User: NTesla76, Location: IA -Driftless Region
Asked on: Tuesday, November 18, 2025 at 7:50 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, November 18, 2025 at 7:50 am EST
Question: 2023 NECSingle family home has an emergency service disconnect outside (meter/main).Bonding screw is installed in emergency service disconnect4 wire from emergency service disconnect to interior panel.Interior panel has equipment ground bar installed. Neutrals and grounds separated.Grounding electrode conductors to concrete encased electrode and copper water line terminate in interior panel.I say 250.24 does not allow this.Another inspector says 250.118(B) Exception allows this.Any input?
You are correct. The second inspector is misinterpreting the code. Here's a breakdown of why: 250.24(C)(1) Exception 1: Grounded Conductor Brought to Service Equipment. This section allows for a grounded conductor (neutral) to be connected to the equipment grounding conductor at the service equipment. In your scenario, the emergency disconnect IS the service equipment, therefore the neutral should be bonded at this location 250.24(A)(5): Load-Side Neutral Connections. This section specifically prohibits connecting the neutral conductor to the equipment grounding conductor on the load side of the service disconnecting means. Your interior panel is on the load side of the emergency disconnect. 250.32(A): Buildings or Structures Supplied by a Feeder or Branch Circuit. Because this is a feeder, it can not be used as a service. The Emergency Disconnect
The emergency disconnect is the service equipment. Because it is an emergency disconnect it's still the location where the NEC requires the bonding of the grounded conductor (neutral) to the equipment grounding conductor.
Why the Other Inspector is Wrong
250.118(B) Exception
This section allows for metal water pipe to be used as an equipment grounding conductor. It ONLY applies to equipment grounding conductors. It does NOT override the fundamental rules about neutral-ground bonding. The fact that the metal water pipe is connected to the ground bar in the interior panel does not justify bonding the neutral at that location.
In summary
The only place the neutral should be bonded to ground is in the emergency disconnect enclosure (the service equipment) with the bonding screw. The interior panel MUST have separated neutrals and grounds. Grounding electrode conductors (to concrete encased electrode and water pipe) are correctly terminated in the interior panel, connected to the grounding bar.
The Correct Installation1. Install the bonding screw in the emergency service disconnect, effectively bonding the neutral and the enclosure/grounding system at the service.
2. Run a 4-wire feeder (hot, hot, neutral, ground) from the emergency service disconnect to the interior panel.3. In the interior panel: Connect the two hot wires to the main breaker. Connect the neutral to the neutral busbar. Connect the ground to the ground busbar. Connect the grounding electrode conductors to the ground busbar.* Ensure that the neutral and ground busbars are isolated from each other.
Your interpretation is correct. The other inspector is creating an illegal neutral-ground bond on the load side of the service equipment, which is a violation of the NEC. Flag for review