Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 230kV UG cable termination pothead and surge arrester support structure

User: adityalagudu3291, Location: Austin

Asked on: Friday, November 14, 2025 at 11:38 am EST
Answered on: Friday, November 14, 2025 at 11:39 am EST

Question: Does 230kV UG cable termination pothead and surge arrester support structure needs to be IEEE 693 seismic qualification in California? or ASCE 113 will be sufficient?At this stage, no vendor has been selected for either piece of equipment, and as such, it is unclear whether the final products will include prior seismic qualification, such as shake table testing or static pull testing. We are trying to avoid potential delays in the design and trying to find out whether we can proceed with ASCE 113. Please provide if there is references on this. Thanks.

This is a complex question with no absolute black and white answer. It depends heavily on the owner/utility requirements, local jurisdiction requirements, and criticality of the equipment. Here's a breakdown of the considerations and potential paths forward

Understanding the Codes and Standards
IEEE 693 (Recommended Practice for Seismic Design of Substations)

Considered the
gold standard for seismic qualification of electrical substation equipment. It provides detailed methodologies for seismic design, including performance criteria, site-specific ground motion parameters, and various qualification methods (e.g., shake table testing, static coefficient analysis, experience data). Crucially, it's a performance-based standard. It focuses on ensuring the equipment performs its intended function after a specified seismic event.

ASCE 113 (Substation Structure Design Guide)

Focuses primarily on the structural design of substation structures. It provides guidelines for the design of steel and concrete structures that support substation equipment. It addresses seismic loading as one of the design considerations, using methods consistent with the IBC (International Building Code) and ASCE 7 (Minimum Design Loads and Associated Criteria for Buildings and Other Structures). It is a prescriptive standard.

Key Considerations for Your Decision
1. Owner/Utility Requirements

This is the MOST important factor. Many California utilities (e.g., PG&E, SCE, SDG&E) have their own stringent seismic requirements for substation equipment, often referencing or exceeding IEEE 693. You must check the specific requirements of the owner of the substation. They might explicitly mandate IEEE 693 qualification for certain equipment, especially for high-voltage components like cable terminations and surge arresters. Contact them early in the design process to clarify their expectations. Their specifications supersede general code interpretations.2.

Local Jurisdiction (e.g., City/County) Requirements

The local jurisdiction (building department) will also have its own requirements for seismic design, often based on the California Building Code (CBC), which in turn references ASCE 7. While they might not specifically mandate IEEE 693, they could require structural calculations to demonstrate the structure and attached equipment meet certain performance levels under seismic loads.
3.


Criticality of the Equipment

How critical is the cable termination and surge arrester to the overall system's operation and reliability? A failure of these components could lead to prolonged outages, equipment damage, and safety hazards. Higher criticality often justifies more rigorous seismic qualification, leaning towards IEEE 693. Things to consider: Is this supplying a critical load (e.g., hospital, emergency services)? Is this part of a major transmission line corridor? Are there redundant systems in place?4.

Seismic Hazard Level

California is a seismically active region, but the level of seismic hazard varies significantly depending on location. Sites closer to major fault lines will experience higher ground motion during an earthquake. Higher seismic hazard levels typically warrant more rigorous seismic design and qualification. Use the USGS seismic hazard maps to determine the site's seismic hazard.5.

Equipment Supplier's Capabilities

While you haven't selected a vendor yet, it's important to consider the availability of IEEE 693 qualified equipment. Some manufacturers offer pre-qualified cable terminations and surge arresters, which can save time and money. If you choose a vendor without pre-qualification, you may have to pay for expensive shake table testing.

Can you Proceed with ASCE 113?
Potentially, but with significant caveats. You might be able to proceed with ASCE 113 for the structure supporting the pothead and surge arrester. ASCE 113 provides guidance on the structural design of substation structures, including seismic loads. However, this assumes that ASCE 113 addresses the seismic adequacy of the equipment being supported. ASCE 113 will not qualify the pothead and surge arrester. The Key Issue: Equipment Qualification. ASCE 113 primarily focuses on structural integrity, not the functional performance of the equipment during and after an earthquake. IEEE 693 is focused on functional performance as well. While you can design a structure using ASCE 113 to withstand seismic forces, that doesn't necessarily guarantee that the cable termination or surge arrester will continue to operate correctly. Bridging the Gap (Potentially Costly)

If the owner/utility doesn't require IEEE 693, you might be able to use a combination of ASCE 113 for the structure and a simplified seismic analysis of the cable termination and surge arrester to demonstrate they meet certain performance criteria. This could involve: Obtaining seismic fragility data (e.g., GRS - Generic Response Spectra) from the equipment manufacturer. Performing a static coefficient analysis (as allowed by IEEE 693) to assess the equipment's stability and stress levels under seismic loads. Verifying that the equipment's anchorage to the structure is adequate.

Recommendation
1. Contact the Owner/Utility Immediately

This is the most critical step. Ask them specifically what seismic qualification requirements apply to 230kV UG cable termination potheads and surge arresters in their substations. Get it in writing.2.

Consult with a Qualified Structural Engineer

Engage a structural engineer experienced in substation design and seismic qualification of equipment. They can help you navigate the applicable codes and standards, perform the necessary calculations, and develop a cost-effective seismic design strategy.3.

Investigate IEEE 693 Compliance Early

Even if not explicitly mandated, research the availability and cost of IEEE 693 qualified equipment. It might be cheaper in the long run to purchase pre-qualified equipment than to perform extensive seismic analysis and potentially require on-site modifications later.4.

Factor in Vendor Lead Times

Seismic qualification, especially shake table testing, can significantly increase equipment lead times. Start the procurement process early to avoid delays.

References
IEEE 693

Recommended Practice for Seismic Design of Substations



ASCE 113

Substation Structure Design Guide

ASCE 7

Minimum Design Loads and Associated Criteria for Buildings and Other Structures



California Building Code (CBC)

References ASCE 7 for seismic design.


USGS Seismic Hazard Maps

[https://www.usgs.gov/natural-hazards/earthquake-hazards/hazard-maps](https://www.usgs.gov/natural-hazards/earthquake-hazards/hazard-maps)

In summary, you cannot assume that ASCE 113 alone is sufficient. You need to determine the specific requirements of the owner/utility and local jurisdiction and then develop a comprehensive seismic design strategy that addresses both the structural integrity of the support structure and the functional performance of the cable termination and surge arrester during and after an earthquake. Ignoring IEEE 693 could lead to costly rework and project delays later on. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question