Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: breaker trip investigation

User: mshields, Location: Boston, MA

Asked on: Monday, February 14, 2011 at 6:02 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:35 am EDT

Question: A client of ours had a 4000A Insulated Case, 4000A circuit breaker trip for no apparent reason. The square D equipment is only 10 years old. The client's maintenance guy reset the breaker without looking to see what target it tripped on (this is now lost to eternity and I did check with the vendor). We did a quick coordination study of the board. i.e. just wanted to show that the feeders (all of which have ground fault), coordintated properly - and they do.And I'm wondering what else I can do. Injection testing of the 4000A breaker is one thing I suppose to make sure it's functioning per spec. But what if anything after that.Now, this is Surgery building in a hospital. If it was anything else, I'd say, call me if it happens again and this time make a note of the trip targets (not that would narrow it down much - I'm assuming it's a GF anyway). But because of the nature of the facility, I don't want to leave any stone unturned. Any suggestions?Thanks,Mike

Additional Troubleshooting Steps



Review Maintenance Records

Check for any recent maintenance or testing performed on the breaker or associated equipment that could have inadvertently caused the trip.


Inspect Circuitry

Examine the circuit wiring and connections to ensure they are secure and have not been disturbed in any way.

Measure Line Voltage

Verify that the line voltage is within acceptable limits.


Load Profile Review

Check the electrical load on the circuit to determine if there has been any significant increase or fluctuation that could have contributed to the trip.

GF Testing

Perform ground fault testing on the circuit, especially on any equipment that may have come into contact with water or other conductive materials.

Additional Measures to Consider



Install a Fault Recorder

A fault recorder can capture data during a fault event, providing more information about the tripping targets and root cause.

Establish a Regular Maintenance Schedule

Include periodic testing and inspection of the 4000A breaker and associated equipment to ensure proper operation.


Review Manufacturer Specifications

Consult with the manufacturer of the breaker to obtain detailed specifications, troubleshooting procedures, and any known potential issues related to the equipment.

Extend Coordination Study

Expand the coordination study to include the upstream breakers and transformers to verify the overall system coordination.


Consider Arc Flash Hazard Mitigation

Assess the potential for arc flash hazards in the event of a fault and implement appropriate mitigation measures, such as arc flash relays or protective personal equipment.

Communication with the Client:
Emphasize the importance of recording trip target information in the future to aid in troubleshooting. Explain the additional troubleshooting steps taken and the rationale behind them. Provide recommendations for ongoing maintenance and monitoring strategies to enhance system reliability and safety. Assure the client that all reasonable measures have been taken to identify and mitigate potential risks. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question