Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Starter/OCPD

User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ

Asked on: Tuesday, November 18, 2025 at 3:10 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, November 18, 2025 at 3:10 pm EST

Question: I'm a little unclear as it relates to schedule below. E.g Some of the units indicate "M" for the disconnect which is a motor starter switch which to me is a thermal rated toggle or similar. Then those same units have combo motor starter which I beleive is a disconnect/starter unit combined. Does this make sense to have both the toggle switch and combo starter?

You're right to be confused! It definitely doesn't make sense to have a separate motor starter disconnect switch (the "M" you're seeing which you correctly identify as a thermal-rated toggle) and a combo motor starter on the same unit powering the same motor. That would be redundant and unnecessary.Here's a breakdown of why this likely isn't correct, and what might be happening: Redundancy

A combo motor starter
already includes a disconnect. That's one of its core features. The disconnect is typically a fused disconnect or a circuit breaker housed in the same enclosure as the motor starter (contactor and overload relay).

Purpose of a Combo Starter

A combo starter is designed to provide all the necessary functions for motor control and protection in a single unit:

Disconnect

Allows you to safely isolate the motor for maintenance.


Overcurrent Protection

Fuses or a circuit breaker to protect against short circuits.

Motor Starter (Contactor)

Electrically switches the motor on and off.


Overload Protection

Protects the motor from damage due to excessive current draw (overloads).

Possible Explanations for the Discrepancy


Error in the Schedule/Drawing

This is the most likely scenario. The schedule might be inaccurate. The "M" indicating a separate disconnect could be: A typo. Leftover from a previous design iteration where a combo starter wasn't used. Referring to a different piece of equipment altogether.2.

Very Unusual and Specific Circumstance (Highly Unlikely)

In
extremely rare situations, you might see something like this, but it would need a very specific justification. For example:

Dual Power Feed

If the motor has two separate power feeds for redundancy (e.g., one normal, one emergency), you might have a disconnect for each feed. However, even then, the combo starter would only be on one of the feeds.

Special Local Codes or Requirements

Some local regulations might have unusual requirements. But again, this is very unlikely.


Extremely High Current Motor

In some cases of very high current motors where interrupting rating is a concern, a disconnect switch might be installed

before
the combo starter to safely de-energize it for maintenance.

Next Steps


Double-Check the Schedule

Look for any notes or clarifications that might explain the "M" notation. Are there any related drawings that show the physical wiring?2.

Consult the Electrical Drawings

The electrical one-line diagrams and wiring schematics are crucial. They will show exactly how the motor is wired and what components are in the circuit.3.

Talk to the Electrical Designer/Engineer

The person who created the schedule and drawings is the best resource for resolving this ambiguity. Ask them why there's a disconnect switch ("M") in addition to the combo starter.4.

Field Verification

If possible, visually inspect the actual installation. See what's physically present. The schedule could be out of date.

In summary, don't assume the schedule is correct without verifying it. Start with the drawings and then talk to the electrical designer to understand the intent and clarify the discrepancy.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question