User: philly, Location: DC area
Asked on: Wednesday, February 9, 2011 at 3:28 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:22 am EDT
Question: Why on a Time Coordination Curve (TCC) the cable damage curves are not a continuous line. They always start at the high current value and then go to about midway through the plot before they stop. Then at the top of the plot at the highest time the pickup of full load rating of the cable is shown as a small mark. Why are these not shown as a continuous line?When plotting protective devices against these cable damage curves must you have both segments of the cable damge curve above or to the righ of the protective device curve? Should the protective device curve even be below the cable damge curve pickup point? I'm referring to breakers upstream of the cable, but how do downstream breakers come into play?Also on a slightly different subject does the transformer inrush point shown of on a TCC need to be completely clear of a LV breaker tolerence bandwidth. What if the inrush point is not completely below the LV breaker band but rather falls righ in the middle of the band? Is this a potential problem?
Time Coordination Curve (TCC) Cable Damage Curves
Cable damage curves on a TCC are not continuous lines because they represent two different types of damage: Continuous Cable Damage
High current and long duration, which causes gradual insulation degradation and eventual failure.
Impulse Cable Damage
High current and short duration, which may shock the cable and cause immediate insulation breakdown.The plotted curve shows the threshold for continuous damage (starting at the high current value) and the threshold for impulse damage (midway through the plot). The mark at the top of the plot represents the ability of the cable to withstand full load current for an extended period.
Protective Device Curves Relative to Cable Damage Curves
Protective device curves should be above and to the right of both segments of the cable damage curve for both upstream and downstream breakers. This ensures that the protective device will trip before the cable is damaged.
Transformer Inrush Point and LV Breaker Tolerance Bandwidth
The transformer inrush point should be completely clear of the LV breaker tolerance bandwidth. If the inrush point falls within the bandwidth, it may not be possible for the breaker to trip quickly enough to prevent damage to the breaker or other equipment.
Downstream Breakers
Downstream breakers should also have their curves above and to the right of the cable damage curves. However, the downstream breaker curve may be below the pickup point of the cable damage curve if the downstream breaker is intended to provide backup protection for the upstream breaker. In this case, the upstream breaker should still be the primary protective device. Flag for review