User: hockeyoligist2, Location: close to greenville sc
Asked on: Friday, February 11, 2011 at 5:41 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:29 am EDT
Question: Two identical 460v sewer grit pumps. They both have had the wire short to ground and/or burn one wire in two inside the concrete enclosed conduit several times since they went online a year ago. The original contractor has replaced it under warranty and it is good for a while, then we get a call that it is tripping.Every time I or one of the other electricians get there we find that it is shorted or lost a leg. Hook up temp wires, everything is good. Last week I got the dreaded call, checked no power on one wire. Hook up our temps again, everything good. Next day the other one lost a leg. Temped it.Got the call again today, temps still connected, I checked for shorts, power, and motor, everything good. Turned it on and it tripped immediately. Went downstairs to check the motor again and it was running without power and was cold! Pulled the disconnect and it was still turning. I could hear water coming through the pipes. It throttled down and stopped.I traced out the pipes and found a backwash valve that clears the lines after it shuts down to prevent the lines and pump from stopping up with grit. It is controlled separately by the plants computer system. The computer system gets a signal from another valve telling it that it is closed, then it purges the pipes. We don't have very good control drawings, so we never knew it was there.The pumps cycle every 4 1/2 minutes, the PC was telling it to purge for 3 minutes. The valve takes about 1 1/2 minutes to close, so the pump is still spinning backwards when it tries to restart! I changed the PC timer to 2 minutes which is more than needed to purge.I'm guessing that the wire is the weakest link and it eventually breaks down. Sound reasonable?
Yes, it is reasonable to assume that the wire is the weakest link and is eventually breaking down due to the following reasons: Mechanical Stress
The wire is likely running through a concrete enclosed conduit, which can subject it to mechanical stress and damage. The constant cycling of the pumps and the associated vibrations may further aggravate this stress.
Electrical Stress
The repeated shorting to ground and burning of one wire indicate significant electrical stress on the system. This could be caused by insulation breakdown, loose connections, or other electrical faults.*
Environmental Factors: The concrete conduit and the presence of moisture may create a corrosive environment that can deteriorate the wire insulation.When the pump motor is running backwards due to the backwash valve operation, it generates counter-electromotive force (CEMF) that opposes the incoming power. This CEMF can stress the wire insulation and potentially cause a breakdown or short.The fact that the pump is still running without power and is cold suggests that the motor is being driven by the incoming water flow. This indicates that the water backwash is creating a current that is sufficient to keep the motor spinning.By adjusting the PC timer to reduce the purge time, you have effectively allowed the valve to close fully before the pump restarts. This eliminates the backward rotation and its associated electrical stress on the system.Overall, it is likely that the wire is experiencing excessive mechanical, electrical, and environmental stress, which is leading to its failure. Replacing the wire with a more robust and durable option may help mitigate the issue. Flag for review