Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Grounding dilema ! ground wire required or not ?

User: delta4u, Location: 3 Hr 2 Min from Winged Horses

Asked on: Wednesday, February 16, 2011 at 6:42 pm EST
Answered on: Tuesday, May 14, 2024 at 1:40 am EDT

Question: I have installed in dozens of mobile home parks, Distribution transformers primary 1ph 480 volt to 1ph 120/240 volt 167 kva in all instances except a few the inspecting body has been Ca HCD. A typical install is usually running a 2" sch 40 pvc pipe from the main panel underground to the unit substation using parallel 4/0 copper (no equipment ground wire) on a 350 amp breaker.at the transformer we always drive a 10 ft solid copper ground rod and have never had any problems. Now we have installed one in a community thats under a cities jurisdiction and they are insisting it needs an equipment ground wire even though we have installed 50 or 60 of these exactly like this. I always figured this is a seperatly derived power source under article 250 and a ground rod is sufficient. Problem is i do not have room for a ground wire and have ran over 300 ft of underground pipe !!!

NEC Requirements for Separately Derived Systems

According to NEC Article 250.30(A)(2), separately derived systems must have an equipment grounding means installed in accordance with NEC Article 250.
58.

Equipment Grounding Wire

NEC Article 250.58 requires an equipment grounding wire to be installed in the same raceway or cable as the circuit conductors. The equipment grounding wire must be sized according to Table 250.
122.

Grounding Rod

While a grounding rod may provide a path to earth, it is not considered an acceptable grounding means for separately derived systems. NEC Article 250.58 specifically requires an equipment grounding wire.

Your Situation

In your case, the inspecting body (city jurisdiction) is correct in requiring an equipment grounding wire. The distribution transformer is a separately derived system, and an equipment grounding wire is necessary for safety.

Options

You have two options:1. Install an Equipment Grounding Wire

Run a separate 4/0 copper equipment grounding wire in the underground pipe to the unit substation.2.

Change the Circuit Breaker

Replace the existing 350 amp breaker with a 167 amp breaker. According to NEC Table 250.122, a 4/0 copper equipment grounding wire is only required for circuit breakers rated 300 amps or greater. By reducing the breaker size, you may be able to eliminate the need for an equipment grounding wire.

Note:
Always consult with the local inspecting body for specific requirements and guidance. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question