User: edgarp, Location: East Tennessee
Asked on: Friday, February 11, 2011 at 8:42 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:28 am EDT
Question: We have a weird situation that has us scratching our heads...sorry for the long post and I hope I don't leave anything out.System: Two 40 hp belt driven fan motors. Each motor has a normal and an emergency supply. Motor #1 starts and runs fine on both feeds - no problems at all.Normal supply is about 30 feet from transformer. Emergency supply is from 600 feet away, but voltage drop doesn't appear to be a factor. A manual transfer switch changes from normal to emergency - double throw, 3 pole, 600V, 100A non-fusible.On emergency power, motor #2 starts and runs every time. On normal, it starts every other time. The MCP (Cutler Hammer HMCP100R3) trips every other time, and once it is reset, the motor will start. Settings on the MCP have been adjusted up with no change - currently set at 600A. Everything in the combination starter is common to both feeds from the XFR switch.We online (Baker) tested the motor with normal results, same on both feeds. MCP has been replaced. The guts of the manual transfer switch have been replaced with no change. Both motors start and run with same current and acceleration time, and voltage is within 5 volts on either supply. The power quality appears to be fine, tested with Fluke equipment.All branch wiring has been meggered with good results. At one point the motor was reconnected for the wrong rotation and it started every time. That shouldn't significantly affect inrush, just running current I thought.Every time we come up with an idea, it just doesn't add up since the motor starts and runs every time on one feed, and every other time on the other. Once the motor is running, it runs perfectly, just as motor #1 does. If we had a fault somewhere we believe tripping would be more random, but I have seen multiple starts and it is a definite pattern of every other time.Has anyone ever seen anything like this? We believe the combination start is ok because it is common to both feeds, and we believe the motor is fine, as well as the transfer switch. Between engineers and electricians we have tons of experience, but like I said we are scratching our heads.
Troubleshooting Steps
1. Isolate the Motor
Disconnect motor #2 from the combination starter and test it directly on both feeds. This will help determine if the issue lies within the motor or its wiring.
2. Check Feed Continuity
Use a continuity tester to verify that both feeds are functioning correctly. Ensure that there are no loose connections or intermittent faults in the wiring.
3. Inspect the Transfer Switch
Thoroughly inspect the transfer switch for any signs of damage or wear. Check the contacts and terminals for proper connections and tightness.
4. Review MCP Settings
Verify that the MCP settings are appropriate for the motor's current draw. Consider reducing the trip threshold slightly to reduce false tripping on the affected feed.
5. Analyze Branch Wiring
Use a high-resolution insulation tester (such as a Megger) to conduct a more detailed analysis of the branch wiring. This can reveal insulation defects or other issues that may not be apparent with a standard megger test.
6. Monitor Power Quality
Use a power analyzer to continuously monitor the power quality on both feeds. Look for any anomalies or fluctuations that could affect the motor's starting performance.
7. Consider System Harmonics
Use a harmonic analyzer to check for excessive harmonics on the system. Harmonics can cause problems with motor starting, especially on low-voltage feeds.
8. Check for Resonance
If the branch wiring length is significant, consider the possibility of resonance. This can occur when the natural frequency of the wiring matches the motor's starting frequency, leading to excessive voltage spikes.
Additional Considerations: It's worth noting that the motor starting every time on the wrong rotation suggests a possible fault in the branch wiring or connection. Review the wiring diagrams carefully to ensure that the motor is correctly connected and that the control circuits are functioning as intended.* Consult with a qualified motor repair technician for their assessment if the issue persists. Flag for review