Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Detached Garage Code Issues after a Fire

User: hitehm, Location: Las Vegas NV

Asked on: Friday, November 14, 2025 at 5:44 pm EST
Answered on: Friday, November 14, 2025 at 5:46 pm EST

Question: Our customer's detached garage had an electrical fire that started in the attic space and he wants to know if there were any obvious violations. The garage was built with the house in 1995. The garage is supplied by a 3 wire, 100A feeder inside the main switch panel in the main house on 1awg aluminum to an MLO panel in the garage. The feeder has NO ground wire run with the 2 hots and neutral and the N and G bars and not bonded inside the garage subpanel.Violations:1 - I know this was built under some 1990s code but the first violation that I'm guessing was code even back then is, being a separate building supplied by a feeder, there is no disconnect mean at the building. The feeder attaches directly to the MLO subpanel with not separate disco. It has more than 6 breakers btw so the 2-6 rule is not valid.2 - I understand prior to 2008, 250.32.B.2 allowed the option to run the feeder w/o an EGC and use the grounded N conductor as the ground fault path back to the main panel. However, doesn't this require N and G to be bonded in the subpanel? Otherwise, how would a ground fault, let's say up in the attic space, make its way from the branch circuit EGC to the grounded N to clear the fault? In fact, all of the branch circuit ground wires terminate on the subs grounding terminal strip and, other than being connected to the building grounding system (GEC), they go nowhere after that. So they basically do nothing as far as EGC.3 - The feeder conduit also has 2 branch circuits leaving the subpanel going back down the conduit, one to the gate motor and the other is unlabeled. I see no issue with feeders and branch cons in the same conduit but we couldn't find any junction box above ground where they would separate out those branch circuits. So is it buried under the concrete, or worse?Any input agreeing or disagreeing or if more info is needed to determine this accurately would be helpful. I hate being that guy that calls out previous work without having all my facts straight.

Okay, let's break down these potential violations in the detached garage electrical system. You're right to be cautious and thorough.

General Comments Code at the Time

It's crucial to determine the specific edition of the NEC adopted by the jurisdiction in 1995. You'll want to reference a copy of that code for absolute certainty. However, we can make some reasonable assumptions based on typical practices around that time.


Fire Origin

While you're looking for code violations, it's vital to determine the cause of the fire. Code violations can contribute to fires, but the actual ignition source is important for insurance and prevention.

Addressing the Violations


Here's my assessment, based on general knowledge of the NEC during the mid-1990s and forward

1. Disconnecting Means (Violation):
Agreement

You are correct. Even in the 1990s, the NEC generally required a disconnecting means at a separate building. The purpose is to allow for safe isolation of the power supply to the garage. The 2-6 handle rule doesn't apply when you have more than 6.


Specifics

The disconnect must be readily accessible, and it must disconnect all ungrounded (hot) conductors.

1996 NEC (Example)

If the 1996 NEC was in effect, it would fall under

225.31 - 225.39
(Disconnecting Means for Outbuildings). These sections require a disconnect.2. Feeder Without EGC (Significant Violation - Dangerous)



Agreement

You're essentially correct in your analysis. While a 3-wire feeder (2 hots, 1 neutral) was permitted under certain circumstances (specifically, pre-2008 NEC), the proper implementation was absolutely critical.

Key Issue: Bonding and Grounding - This is where the main problem lies!
If the garage subpanel uses a three-wire feeder (two hots and a neutral), then the neutral conductor must be used as the equipment grounding conductor as well. This means the neutral and grounding bars MUST be bonded together in the garage subpanel, and it can only be bonded at the subpanel. The Neutral and Grounding bars are not bonded in the subpanel. This creates an extremely dangerous situation. With the Neutral and Grounding bars separate in the garage subpanel: There is no low-impedance path for fault current to return to the source. A ground fault on a branch circuit would energize all grounded metal parts (enclosures, appliances, etc.) in the garage. This is a shock hazard. GEC is Required. A grounding electrode conductor (GEC) connected to a grounding electrode system (ground rod, water pipe, etc.) is required at the detached building. The GEC connects to the grounding bar. This is to provide a path to ground for lightning and other stray currents. Code References (Example)

In the 1996 NEC, 250.32(B) permitted this under specific conditions, and 250.32(B)(1) (if applicable) required the grounded conductor to be insulated.

3. Branch Circuits in Feeder Conduit (Possible Violation - Needs Further Investigation)



Agreement

Generally, running feeders and branch circuits in the same conduit is not inherently a violation, if the conductors are insulated for the highest voltage applied in the raceway.

The Real Problem: The Missing Junction Box
This is the biggest concern. Code requires that connections and splices be made in accessible junction boxes or enclosures. If you cannot find a junction box above ground, it's highly likely the splices are buried. This is a major violation because: It's a fire hazard (if connections are not properly made). It makes troubleshooting and repairs impossible without digging up the concrete. Recommendation

Further investigation is definitely needed to determine where those branch circuits are originating from and how they're connected. It's highly suspicious.

Voltage Drop
Depending on the load requirements for each circuit and the length of the circuits in the conduit, there could be a voltage drop issue.

Additional Considerations



Aluminum Conductor

Using aluminum conductors (especially in older installations) is generally fine if properly installed. Proper termination is critical to prevent oxidation and loose connections (which can cause overheating and fires). Check for signs of overheating, corrosion, or loose connections at the terminals in both the main panel and the subpanel. An anti-oxidant paste should have been used during installation.

Overcurrent Protection

Make sure the breakers in the main panel protecting the feeder are appropriately sized for the ampacity of the #1 AWG aluminum conductors.


Workmanship

Look for other signs of poor workmanship, such as loose connections, damaged insulation, or improper wiring methods.

In summary, the lack of a ground wire with the feeder, with the ground and neutral bars not bonded in the subpanel is the biggest issue and a serious safety hazard, followed by the missing JB for the gate motor and unlabeled circuit
Recommendations


Consult a Qualified Electrician

The homeowner needs to hire a licensed and experienced electrician to thoroughly inspect the entire electrical system in the garage. The electrician should be familiar with the NEC editions in effect at the time of the original installation and current code requirements.2.

Correct the Grounding

The electrician must correct the grounding situation. The safest solution is to replace the feeder with a 4-wire system (2 hots, neutral, and EGC). The EGC should be connected to a grounding bar in the garage subpanel.3.

Install a Disconnect

A proper disconnecting means should be installed at the garage.4.

Investigate and Correct the Branch Circuits

The electrician must locate the source of the branch circuits running through the feeder conduit and ensure they are properly connected in accessible junction boxes.5.

Document Everything:
The electrician should provide a detailed report of all findings and the corrective actions taken.By addressing these issues, you can significantly improve the safety and reliability of the electrical system in the detached garage. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question