Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: megging pump/motor- Bad call for repair?

User: jimbo123, Location: NE (9.06 miles @5.9 Degrees from Winged Horses)

Asked on: Sunday, February 13, 2011 at 8:07 am EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:31 am EDT

Question: We removed a sump pump motor from a pit to check because of tripping the cb Motor has been in service for about a year now, cycles every 20 minutes or so , 5 days a week , 8 hrs a day.We checked the motor and found the cable attached to the control box to the motor was damaged . It appeared cable were nicked near the pump inside the pit.We removed all but 4' of cable to test motor winding before sending it out for repair.We used a fluke 1587 to test motor. We megged motor and got a reading of .4 megs . Also found continuity from winding leads to egc and case of motor .Outside shop reported empeller was eaten away but windings were ok. We also compaired our reading to the alternate pump in same pit . Motor had a reading of over 1 gig. Both are 7.5 hp 480v. Where did we go wrong with our call ?

Possible Reasons for the Discrepancy



1. Test Conditions

Ensure that both motors were tested under the same conditions, such as temperature and humidity. Variations in conditions can affect megger readings.

2. Cable Length and Connections

The shorter cable length used for your test (4') could have introduced additional resistance, reducing the megger reading. The connections between the megger and the motor windings should be clean and secure. Loose connections can also affect the reading.

3. Megger Readings

The megger reading you obtained (0.4 megohms) is not necessarily indicative of a faulty motor. Insulation resistance readings can vary depending on the motor type and operating conditions. A more conclusive test would be to perform a polarization index (PI) test or an insulation resistance test over time. These tests provide a more accurate assessment of insulation integrity.

4. Motor Condition

The outside shop reported that the impeller was eaten away, which suggests that the motor may have been subjected to harsh conditions or was not properly maintained. This could have contributed to reduced insulation resistance and the continuity you observed between the winding leads and the ground and case.

5. Fluke 1587

The Fluke 1587 is a reliable megger, but it has a limited range of insulation resistance measurements (up to 200 megohms). For higher resistance measurements, such as in the case of the comparison motor, a different megger with a wider range may be required.

Recommendation:
Perform additional tests, such as a PI test or a time-based insulation resistance test, to confirm the condition of the motor. Consult with a qualified motor repair specialist to assess the motor's overall condition and determine if it can be safely repaired or should be replaced. Consider using a megger with a wider range of insulation resistance measurements for future tests. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question