Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Using an electrical system grounding ring electrode in lieu of (instead of) dedicated grounding electrodes.

User: corvalan

Asked on: Monday, November 17, 2025 at 12:52 am EST
Answered on: Monday, November 17, 2025 at 12:53 am EST

Question: I still do not have a clear understanding of the following hypothetical situation. One of the existing electrical system grounding electrodes is a ground ring. This ground ring satisfies all the NEC requirements. We decided to install a brand new LPS. This LPS has five down conductors. I realize that the electrical system ground ring also satisfies all the rules of the NFPA 780 for a ground ring. I consider, then, in lieu of installing dedicated LPS grounding electrodes, to use the existing electrical system ground ring. Then I read that the NFPA 780 says, "Electrical system grounding electrodes shall not be used in lieu of lightning protection system grounding". This seems to be a problem because instead of installing dedicated LPS grounding electrodes, I am using an existing electrical system grounding electrode in direct violation of NFPA 780. Any thoughts?

You've accurately identified the core conflict: NFPA 780 explicitly discourages using electrical system grounding electrodes as substitutes for dedicated LPS grounding electrodes, even when the electrical ground electrode, like your ground ring, seemingly meets all the requirements.Here's a breakdown of the reasoning and potential solutions

Why NFPA 780 Discourages Sharing:
High Surge Currents

Lightning strikes inject massive, rapid-rise surge currents into the grounding system. These currents can induce damaging voltages in sensitive electronic equipment connected to the electrical system. A dedicated LPS grounding system aims to isolate these massive surges from the electrical system.


Equipment Protection

The intent is to protect electrical equipment from the damaging effects of lightning currents flowing through the electrical system. While the ground ring provides a low-impedance path to earth, sharing it with the LPS increases the potential for voltage rise and current flow within the electrical system during a strike.

Fault Current Considerations

The electrical ground ring is primarily designed to handle fault currents associated with electrical system failures. Adding LPS currents can potentially overload the ground ring, affecting its ability to safely handle electrical faults.


Maintenance and Testing

Having separate grounding systems simplifies maintenance and testing. Problems within one system (LPS or electrical) are less likely to cascade into the other.

Understanding the "In Lieu Of" Language

The phrase "in lieu of" is key. NFPA 780 isn't saying you cannot connect the LPS to the electrical ground ring. It's saying you cannot replace the required LPS grounding with only the electrical ground ring.

Possible Solutions and Interpretations

1.

Supplement, Don't Substitute

The best approach is to install the required LPS grounding electrodes in addition to connecting the LPS to the existing electrical ground ring. This means installing the five LPS down conductor ground electrodes as per NFPA 780. Then, you bond the LPS ground ring to the existing electrical system ground ring. This approach provides the dedicated grounding required by NFPA 780 while also utilizing the existing ground ring for equipotential bonding. This minimizes potential differences.2.

NFPA 780 and Equipotential Bonding

NFPA 780 emphasizes equipotential bonding. Section 4.14 of NFPA 780 discusses grounding and bonding requirements. It mandates bonding of metallic systems to the LPS ground system, and that can include bonding to the electrical grounding system. Section 4.
14.6 states, "Bonding to the grounding electrode system of a structure's electrical service shall be provided." So, a supplemental connection to the electrical grounding system is actually required in most cases.3.


Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)

In situations where installing completely separate LPS grounding is extremely difficult or impractical, you must consult with the AHJ. They may allow you to deviate from the strict interpretation of NFPA 780 if you can demonstrate that the existing electrical ground ring provides adequate grounding for both systems and that appropriate surge protection devices are installed within the building to protect sensitive equipment. You'll need to provide a detailed engineering analysis supporting your argument. This is the most challenging and least guaranteed path.4.

Engineering Analysis and Risk Assessment

Regardless of the approach, a thorough engineering analysis and risk assessment is crucial. This assessment should consider: Soil resistivity Ground ring impedance The magnitude and frequency of expected lightning strikes The sensitivity of the electrical and electronic equipment connected to the electrical system The adequacy of surge protection devices

In Summary:
The safest and most compliant approach is to install dedicated LPS grounding electrodes according to NFPA 780 and then bond the LPS grounding system to the existing electrical ground ring. Never rely solely on the existing electrical ground ring as a substitute for dedicated LPS grounding electrodes without documented approval from the AHJ and a comprehensive engineering analysis. Equipotential bonding between the LPS and electrical grounding systems is generally required, but this bonding should supplement, not replace, the dedicated LPS grounding.* Consult the AHJ early in the design process to discuss your specific situation and get their input on the acceptable approach.Remember to document all decisions and calculations for future reference. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question