Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: series rated vs fully rated

User: lectrified, Location: Tennessee

Asked on: Saturday, February 12, 2011 at 2:26 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:31 am EDT

Question: I need to replace a service to a machine shop. This shop has 3phase 240volt delta. ungrounded. I would like some input on series rated vs fully rated. keep in mind this is only a 200amp service. with an aic rating of 24100. Im also installing a 400amp main with a 200amp rating plug for future upgrade. biggest motor load is 100amps.

Fully Rated vs. Series Rated BreakersFully Rated Breakers

Designed to carry their full rated current indefinitely. More robust and reliable under extreme conditions, such as high temperatures and sustained overloads. Usually more expensive than series rated breakers.

Series Rated Breakers

Rated for a specific current when used in a specific combination with other series rated components, such as fuses or other breakers. Less expensive than fully rated breakers. May have reduced performance under extreme conditions due to the reliance on other components in the circuit.

For a 200amp Service


Given the relatively small size of the service and the absence of a grounding connection, a series rated breaker would likely be sufficient. Here's the reasoning: The biggest motor load is only 100amps, leaving significant headroom for future expansion. The AIC rating of 24100 is high enough to withstand a potential short-circuit event. The 400amp main with a 200amp rating plug provides future upgradeability without requiring a major service change.

Recommendation

Consider installing a 200amp series rated breaker. This option provides cost savings without compromising safety or reliability for the current load and future expansion plans.

Additional Considerations
To maintain the ungrounded nature of the system, ensure that all neutrals are isolated from ground. Install surge protection devices to protect the equipment from transient voltage spikes. Regularly inspect and maintain the electrical system to ensure its continued proper operation. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question