User: richwaskowitz, Location: Shelby Twp. MI, near Detroit
Asked on: Thursday, February 3, 2011 at 10:55 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:06 am EDT
Question: Please, I just don't understand how "subject to physical abuse" can be so subjective!I got red tagged on a recent service and panel replacement when the inspector got all excited about some Romex and some UF cable which was exposed (stapled to a plywood panel attached to the wall) where it entered the panel and also where the UF passed through the exterior wall near the same opening as the SE cable and then ran a few feet to an A/C disconnect. He insisted that the cable to the A/C unit (strapped to the siding about 4 feet off the ground) was subject to physical abuse but that the SE cable was OK. How can that be? This is not near a driveway or patio and I just don't see where the risk is. Even if there is a potential risk to the A/C cable, why not the SE cable too? He made me build a plywood door to cover all the NM cables coming down out of the ceiling and running into the top of the panel (or I could have put them all in conduit). Is this inspector paranoid or do I need to anticipate this everywhere I go in the future? I think I might be missing something and I would really appreciate your opinions. I have never been hit for this before in 30 years.
Subjectivity of "Subject to Physical Abuse"
The term "subject to physical abuse" is indeed open to interpretation, as it depends on a number of factors: Location
Cables exposed in areas where there is potential for contact with people or objects (e.g., driveways, walkways, patios) are more likely to be considered subject to physical abuse.
Height
Cables that are low to the ground are more likely to be damaged by impact from lawnmowers, bicycles, or other items.
Protection
Cables that are covered or enclosed in some form of protection (e.g., conduit, raceways) are less likely to be considered subject to physical abuse.
Inspector's Reasoning
In the case you described, the inspector may have considered the following factors: Location of A/C Cable
The cable to the A/C unit was strapped to the siding and within a few feet of the ground, making it more accessible to potential impact or damage from landscaping activities.
Lack of Protection
The cable was not enclosed in any type of protection, further increasing its vulnerability to damage.
Proximity to SE Cable
The SE cable was not as exposed and may have been perceived as less likely to be impacted by the same potential hazards.
Inspector's Concerns
The inspector may have been extra cautious in this case due to the following: Potential Hazard
Even if the risk of physical abuse seemed minimal, the inspector may have erred on the side of caution to prevent any potential danger or liability.
Code Interpretation
Local building codes or interpretations may vary on the subject of physical abuse, and the inspector may have followed a stricter standard.
Best Practices
To prevent confusion or disputes in the future, it is important to follow best practices when installing electrical cables: Use Protection
Cables should be enclosed in conduit, raceways, or other approved forms of protection whenever possible.
Avoid Exposed Locations
Cables should be routed in areas where they are less likely to be exposed to potential hazards or damage.*
Be Consistent
Treat similar situations consistently to avoid any appearance of subjectivity.
Conclusion
While the concept of "subject to physical abuse" can be subjective, it is important to understand the factors that inspectors consider when making this determination. By following best practices and being aware of potential hazards, you can minimize the risk of having your installations flagged for code violations. Flag for review