Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Foreign systems

User: gaelectric, Location: Highlands Ranch, CO

Asked on: Monday, February 14, 2011 at 2:13 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:34 am EDT

Question: I have an inspector that cites 110.26 for an area above a sub-panel in a mechanical room in a residential basement finish.There is a 1/2" water pipe that runs across the ceiling fastened to the floor joists. There is also a furnace flue that is in the dedicated space as well. We kept all of the combustible material clear of that.Now i'm confused as to the way the code reads on 110.26F(1)a and b.(PHP:

NEC Section 110.26(F)(1)(a) and (b)(F) Spaces Above Electrical Equipment.(1) Within Reach from Grade or Working Space.(a) The space above electrical equipment that may need examination, adjustment, servicing, or maintenance while energized shall be accessible by fixed means. Where necessary to provide access, a ladder shall be provided.(b) Where the equipment is in a room or enclosure where the only access is through a doorway, the doorway shall comply with 110.26(F)(1)(a).

Inspector's Interpretation

The inspector is likely citing this code section because the space above the sub-panel in the mechanical room is not accessible by fixed means, such as a ladder. This means that if an electrician needs to service or maintain the sub-panel while it is energized, they would need to use a portable ladder or other unsafe means to access the space.

Contractor's Argument

The contractor may argue that the space above the sub-panel does not need to be accessible because there are no combustible materials present and the furnace flue and water pipe are not considered to be electrical equipment. However, the code section does not make any exceptions for these types of situations.

Possible Solutions

To comply with the code, the contractor could install a fixed ladder or other means of access to the space above the sub-panel. Alternatively, they could relocate the sub-panel to a location where it would be accessible without the need for additional access means. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question