Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: VFD Emergency Stop Fail Safe requirements

User: Nomadic, Location: Big Easy

Asked on: Wednesday, February 9, 2011 at 4:00 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:22 am EDT

Question: Is there a requirement that all Emergency Stop's be integrated in logic in a fail safe (N.C.) manner?I looked in NFPA 79 and couldnt find anything of the sort. I have a situation where local and remote E-Stops are incorporated N.O in parallel along with other "alarms" which generate a common VFD Fail alarm. The Fail in turn kills the VFD start circuit.Thoughts?

NFPA 79

NFPA 79 does not explicitly require that all emergency stop (E-Stop) devices be integrated into logic in a fail-safe (N.C.) manner. However, it does provide guidance on the design and implementation of E-Stop systems.

Guidance in NFPA 79 Section 7.4.
1.1

Requires E-Stop devices to be "designed and installed so that all potential hazardous conditions are stopped or prevented when actuated."


Section 7.4.
1.3

States that E-Stop devices should be "positive-acting, mechanically latched, and self-resetting."*

Section 7.4.
1.4

Requires that E-Stop devices be "fail-safe."

Interpretation


While NFPA 79 does not specifically require N.C. logic for E-Stop devices, the guidance provided suggests that N.C. logic would be a more fail-safe design. A N.C. circuit ensures that the E-Stop system will activate even in the event of a wire break or other failure. This is because a break in the circuit will open the N.C. contacts, causing the E-Stop system to engage.

Your Situation

In your case, the local and remote E-Stops are incorporated N.O. in parallel with other "alarms" that generate a common VFD Fail alarm. This design may not be as fail-safe as a N.C. logic design. If a wire break occurs in the N.O. circuit, the E-Stop system may not activate, resulting in a hazardous condition.

Recommendation

It is recommended to review the design of your E-Stop system with a qualified electrician or engineer. They can assess the risks and determine if a N.C. logic design would be more appropriate in your situation. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question