User: mannyb, Location: Florida
Asked on: Saturday, November 15, 2025 at 2:03 pm EST
Answered on: Saturday, November 15, 2025 at 2:04 pm EST
Question: We are working a service call where the customer/maintenance team at apartment complex recently working on roof. The maintenance people working on roof mentioned that while accessing roof they touched the aLuminum gutter they got shocked. They didn't test with meter but with their voltage tester pen and everyone's pen lights up. I know I know dont trust the pen but even our own pens would light up. We originally found a conduit leaning against the gutter and thought we disccovered the problem but no this was not it. We got on roof but nothing stood out. We tested gutter down spouts with meters but no clear results. We did show some voltage sometimes 6v to 120v but nothing definitive. We turned off the panel we suspected but still got the readings. Apparently this has been an ongoing issue but just now reported. There are 8 other units. We plan on monday to turn off each unit one by one and see if t goes away. We think maybe a screw may have penerated far enough in the wall to have pierced a live circuit. Just wondering if anyone has had similar situations.
Okay, this is a tricky one. Here's a breakdown of likely causes, troubleshooting steps, and things to consider, based on your situation
Possible Causes (Prioritized):
1. Neutral-Ground Fault
This is the most common culprit in situations like this. A neutral wire somewhere in the system has become grounded, creating a path for current to flow through the grounding system (including the gutters). Since the gutter is grounded, you are getting voltage readings.
Why this is likely
Explains the varying voltage readings. The voltage can fluctuate depending on load and the resistance of the fault.2.
Shared Neutral Issues
Multiple circuits sharing a neutral can sometimes cause problems, especially with older wiring. The increased load on the neutral can elevate its voltage, which can then bleed into the ground.3.
Wiring Faults (Screw through Wiring, Damaged Insulation)
As you mentioned, a screw piercing a wire is a possibility, especially if recent construction/renovation occurred. This is more likely to present with consistent readings not intermittent. Damage may be intermittent due to weather changes.4.
Inductive Coupling/Capacitive Coupling
While less likely to cause a shock, especially one felt by multiple people, nearby energized conductors can induce a voltage in the gutter, particularly if the gutter is running parallel and close to power lines or service entrance conductors. This usually presents as a lower voltage than a true fault.5.
External Sources (Less Likely, but consider)
Utility Transformer
A fault in the transformer supplying the building could cause a rise in ground potential.
Nearby Electrical Infrastructure
Proximity to other electrical equipment or infrastructure could be contributing.
Troubleshooting Steps (Monday's Plan - Excellent starting point)
Systematic Circuit Isolation (Your Plan is Key)
Document Everything
Before you start, create a clear record of your readings at various points on the gutter system (different downspouts, different sections). Note the time of day and weather conditions.
Individual Unit Isolation
Methodically turn off the main breaker of each unit, one at a time. Completely disconnect the unit at the main breaker, don't just turn off individual breakers within the unit's panel. This eliminates the entire unit from the equation. After each unit is switched off, recheck the gutter voltage.
Monitor the Gutter Voltage
Closely watch the voltage on the gutters after each unit is turned off. When the voltage drops significantly or disappears, you've isolated the offending unit.
Record the Unit
Clearly mark which unit eliminated the voltage.2.
Once You've Identified the Offending Unit
Internal Inspection of Unit Panel
Look for loose neutrals, burnt wires, evidence of overheating, or other obvious faults inside the unit's electrical panel. Tighten all connections.
Re-evaluate Neutral to Ground Connection in Panel
Check the neutral to ground connection in the offending unit. Is it loose or damaged? Ensure that it is making solid contact.
Appliance Check (Carefully)
Unplug all major appliances in the offending unit (refrigerator, oven, washer, dryer, etc.). Retest the gutters after each appliance is unplugged. Some appliances can leak voltage to ground.
Visual Inspection
Carefully inspect the unit for any visible signs of wiring damage, especially in areas where recent work has been done. Look for screws penetrating walls near electrical outlets or wiring runs.
Megger/Insulation Resistance Testing
Use a megger (insulation resistance tester) to check the insulation resistance of the unit's wiring, particularly between: Neutral and Ground Hot (ungrounded) and Ground Hot (ungrounded) and Neutral
Test for bootleg grounds on outlets
Use a 3-light tester to look for bootleg grounds.
Check appliances
Unplug all appliance and check to see if the voltage is gone. Check with a multimeter to see if any have voltage leaking to ground.3.
If the Problem Persists After Isolating a Unit
Investigate the Service Entrance
Carefully examine the service entrance conductors and the main panel feeding the apartment complex. Look for any signs of damage or corrosion.
Check the Grounding Electrode System
Verify the integrity of the grounding electrode system (ground rods, water pipe ground). Make sure all connections are tight and free of corrosion.
Contact the Utility Company
If you suspect a problem with the utility transformer or service, contact them for assistance.
Important Considerations
Safety First
Assume all metal parts are energized until proven otherwise. Use appropriate PPE (personal protective equipment) and follow safe work practices.
Qualified Electrician
This type of troubleshooting requires a qualified and experienced electrician.
Documentation
Keep detailed records of all tests, readings, and actions taken. This will be invaluable for future troubleshooting.
Voltage Tester Pens
As you noted, voltage tester pens can be unreliable and should not be the sole basis for determining if something is energized. Use a calibrated multimeter for accurate voltage measurements.
NEC Compliance
Ensure that all repairs and modifications comply with the National Electrical Code (NEC) and local electrical codes.
Liability
Since you are working on behalf of the apartment complex, be aware of your liability and ensure that you have appropriate insurance coverage.
Meter Reading
Try to use an analog meter to read the voltage. A Digital meter may read a ghost voltage but an analog meter will not read anything since it requires more voltage to move the needle.
Specific Tips for Your Situation
Focus on Units Adjacent to the Roof
Since the maintenance team was working on the roof, focus your initial investigation on the units directly below and adjacent to the area where they were working.
Look for New Penetrations
Pay close attention to any recent penetrations through the roof or walls, especially near electrical wiring.
Consider the Weather
If the problem is intermittent and related to weather conditions (rain, humidity), look for areas where water may be entering the building and coming into contact with electrical wiring.
Example Scenario:
Let's say you turn off unit #3, and the voltage on the gutters drops to near zero. This indicates that the fault is likely within unit #3. You would then focus your investigation on that unit, following the steps outlined above.This situation requires patience, persistence, and a systematic approach. By following these steps, you should be able to identify the source of the problem and restore safe electrical service to the apartment complex. Good luck! Flag for review