User: codycl, Location: DFW
Asked on: Tuesday, November 18, 2025 at 9:36 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, November 18, 2025 at 9:48 am EST
Question: Hey guys!In my 18 years in the trade, I have yet to need to come to a forum to ask for help, but the time has come.We are building a multifamily project with two sub-levels of garage with 5-stories of wood structure above. Basically, the two main electrical rooms that feed everything are in the basement below Level 1. I have chase/leave-out locations in the Level 1 slab above these two main electrical rooms with the plans of running SER from the equipment, through the leave-outs in the slab, then through the 5-story wood-framed structure to feed house panels and meter centers throughout.My issue is that there is a 3-hour firewall separating one of the sections. I have approval from the city to penetrate the firewall with electrical cable, as long as we use the correct fire device/assembly/method. Most of the SER will be 250 KCM 3-Phase Aluminum. I am familiar with 2-hour penetrations in walls and floors, but I reached out to our firestopping rep, and he said it would be "an engineering decision" regarding the 3-hour penetration.This is beyond anything I'm capable of figuring out on my own at this time, I dont understand the UL systems, etc, so if you can help me, I'll do my best to help you with a little consultation reward, haha. I'm desperate at this point.Thank you in advance
Alright, this is a tricky one, but definitely solvable. Here's a breakdown of what you need to do and how to approach it, along with explanations to help you understand the UL systems. I'll try to give you practical steps you can take right now.
Understanding the Problem Fire Rating
A 3-hour firewall means the barrier must resist fire for a minimum of 3 hours, preventing the spread of flames and smoke. Penetrations significantly weaken this resistance.
SER Cable
The SER cable itself isn't fire-rated. It will burn and melt, creating a hole through the firewall.
UL Systems
UL (Underwriters Laboratories) develops and tests firestop systems to determine their fire resistance. Each system is assigned a UL number, which documents the specific materials, installation methods, and fire-resistance rating achieved during testing.
Engineering Judgement
Your firestopping rep is right. A 3-hour fire rating for electrical penetrations, especially with larger conductors like 250 kcmil, often pushes beyond standard, readily available tested solutions. That's where engineering judgment comes in. It's not that it can't be done, it's that it likely requires a custom-engineered solution.
Steps to Take Now (Practical & Urgent)1. Re-Engage Your Firestopping Rep, But More Precisely
Be specific
Tell them exactly the type and size of cable you are using: 250 kcmil Aluminum SER cable, number of conductors, and cable diameter.
Reiterate the 3-hour requirement. Ask for their recommendations for firestop manufacturers that have engineers on staff who can assist with developing a custom engineered solution. They know the manufacturers best and which ones are most responsive. Emphasize your need for documentation that will satisfy the AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)
You need a letter or report from the firestop manufacturer stating that their proposed system meets or exceeds the 3-hour rating and is suitable for your specific application.
Don't be afraid to push back
If they can't provide specific recommendations, ask who they would recommend you contact directly for engineering support. You are paying for their expertise, make them earn it.2.
Contact Firestop Manufacturers Directly
Hold off on contacting the Firestop Manufacturer until you speak to the firestopping rep. The rep will be able to steer you in the right direction. If they cannot, call the main number of the top Firestop manufacturers. Be prepared with all the information
Cable type, size, number of conductors, penetration size, type of wall/floor (concrete, drywall, etc.), and specific firewall rating.
Ask for their engineering department directly. Explain that you need assistance specifying a 3-hour firestop system for electrical cable penetrations. Ask for Case Studies or Past Approvals
Inquire if they have dealt with similar situations. They might have a previously engineered solution that can be adapted.3.
Consider a Fire-Rated Shaft Enclosure (Possible Alternative - Requires Design Review)
Instead of individually firestopping each cable penetration, consider encasing all the cables in a fire-rated shaft enclosure as they pass through the firewall and extend upwards. This would create a protected pathway. This will likely require coordination with the architect and structural engineer. The shaft itself would need to be built with materials that meet the 3-hour fire-resistance rating. This may only be a viable solution if the penetration through the firewall is not yet complete, or is fairly large.4.
Document Everything! Keep meticulous records of all your conversations, emails, and recommendations from firestopping reps and manufacturers. This documentation is crucial for the AHJ.
Common Firestopping Products/Techniques (FYI)
Firestop Putty
Often used for small penetrations (e.g., small wires). Not typically suitable for large cable bundles.
Firestop Sealant
Applied around penetrations to prevent the passage of flame and smoke. Requires proper depth and backing materials.
Firestop Pillows
Bags filled with fire-resistant material that expand when exposed to heat. Useful for larger openings and cable trays.
Firestop Collars
Intumescent collars that are wrapped around combustible pipes and cables. They expand when heated, crushing the burning material and sealing the penetration.
Mineral Wool
Used as a packing material in larger openings, combined with firestop sealant.
Understanding UL Systems (Simplified)
UL systems are categorized by: Penetration Type
What is penetrating the barrier (e.g., electrical cables, pipes, ducts).
Construction Type
The material and thickness of the wall or floor (e.g., concrete, drywall, wood).
Fire Rating
The fire resistance rating (e.g., 1-hour, 2-hour, 3-hour).
Specific Materials and Installation
The exact firestopping products and installation methods used during testing.When you find a UL system that seems close, always verify that it matches your specific conditions. Small variations can invalidate the rating.
Example of a Possible Approach (Highly Dependent on Specific Products and Approvals)
Concrete Slab Penetration
You might need to core a slightly larger opening than the cable bundle requires.
Packing
Pack the annular space (the gap between the cables and the concrete) tightly with a fire-rated mineral wool packing material.
Firestop Compound
Apply a thick layer of a UL-listed firestop sealant on both sides of the penetration, embedding the cable bundle and mineral wool. The specific sealant and application depth will depend on the UL listing you find.
Firestop Collar
Using a Firestop Collar on each individual cable might be a solution if you have room.
Important Considerations
AHJ Approval
The Authority Having Jurisdiction (e.g., building inspector) has the final say. Get their input early in the process. Show them the UL systems you're considering and any engineering documentation you obtain.
Installation Quality
Proper installation is critical. Follow the manufacturer's instructions meticulously. Consider having a certified firestop installer perform the work.
Future Changes
If cables are added or removed in the future, the firestop system must* be re-evaluated and re-sealed.
The "Consultation Reward"
Don't worry about a consultation reward just yet. Focus on getting this solved. If you're still stuck after trying these steps, and if I can provide further specific guidance based on the manufacturer feedback you receive, then we can talk. Good luck! Let me know how it goes. Flag for review