
Difficult to reconfigure in the future if needs change.
Higher Incident Energy at Panel
Higher Available Fault current at each Panel will mean higher PPE requirements.
Why Option 1 (Separate Feeders) is Generally Preferred for Your Scenario
Given your multi-story building and the desire for reliability and maintainability, running individual feeders to each panel is generally the better approach. The advantages in voltage drop control, coordination, and future flexibility outweigh the potentially higher initial cost.
Important Considerations and Steps
Load Calculation
Start with a solid load calculation for each panel, based on the intended use of each floor. Don't just assume 80A. Consider diversity factors.2.
Voltage Drop Calculation
Perform voltage drop calculations for both options, based on the calculated loads and the conductor length. Use the worst-case scenario (highest load). Use a voltage drop calculator or software.3.
Conductor Sizing
Size conductors to meet the ampacity requirements of the load and to minimize voltage drop. Consider using larger conductors than strictly required for ampacity to reduce VD.4.
Overcurrent Protection
Select appropriately sized circuit breakers or fuses for each panel and for the main service entrance equipment. Ensure selective coordination.5.
Conduit Fill
Carefully calculate conduit fill to ensure compliance with code. Consider using multiple smaller conduits if needed.6.
Riser Diagram
Create a detailed riser diagram showing the location of panels, conduit runs, splice boxes (if any), and conductor sizes.7.
Arc Flash Study
Perform an arc flash study to determine the appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE) required for working on the electrical system.8.
Engineering Review
Have a qualified electrical engineer review your design.
In Summary
While the upfront cost might be slightly higher for individual feeders, the long-term benefits of voltage drop control, coordination, maintainability, and future flexibility make it the better choice for your 8-story building. Option 2 is generally not recommended because of safety/maintenance and voltage drop.
Important Disclaimer: Consult with a licensed electrical engineer for the design and installation of your electrical system. Electrical work can be dangerous, and it must be performed by qualified professionals in accordance with all applicable codes and regulations. Flag for review