User: mshields, Location: Boston, MA
Asked on: Wednesday, February 2, 2011 at 11:46 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:03 am EDT
Question: Lets say you have a 2500kVA double ended lineup with transformers outside. And off of the double ended switchgear you've got multiple DP's. to find heat loss to hand over to our HVAC guys, I typically use various data I've received from manufacturer's over the years based on number and size of breakers plus bus size. But I'm wondering if I could just do the following:Assume a load of 80% of a single 2500kVA service (since system is a 2N).assume no more than average Voltage drop for loads off that system is 2%.Take the KVA using 480V subtract the KVA using 480V x 98%.Use the difference as the maximum heat loss.Is there anything wrong with this logic?I suppose that one thing would be the fact that much of the losses are occuring in the cable outside of the room. So your attributing more loss to the main room than there will actually be. But still - it's a safe approach is it not?Thanks,Mike
Your logic is generally correct and can provide a reasonable estimate of the heat loss in the electrical room. However, there are a few factors to consider: Cable Losses
As you mentioned, a portion of the heat loss occurs in the cables outside the room. This heat loss is not accounted for in your calculation. To get a more accurate estimate, you should include the cable losses in your calculation.
Voltage Drop
The voltage drop of 2% is used to estimate the losses in the distribution system. However, this voltage drop also includes the voltage drop in the cables outside the room. To get a more accurate estimate, you should subtract the voltage drop in the cables from the 2% assumed voltage drop.
Diversity Factor
The load factor of 80% is a reasonable assumption for a typical electrical system. However, it is possible that the actual load factor could be higher or lower than 80%. If the load factor is higher, the heat loss will be higher. Conversely, if the load factor is lower, the heat loss will be lower.
Transformer Losses: The transformers in the lineup also contribute to the heat loss. The heat loss in the transformers should be included in your calculation.Overall, your approach provides a reasonable estimate of the heat loss in the electrical room. However, it is important to consider the factors mentioned above to get a more accurate estimate.Here is a modified calculation that addresses some of the factors mentioned above:Heat Loss = (KVA @ 480V - KVA @ (480V - 2% Voltage Drop)) Power Factor Load Factor + Transformer Losses + Cable LossesBy using this calculation, you can get a more accurate estimate of the heat loss in the electrical room. Flag for review