Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 1296 errors in Informative Annex C (raceway fill) Tables C.1 through C.12

User: nercGerald, Location: Illinois

Asked on: Monday, February 7, 2011 at 11:55 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:14 am EDT

Question: For conductor sizes No. 14 to No. 8 for insulations THHW, THW, and THW-2 the fill tables are incorrect. These conductors should have the same fill numbers as TW since they have the same cross sectional areas as TW. This was confirmed by using a computer program that recalculates the fill based on areas from Tables 4, 5, 5A, and 8 located in Chapter 9 of the NEC. The program is the raceway and trough fill program from Code Calculators downloadable for free at:at:http://www.electriciancalculators.com/codecalc_3/publish.htmI have submitted the following proposal to change the 2011 NEC.For Informative Annex C, Tables C.1 to C.12 add THHW, THW, and THW-2 to the TW section for No. 14, No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8 and retain the fill numbers as shown for TW. Remove THHW, THW, and THW-2 from Sections for No. 14, No. 12, No. 10 and No. 8. Redo RHH*, RHW*, and RHW-2* into single section for No. 14, No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8 and retain fill numbers shown for these insulations.Substantiation:Table 310.104(A) shows dimensions of TW insulation thickness for No. 14, No. 12, No. 10 and No. 8 as equal to THHW, THW, and THW-2. Table 402.3 shows TW as having the same insulation thickness as XF and XFF for No. 14.Chapter 9 Table 5 page 716 bottom shows that TW has same area for No. 14 AWG as XF, XFF, THHW, THW, and THW-2. On Page 717 top Table 5 shows TW as having the same area as No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8 AWG as THHW, THW, and THW-2. However, the Tables in Annex C, C.1 to C.12, show the TW fill section separate from these insulations with different fill numbers. Either Table 5 is incorrect or the tables in Informational Annex C are incorrect. From the information in Tables 310.104(A) and 402.3 the areas shown in Table 5, Chapter 9 are correct but the fill sections for THHW, THW, THW-2 in Annex C Tables C.1 through C.12 are incorrect. Since THHW, THW, and THW-2 conductors have same cross sectional areas as TW for No. 14, No. 12, No. 10 and No. 8 they should be placed in the same category as TW. By moving insulations THHW, THW, and THW-2 to the TW section and regrouping RHH*, RHW*, and RHW-2* for sizes No. 14, No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8 this will correct the problem.It should also be noted that the present Tables C.1 to C.12 omits THW-2 for sizes No. 12 and No. 10, but Table 5 gives the area for these sizes and Table 310.104(A) lists these as valid sizes.

ProposalSubpart C - Wiring Methods and MaterialsSection 310Article 310.104 Conductor and Fixture Wires(A) General.

Insert the following sentence as the third sentence in the paragraph:> Conductors and fixture wires that have the same cross-sectional areas as TW for conductor sizes No. 14 to No. 8 shall have the same fill numbers as TW in Tables C.1 through C.12 of Informative Annex C.

Informative Annex CTable C.1List of Conductor Insulations> In the TW section, add THHW, THW, and THW-2 for sizes No. 14, No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8.

Table C.2 Freestanding Conductors> In the TW section, add THHW, THW, and THW-2 for sizes No. 14, No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8.> Remove THHW, THW, and THW-2 from the RHH, RHW, and RHW-2 section for sizes No. 14, No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8.> Combine the RHH, RHW, and RHW-2 sections for sizes No. 14, No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8 into a single section.

Tables C.3 through C.12> Repeat the changes described for Tables C.1 and C.2 for Tables C.3 through C.12.

Substantiation

The proposed changes correct an error in the 2011 NEC where the fill tables for conductor sizes No. 14 to No. 8 for insulations THHW, THW, and THW-2 are incorrect. These conductors should have the same fill numbers as TW since they have the same cross-sectional areas as TW. This has been confirmed by using a computer program that recalculates the fill based on areas from Tables 4, 5, 5A, and 8 located in Chapter 9 of the NEC. The program is the raceway and trough fill program from Code Calculators downloadable for free at:> http://www.electriciancalculators.com/codecalc_3/publish.htmTable 310.104(A) shows dimensions of TW insulation thickness for No. 14, No. 12, No. 10 and No. 8 as equal to THHW, THW, and THW-2. Table 402.3 shows TW as having the same insulation thickness as XF and XFF for No. 14. Chapter 9 Table 5 page 716 bottom shows that TW has same area for No. 14 AWG as XF, XFF, THHW, THW, and THW-2. On Page 717 top Table 5 shows TW as having the same area as No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8 AWG as THHW, THW, and THW-2. However, the Tables in Annex C, C.1 to C.12, show the TW fill section separate from these insulations with different fill numbers. Either Table 5 is incorrect or the tables in Informational Annex C are incorrect. From the information in Tables 310.104(A) and 402.3 the areas shown in Table 5, Chapter 9 are correct but the fill sections for THHW, THW, THW-2 in Annex C Tables C.1 through C.12 are incorrect. Since THHW, THW, and THW-2 conductors have same cross sectional areas as TW for No. 14, No. 12, No. 10 and No. 8 they should be placed in the same category as TW. By moving insulations THHW, THW, and THW-2 to the TW section and regrouping RHH, RHW, and RHW-2* for sizes No. 14, No. 12, No. 10, and No. 8 this will correct the problem.It should also be noted that the present Tables C.1 to C.12 omits THW-2 for sizes No. 12 and No. 10, but Table 5 gives the area for these sizes and Table 310.104(A) lists these as valid sizes. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question