User: goldstar, Location: New Jersey
Asked on: Wednesday, February 2, 2011 at 6:20 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:03 am EDT
Question: Just want to bring this to eveyyone's attention seeing as how I recently got tagged for this on a kitchen remodel. The ceiling rafters at this project were 2" x 8" construction, 12" on center. I used (8) Juno 5" non-IC cans as there was no insulation going into the ceiling, and (4) 5" non-IC remodel cans in the dining room (existing sheetrock). I had about a 1/8" clearance above the can but the inspector cited 410.116 stating that there had to be 1/2" clearance between the can and the flooring above if I'm using non-IC cans. This section of the NEC clearly states that and (for the most part) I can understand and see the logic of the ruling. If you're using 6" non-IC cans you can use up to 150 watt bulbs in the can and I'm sure the can could possibly get quite hot (though I can't imagine it could get hot enough to burn through the can and then through the flooring above). In contrast, a 5" can restricts you to a 65 watt bulb, irrespective of whether you use an IC can or not. I think this section of the NEC needs to be re-examined and redefined in cases where the can restricts the bulb wattage.I changed out the remodel cans and replaced the new work cans only and left the nail-on framing in tact. Took me about 3 hours to change out 12 cans.BTW, I'm also writing a book on "How to bid jobs real close and then lose money when you have little or no work to begin with". :grin:
Regarding the NEC Clearance Requirement
The NEC requirement for 1/2" clearance between non-IC cans and the flooring above is intended to prevent potential fires. Non-IC cans are not designed to be in direct contact with combustible materials, and heat buildup in the can could ignite these materials.While 5" non-IC cans have a lower wattage limit than 6" cans, it's important to note that even 65-watt bulbs can generate significant heat. This heat can still accumulate in the can and pose a safety risk.Therefore, the NEC requirement remains applicable to all non-IC cans, regardless of size or wattage.
Suggestions for the NEC
While the NEC requirement for non-IC cans is generally sound, it could be reconsidered in certain situations, such as: Where the ceiling contains no insulation, providing additional thermal protection. Where the can is recessed deeply into the framing, further minimizing heat buildup.However, any such changes would require careful consideration and testing to ensure that safety is not compromised.
Bidding and Job Losses:
The issue of bidding jobs closely and losing money is a common challenge in the construction industry. It's important to factor in all potential expenses, including materials, labor, and unforeseen circumstances, when determining your bid price.To avoid losses, it's crucial to: Estimate materials and labor accurately. Allow for a safety margin in your pricing. Stay within your budget during the project. Manage your expenses effectively.* Seek additional work to supplement your income when necessary. Flag for review