User: Tainted, Location: New York
Asked on: Saturday, November 15, 2025 at 10:12 am EST
Answered on: Saturday, November 15, 2025 at 10:13 am EST
Question: Does anyone here have any experience with Cogen units? This generator is typically inter-tied parallel with utility. Beckwith device are used for monitoring electrical parameters of the system between utility and cogen. The Beckwith device comes with 27, 59, 81, and 32 relaysI've seen many Cogens in NY, what is the process for filing? Must these plans be filed with Con-Edison?Who determines the setpoint settings for the 27, 59, 81, and 32 relays? Is it the utility?
Yes, I have experience with cogeneration (Cogen) systems, including their protection and interconnection requirements. Let's break down your questions
1. Filing Process in NY (specifically with Con Edison):
Yes, interconnection plans must be filed with Con Edison. They are the Area EPS Operator. The exact process and required documentation depend on the size and complexity of the Cogen system. Expect a multi-stage process: Preliminary Screening Study/Feasibility Study (often required)
This is the initial "does this even make sense?" stage. Con Ed will review the impact of your proposed system on their grid, identifying potential issues and upgrade requirements.
Detailed Interconnection Study (DIS)
If the feasibility study is favorable, this is a deeper dive. It involves detailed modeling of the grid at the point of interconnection and determines the exact technical requirements for safe and reliable operation. It's expensive.
Design and Construction Review
Con Ed will review your engineering designs and specifications to ensure compliance with their requirements.
Commissioning and Testing
Con Ed will witness commissioning tests to ensure proper operation before authorizing parallel operation.
Key Documents to Expect (may vary)
Single-Line Diagram
A detailed electrical diagram showing the Cogen system, interconnection point, protection devices (like your Beckwith relays), metering, and other critical components.
Protection Relay Settings
Detailed documentation of the settings for all protective relays, including 27, 59, 81, and 32, with justifications for those settings.
Equipment Specifications
Datasheets and specifications for all major equipment (generator, transformer, switchgear, relays, etc.).
Coordination Study
A study demonstrating that the protection system coordinates with Con Edison's existing protection scheme.
Operating Procedures
Documents outlining the normal and emergency operating procedures for the Cogen system, including start-up, shutdown, and response to grid disturbances.
Testing Procedures
Comprehensive documents outlining the testing procedures conducted during the Commissioning Phase of the generator.
Communication System Details
Details outlining all the systems involved in the telemetry and the communications protocol used.
Important Note
Con Ed's interconnection process is often time-consuming and complex. Engage a qualified consultant or engineering firm with experience in Cogen interconnection in New York as early as possible.
2. Determination of Relay Setpoints (27, 59, 81, 32)
It's a collaborative effort, but Con Edison has the final say. Generator Owner/Engineer Proposes Settings
You (or your engineering consultant) will initially propose the relay settings based on:
Generator Capabilities
The generator's voltage, frequency, and power limits.
Local Load Characteristics
The needs of the local loads served by the Cogen system.
Protection Coordination
Ensuring the protection scheme coordinates properly (i.e., the Cogen system trips before causing problems on Con Ed's grid and vice-versa).
Applicable Standards
IEEE 1547, UL 1741, and other relevant standards.
Con Edison Reviews and Approves (or Rejects/Modifies)
Con Edison will meticulously review the proposed settings to ensure they protect their grid and do not create instability or reliability issues. They have the authority to require changes to the settings.
Coordination Study is Key
The interconnection study mentioned earlier is critical in determining these settings. It's a complex process, often requiring iterative adjustments and simulations.
Explanation of Relays and Their Importance in Interconnection
27: Undervoltage Relay
Detects low voltage conditions. Used to trip the generator if the voltage drops too low, preventing it from trying to support a severely sagging grid or causing damage to itself.
59: Overvoltage Relay
Detects high voltage conditions. Used to trip the generator if the voltage rises too high, preventing it from damaging itself or other equipment on the grid.
81: Under/Over Frequency Relay
Detects deviations from the nominal frequency (60 Hz in the US). Used to trip the generator if the frequency goes too high or too low, indicating a potential system imbalance or instability. This is crucial for grid stability.
32: Reverse Power Relay
Detects power flowing into the generator from the grid (i.e., the generator is acting as a load). This can indicate a fault or abnormal operating condition and triggers a trip to protect the generator.
Note
Some systems use a 32 to block export of power, if that is the inter-connection agreement.
Example of Coordination Considerations
Let's say you want your 81 relay to trip at 59.5 Hz. Con Edison might require a higher setting (e.g., 59.0 Hz) to ensure their grid can handle minor frequency fluctuations before the Cogen system disconnects. They want to avoid a cascade of Cogen systems tripping offline during a grid disturbance.
Key Takeaways
Engage Experts Early
Don't attempt Cogen interconnection without experienced engineering and consulting support. The regulations, technical requirements, and bureaucratic hurdles are significant.
Be Prepared for Costs
Interconnection studies, equipment upgrades, and Con Edison review fees can be substantial. Factor these costs into your project budget.
Prioritize Safety and Reliability
The primary goal is to ensure the safe and reliable operation of the grid. Be prepared to make compromises on your desired operating parameters if necessary.*
Communicate Effectively: Maintain open and transparent communication with Con Edison throughout the interconnection process.Good luck with your Cogen project! Flag for review