User: anbm, Location: Tennessee
Asked on: Friday, February 11, 2011 at 5:45 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:29 am EDT
Question: 112.5kVA transformer 480Vdelta primary - 208Y/120V secondary.We used to put 175A/3P breaker in the panel that feeds this transfomer.Square-D recently issues a document and states that we have to use 250A/3P breaker to protect this xfmr instead of 175A/3P, they said because 175A/3P won't help transformer inrush current. This doesn't make much sense to me:1. Never heard a xfmr can have inrush current, most of time we won't have motor load fed out of this type of xfmr, typical load shall be receptacle and lighting or small equipment.2. If we increase primary CB from 175A to 250A as recommended, we may need to increase primary wire size to comply with NEC.3. We may run into coordination issue between 250A breaker and its upstream breaker instead of 175A CB.4. Not sure if other manufacturers have similar approach?Anyone has any experiences with this matter? Thanks!
Understanding Transformer Inrush Current
Transformers can indeed experience inrush current when energized. This is a transient surge of current that occurs for a short duration (typically a few cycles) when the transformer is first connected to the power source. The inrush current is caused by the magnetization of the transformer core.
Impact of Primary Breaker Rating
The primary breaker is responsible for protecting the transformer from overcurrent conditions, including inrush current. A breaker that is rated too low may not be able to handle the inrush current and could trip unnecessarily.
Square-D's Recommendation
Square-D's recommendation to use a 250A/3P breaker for this transformer is likely based on their analysis of the transformer's inrush current characteristics. They may have determined that a 175A/3P breaker is insufficient to protect the transformer under certain operating conditions.
Concerns Raised
Your concerns are valid:1. Inrush current on a non-motor load
While typical loads like receptacles and lighting may not have significant inrush currents, it's possible that there could be some small motors or other devices that contribute to the inrush.2.
Increased primary wire size
If the primary breaker is increased to 250A, the primary wire size may need to be increased to comply with NEC requirements. This could add additional cost and complexity.3.
Coordination issues
Increasing the primary breaker from 175A to 250A may create coordination issues with the upstream breaker. This could result in unwanted tripping of the upstream breaker during inrush conditions.4.
Other manufacturer's approach
It's possible that other manufacturers may have different recommendations for transformer inrush current protection.
Recommendation
Given these concerns, it's advisable to consult with a qualified electrician or engineer to assess the specific application and determine the appropriate primary breaker rating. They can perform calculations to estimate the transformer's inrush current and make informed recommendations based on the findings.
Additional Considerations Consider using a breaker with adjustable trip settings to provide flexibility in setting the trip current to accommodate transformer inrush characteristics. Explore the use of inrush current limiting devices, such as fuses or surge suppressors, to mitigate the impact of inrush current on the primary breaker.* Coordinate with the equipment manufacturer to obtain specific data on the transformer's inrush current rating. Flag for review