User: chriskthx, Location: DC area
Asked on: Friday, February 11, 2011 at 4:43 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:29 am EDT
Question: I'm curious which voltage drop formula you all use for standard roadway lighting or other circuits. I have come across three and all offer slightly different results (based on the complexity of the formula). My local resources show to use #1 as the default formula, however I have seen #2 and #3 used elsewhere.1) The simple VD = 2 x K x I x D/CM2) The IEEE Formula http://www.dolphins-software.com/voltageDrop.htm3) The NEC Formula found in table 9.
1) Simple Voltage Drop Formula
VD = 2 x K x I x D/CMWhere: VD = Voltage drop (in volts) K = Circular-mil-to-distance conversion factor (3.05 x 10^-6) I = Current (in amperes) D = Distance (in feet) CM = Circular mils
Advantages
Simplest formula Useful for quick approximations
Disadvantages
Does not account for all factors that can affect voltage drop Not as accurate as more complex formulas
2) IEEE Formula
This formula is more complex and takes into account additional factors such as conductor temperature, frequency, and material resistivity. It can be found on the website you provided (http://www.dolphins-software.com/voltageDrop.htm).
Advantages
More accurate than the simple formula Considers additional factors that can affect voltage drop
Disadvantages
More complex to use Requires more information than the simple formula
3) NEC Formula
The NEC formula is found in Table 9 of the National Electrical Code (NEC) and is intended for use with copper conductors. It is similar to the simple formula but uses different values for the circular-mil-to-distance conversion factor (K) and the distance unit (D).
Advantages
Provides a standard formula for voltage drop calculations in the NEC Easy to use
Disadvantages
Not as accurate as the IEEE formula* May not be applicable to non-copper conductors
Which Formula to Use?
The choice of which formula to use depends on the required accuracy and the available information. For quick approximations or when accuracy is not critical, the simple formula (#1) can be used. For more accurate calculations, the IEEE formula (#2) or the NEC formula (#3) is recommended. Flag for review