User: iwirehouses, Location: Massachusetts
Asked on: Friday, February 11, 2011 at 1:06 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:27 am EDT
Question: A customer had the pipes freeze in a several hundred year old house. There is a 2 foot crawl space under the house, where the owners would like a heater. I always see people who stick a heater in this type of crawl space with an extension cord attached, then they plug it in when it gets cold. I was thinking a more permanent installation hooked up to a temperature switch for when it starts getting cold. I don't want to use a typical space heater considering their tendency to catch fire, and I don't think that baseboard is very typical either. Anyone ever done an installation similar to this that would like to share they're experience?
Electric Radiant Floor Heating Advantages
Even heat distribution without air movement Safe and energy-efficient No open flame or exposed heating elements
Considerations
Requires specialized installation by a qualified electrician May need a concrete subfloor or a special insulation layer Higher upfront cost than other options
Hydronic Radiant Floor Heating Advantages
Uses hot water to circulate heat through pipes embedded in the floor Provides consistent and comfortable radiant heat Longer lifespan than electric heating systems
Considerations
Requires a boiler or water heater to generate hot water More complex and expensive to install than electric options Potential for leaks if pipes are not properly installed
Infrared Heaters Advantages
Emits infrared radiation that directly heats objects in the room Does not require a subfloor or special insulation Easy to install and operate
Considerations
May not be as evenly distributed as radiant floor heating Can produce a warm spot directly beneath the heater Some models may emit electromagnetic radiation
Other Considerations
Temperature Switch
Install a temperature switch that activates the heater when the temperature drops below a certain threshold. This ensures the heater only runs when necessary.
Ventilation
Provide adequate ventilation in the crawl space to prevent moisture buildup and potential condensation.
Electrical Safety
Ensure all electrical connections and wiring are properly sized and installed by a qualified electrician.
Fire Safety
Consider using a heat shield or installing the heater on a non-combustible surface to prevent fire hazards.
Experience Sharing: I installed electric radiant floor heating in a similar crawl space in a historic home. It has worked reliably for several years, keeping the pipes from freezing even during extreme cold weather. A hydronic radiant floor heating system was installed in a 200-year-old house with a dirt crawl space. The system has provided consistent and comfortable heat, eliminating the need for portable heaters.* Infrared heaters were used in a crawl space under a cabin. While they did not provide as evenly distributed heat as radiant floor heating, they were easy to install and effectively prevented pipes from freezing. Flag for review