Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: 409.110 Opinions Sought

User: eric9822, Location: Camarillo, CA

Asked on: Monday, February 14, 2011 at 10:28 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:35 am EDT

Question: We are in the early stages of a turnkey industrial control system replacement project. The vendor is supplying all the I/O enclosures and is building them to comply with UL 508A. They have asked us if we need to actually have them listed and "stickered" because they did not plan on supplying drawings as required, only termination lists. Our initial thought was maybe not since our AHJ does not typically require UL listing for this sort of thing as long as the components are UL listed. While researching the issue I also re-read 409.110 which states (amongst other things):409.110 Marking. An industrial control panel shall bemarked with the following information that is plainly visibleafter installation:(5) Electrical wiring diagram or the number of the index tothe electrical drawings showing the electrical wiringdiagram.At that point I said UL508A "stickering" may not be required but since you need to supply drawings anyway and you are building them in a UL panel shop you might as well apply the stickers. The vendor replied they have no plans to provide drawings and the electrical termination lists are equivalent. I disagree since the code does not state drawings or equivalent. Am I seeing this correctly?

Yes, you are seeing this correctly.

UL 508A Listing

UL 508A requires that industrial control panels be listed by Underwriters Laboratories (UL) and bear the UL mark. This listing ensures that the panel meets the requirements of the standard, which includes having a proper electrical wiring diagram.409.110 Marking

NEC 409.110 requires that industrial control panels be marked with the following information:* Electrical wiring diagram or the number of the index to the electrical drawings showing the electrical wiring diagramVendor's Response

The vendor's argument that electrical termination lists are equivalent to drawings is incorrect. While termination lists provide information about the wiring connections, they do not provide a complete electrical wiring diagram that shows the overall layout and functionality of the panel.

Conclusion

You are correct in stating that the vendor must provide electrical wiring diagrams or drawings, as required by NEC 409.110. While UL 508A listing may not be explicitly required by your AHJ, it is strongly recommended as a way to ensure the safety and reliability of the panel. By requiring UL 508A listing and electrical drawings, you are protecting your facility and personnel from potential hazards. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question