User: Mr 3phase, Location: California
Asked on: Saturday, February 12, 2011 at 12:03 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:31 am EDT
Question: I have seen a lot, but never this...I was at a house on Friday and the customer told me that one of the stair way lights (there are two) on a three way switch was not working. The light fixture at the top of the stairs had been removed. I looked at the light switch and this is where the 'mystery' begins. The 'switches' are push buttons, two of them on one yoke, both of them are three way in design. One is locate at the bottom of the stairs, the other at the top. The one at the top of the stairs has a single wire going from the 'point' on the three way on the 'top' of the yoke, to the light fixture that is removed. Just a single wire. The other two wires go some where (did not get too deep into it as I was short on time). The 'bottom' three way (bottom of yoke ), has a knob and tube three wire attached to the three screws. The switch at the bottom of the steps works the light at the bottom of the stairs but not the top. The switch at the top of the stairs works the light at the bottom of the stairs but not the top. I have to go back there on Monday. What the heck is this and how does it work?
The situation you described is unusual and can be confusing. However, here's a possible explanation of how it works and what could be causing the malfunction
Wiring Configuration:
The push-button switch at the top of the stairs is likely a two-wire switch, with one wire going to the light fixture and the other wire being the traveler wire. The switch at the bottom of the stairs is a three-wire switch with the knob and tube wiring connected to the traveler, common, and neutral terminals. The common terminal of the bottom switch is connected to the neutral wire from the knob and tube wiring. The traveler terminals of both switches are connected together.
Operation
When you press the top push-button, it completes the circuit between the traveler and a terminal on the light fixture, turning on the light at the bottom of the stairs. When you press the bottom switch, it completes the circuit between the traveler and the common terminal, connecting it to the neutral wire and turning on the light at the bottom of the stairs.
Malfunction
The issue with the top light fixture not working could be due to several reasons: The light fixture itself may be faulty or have a loose connection. The single wire connecting the switch to the fixture may be broken or disconnected. There could be a problem with the traveler wire connection between the two switches.
Troubleshooting
Start by checking the light fixture for any loose connections or damage. Test the single wire connecting the top switch to the fixture with a voltage tester to verify continuity. Inspect the traveler wire connection between the two switches and ensure it's secure. Use a voltage tester to check for power at the top switch and the traveler wire to determine where the problem lies.
Possible Solutions: Replace the faulty light fixture. Repair or replace the single wire connecting the top switch to the fixture.* Tighten or reconnect the traveler wire connection between the two switches. Flag for review